Joel Schechter's Eighteenth-Century Brechtians: Theatrical Satire in the Age of Walpole aims to locate an epic theatre that may have existed before Brecht articulated its definition in the twentieth century. Schechter is wise to seek this model in the comic plays of 1700s England. With figures such as Jonathan Swift, Henry Fielding, David Garrick, and others, there are plenty of politically minded, theatrically experimental, and boundary-breaking artists from whom to choose. This period also demonstrates the rapid growth of a capitalist state driven by trade and commerce. The expansion of mercantilism, the boom of the middle class, and the rise of parliamentary figures such as Robert Walpole coalesce to make eighteenth-century England a veritable wellspring of the political, social, and economic structures that Brecht later would critique and seek to dismantle.
Schechter's definition of proto-Brechtians is stated most succinctly about midway through the book when he describes “practitioners of oppositional theatre who defy entrenched artistic and political states through their playwriting” (110). With this definition informing the subtext of his analysis, Schechter defines the eighteenth-century playwrights as not only Brecht's precursors but his collaborators, both in a literal and a figurative sense. Brecht staged adaptations of two plays from the period: John Gay's The Beggar's Opera (1728) and George Farquhar's The Recruiting Officer (1706). By looking at collaborations more broadly, seeking ideological and aesthetic partners in the past, and casting several theatrical artists in the eighteenth century as Brecht avant la lettre, Schechter's approach proves illuminating. He paints a picture of a vibrant theatrical climate, filled with metacommentary, political activism, cross-dressing, and satire aimed at exposing hypocrisy and corruption in institutional structures.
The portions of the book dedicated to Henry Fielding are particularly strong in this regard. Schechter says, “Like Brecht, [Fielding] created his own theatre company capable of innovative and politically engaged artistry” (75)—that theatre company being Haymarket, which competed against the licensed stages of Drury Lane and Covent Garden. Fielding's theatrical endeavors, often staged in direct opposition to the prime minister, Robert Walpole, eventually led to their suppression through the Licensing Act of 1737. The efforts of the Haymarket Theatre and its staging of satires such as Pasquin (1736) and Eurydice Hissed (1737) “enlarged and celebrated existing opposition to Walpole that was far more vocal in the street than inside playhouses” (77). As in Brecht's theatre, Fielding's exploits used a theatrical and fictional lens to refer to, comment on, and re-create, without standing in for, actual events outside the theatre. Schechter's reading of Fielding qua Brecht in this regard enlarges the importance of Fielding's work and emphasizes the nature of satire, especially its ability to raise to a boil already simmering discontent. Schechter discusses several other figures at length, such as John Gay, Jonathan Swift, Charlotte Charke, David Garrick, William Hogarth, and James Boswell, but none seem as fittingly Brechtian as Fielding.
Another highlight is Schechter's discussion of female characters in works by Gay and Farquhar. The author describes the character Polly in The Beggar's Opera as a dialectical heroine, embodying the purity and faithfulness of sentimental drama through unyielding devotion to the criminal Macheath, but also mocking that sentimentality through the juxtaposition of her pastoral charm with a filthy prison. The discussion of female characters in these satires also leads to an analysis of cross-dressing and experimental casting in the eighteenth century, particularly through the actress Charlotte Charke, who played both Polly and Macheath (though not simultaneously). Charke also played men in other plays and cross-dressed in her daily life, which Schechter says acted as a type of precursor to performance art: Charke's “rejection of patriarchy, and her impersonation of men onstage and off, anticipated the refusal of conventional gender roles that continues in our own day” (209). Citing eyewitnesses of her performance, Schechter demonstrates how Charke's fluid movement among gender roles recontextualized the characters and mocked standards of masculinity. Thus, through male impersonation, actresses could bracket their roles onstage as roles, distance the audience from assumed perceptions, and critique modes of behavior through performance in a way Brecht would have admired.
Schechter's discussion covers other eighteenth-century theatrical devices, such as direct address of the audience, the cold and unaffected performance style demonstrated by Garrick, and metatheatrical plays that comment on the business of theatre. But herein lies the limitations of Schechter's argument. Other than indicate that Brecht would replicate these very elements in his own theatre, Schechter does not sufficiently explain how any of these elements created a Verfremdungseffekt in the eighteenth century. When Brecht interpreted the alienation effects of Chinese acting through Mei Lan Fang, he found a model for his theories through an Asian aesthetic. Yet, although Mei Lan Fang's performance may have been alienating to a European audience, Brecht failed to acknowledge that those very techniques were conventional and affecting to a Chinese one. Similarly, the cross-dressing by Charke may have been in part transgressive, but it was also part of a performance culture that celebrated women in breeches because the contours of their feminine body could be made even more evident. Without enough attention to what may have been alienating to an eighteenth-century audience, Schechter's argument requires further exploration.
Nonetheless, his study of these important theatrical figures through the lens of Brecht offers a fresh, critical engagement that indicates how the political spirit enlivening the dramas of Dario Fo, Vaclav Havel, David Hare, and Caryl Churchill could find its antecedent in the eighteenth century. The book offers twenty-four chapters, some very brief and playful. This structure allows Schechter to interlace conventional scholarship with fictional narratives, dramatized conversations, transcribed diaries, and comparisons to modern movements such as Occupy Wall Street and figures such as Yoko Ono and Chelsea Manning. These interludes, asides, and anachronistic nods provide a Brechtian approach to historical scholarship, honoring the spirit of his source material and providing an engaging reading experience.
