In some respects, the ‘clues’ to reading this work come at the end. In the afterword and acknowledgments, the reader learns a number of important things about the relationship between the author and his subject, Zhores Alferov, the joint last Russian winner of the Nobel Prize for Physics (2000): first of all, further confirmation that Josephson has known Alferov ‘for over 20 years’ (pp. 11, 268) and, second, that ‘Zhores has read every chapter’ (p. 268). Long before reaching the end of the book, this reviewer was suspicious of the level of detachment between author and subject: given the men's long-term relationship, could the author still make serious criticism of his subject? Indeed, there is only one direct criticism made of Alferov – that the latter's ‘efforts to paint himself as somehow representing reform obscures the fact that he was a member of the establishment’ (p. 198) – and this would seem to lend support to the fear that this biography would have been substantially stronger if the distance between author and subject had been greater.
Composed of six chapters and a number of subsections, the book examines Alferov's life and times, from his birth in pre-Second World War Belarus, spending the war years in some comfort in the Urals, student days in Leningrad (in particular at the Leningrad Electro-Technical Institute and the Leningrad Physical-Technical Institute, which he was later to head), to his scientific work in developing semiconductors and, most importantly of all, heterostructures (the achievement for which he was to jointly win the Nobel Prize for Physics).
His subsequent political career, begun under Gorbachev in 1989, when he was elected to the Congress of People's Deputies, to his current position as a member of the Communist faction of deputies in the current Russian parliament, is also detailed. Regardless of Alferov's apolitical stance in the past, science is now a political battleground and, as a vice-president of the Russian Academy of Sciences and a man who sees it as his ‘mission’ to protect science in Russia (pp. 12–13), he has become a controversial figure in Russian science politics, seeking to minimize the influence of ‘myopic’ bureaucrats in the running of the Russian Academy of Sciences (p. 242).
Alferov's most recent appointment in April 2010, as ‘scientific leader’ of the country's ‘innovation centre’ at Skolkovo, is proof of the man's continuing importance in shaping Russia's scientific future. However, given his previous outspoken criticism of contemporary Russian scientific policy, particularly following his Nobel Prize win in 2000, it might be wondered whether this appointment should be seen as a double-edged sword: given his advancing years (he was born in 1930), it could be interpreted as a cynical attempt to keep him busy, so as to reduce his efforts at thwarting the attempts of others to downgrade the role of the Russian Academy of Sciences in the direction of scientific research in Russia.
The book set itself a large goal: ‘to give the reader a sense of both Alferov's life and of Soviet and Russian science generally, hoping to contribute to our understanding of big science, politics and the modern state before, during and after the Cold War’ (p. 5). Thus the book is simply not just about the life and career of one of Russia's most prominent physicists, but also a ‘biography’ of Soviet/Russian science throughout the twentieth century, as well as in the first decade of the twenty-first. For good measure, a large part of the book also examines various aspects of Soviet/Russian history and Soviet/Russian culture. Arguably, much of this could have been placed in footnotes or endnotes, thereby avoiding burdening the body of the book with extraneous detail.
The book would have been better served if the author had used more direct quotation, whether from Alferov's writings and speeches or from any of the interviews conducted between author and subject over the years. The first quotation of Alferov – on scientific cooperation – does not appear until two-thirds into the book (p. 188). Surely it would have been a comparatively easy task to replace a few of the ‘he believes’, ‘he claims’, ‘he asserts’ with ‘he states’, ‘he wrote’ and direct quotation of Alferov, allowing the reader a deeper insight into the man himself?
The book is particularly strong in examining the motives behind Alferov's current stance on science and education policy, as well as his sense of debt to the former USSR. Bearing in mind that he lost his only brother in the war in 1944, Zhores Alferov has become a staunch defender of the Soviet system:
some of the unassailable feelings he has about the Soviet system originated in deep patriotism that developed during … the life-and-death struggle against fascism and in the sacrifice of his brother … the loss of his brother, the postwar rebuilding effort, entry into higher education, the death of Stalin – all of these things shaped Alferov's views about the crucial place of education, science and technology in protecting the Motherland (pp. 59–60).
Thus it comes as no surprise to learn that Alferov remained a member of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union up until the collapse of the USSR in 1991 and is a member of the Communist faction of deputies in the Russian parliament, believing that only the Communist faction in the current Russian parliament shares not only his views concerning the necessity of regaining the scientific status of the former USSR but also his views about ensuring science's revival in the years ahead. This will be no mean task. As the book points out, politically speaking Alferov does not enjoy a particularly cordial relationship with either of the two men on Russia's political ‘tandem’, Putin and Medvedev. In the ongoing power struggle – well and interestingly described here – between the Kremlin and Alferov over the eventual fate of the Russian Academy of Sciences, it remains to be seen whether Alferov's lasting achievement lies less in the scientific/research arena and more in the arena of science administration/education.
