Julie Peteet situates this monograph about Palestinians in Lebanon within the theoretical literature on place and displacement. Based on years of fieldwork and extensive interviews, her work analyzes how place and identity are mutually constitutive and mediated over time by violence, resistance, and power among Palestinians living in refugee camps in Lebanon from the 1950s through the 1990s. The innovative work of this volume lies in two analytical themes that Peteet uses throughout: place and agency.
The first analytical trope of the book is the importance of place to Palestinians' lives: the author focuses on the ways Palestinians use and recreate places in exile to establish social and spatial stability and meaningful identities. She adeptly discusses how Palestinians relied on the village structures of pre-1948 to settle in camps together with members of the same village, thus replicating social and familial structures and networks through spatial proximity. Peteet shows that, by recreating familiar place relations associated with their natal villages, Palestinians engendered a familial and social stability that stood in contrast to the daily humiliations they endured as refugees constantly monitored and disciplined by the Lebanese state and economically dependent on United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) rations.
The rise of the resistance movements in the late 1960s and the signing of the Cairo accords in 1969 (which allowed Palestinians in Lebanon the right to work, form organizations in the camps, and participate in armed struggle) provided Palestinians a newfound stability through their own administration of the camps. Affiliation with “the resistance,” which created new public services and spaces such as offices and clinics, encouraged a broader Palestinian identity that went beyond and even replaced familial and village allegiances. Peteet then shows how during and after the “days of the wars” (1982, 1985–87), Palestinian relationships to place again changed due to the elimination of the resistance movement, the implementation of restrictive laws on Palestinian employment, increased poverty and immigration, and the influx of new residents to the camps. Restricted and disempowered within what Peteet calls “the geography of terror and reconfinement” (p. 170), Palestinians fell back on familial and village origin as a social and economic support structure.
The second analytical method that Peteet carries throughout the narrative is the constant attention to Palestinian agency within discussions of the much larger bodies that try to maintain and monitor them or threaten them. The author establishes this type of analysis early on by examining the effects of power and violence on Palestinian identification practices within the international efforts to define Palestinian “refugee” status and coordinate assistance to those determined to be refugees after 1948. She reviews the international efforts to rehabilitate and resettle the refugees, the discourse about bodies and health, and their economic solutions to political problems (that, thus, ultimately failed), showing how through their organization and practices they “produced in refugees new capacities for action” (p. 69). Throughout the book she maintains the focus on how Palestinian refugees internalized, acquiesced, resisted, co-opted, and repoliticized the efforts to rule over, manage, and provide for them by aid regimes, states, local powers, and even the resistance movements.
Peteet's attention to gender and the local context of the refugee experiences complement the other themes of the book. She effectively charts the changing relationships of Palestinians to the space within the camp through gendered practices (both male and female) that are never static and relate to obtaining UNRWA aid; the significance of dress, travel, and work; and senses of responsibility and security. Similarly, each chapter discusses the changing relationships among Palestinians and Lebanese, initially felt as the responsibilities of “hosts and guests,” which then turned into new relationships and affiliations as the camps blended into the largely poor and disenfranchised Shiעa neighborhoods around them. Her interviews (before and after the war of the camps) with two women who remained friends but whose children and husbands fought each other in the camp wars reveal the complicated and powerful pull of both politics and friendships.
A short chapter on the Zionist production of knowledge about Palestine and its indigenous inhabitants' relationship to the land seems out of place in this well-focused work on Palestinian refugees in Lebanon. Similarly, a reliance in chapter 3 on Gaza source material and volunteers' letters from the American Friends Service Committee archives to tell the story of the early years of refugee aid, before UNRWA, supports the author's arguments; the material is extremely interesting, but it appears a bit incongruous with the rest of the chapter and a book that concentrates on Lebanon. Finally, it would have been useful to have dates on the many excellent and expressive photographs of the camps.
Landscape of Hope and Despair offers new analytical approaches to understanding Palestinian identity through the insights and research material of a scholar who has been working on the topic for almost thirty years. The volume is not a general introduction to Palestinian refugees in Lebanon; rather, it examines the subject through specific theoretical and analytical lenses—providing an analytical picture of the changing social and spatial structures in the camps from the 1950s to the 1990s within the context of the instability, poverty, and violence that characterized refugee life. The theoretical sophistication of the work makes it appropriate for upper division undergraduates or graduate students in any social science or humanities discipline, and it is a worthy acquisition by any library.
Scholars of Palestinian politics and society will find illuminating the ways in which this book reconfigures the conception of Palestinian refugees in Lebanon by examining their relationships to, and experiences in, social and spatial structures, and their changing affiliations and identity practices enacted during their more than fifty years of living in exile in Lebanon. In this well-written book, Peteet powerfully shows that for Palestinian refugees in Lebanon, Palestine symbolizes their “longing for security of place and the rights entailed in being a citizen” (p. 216) rather than their nostalgic reflection on a distant place and past.
