For anyone who has had the opportunity to examine the pathology collections at Glasgow University or has visited the Hunterian Museum at the Royal College of Surgeons, which are among the collections at the heart of Morbid Curiosities, the range of feelings from awe to disgust their Victorian visitors reported may well be familiar. However, whereas a more analytical reading of these collections might view them as examples of a rich social and medical heritage, for contemporaries they were always more than objects of curiosity. They were (curiously) living and dynamic collections designed to be explored, handled, used and interpreted, but the inner lives of these medical museums are only beginning to be examined as historians move beyond Richardson's seminal work on dissection and body snatching to look at the period after the 1832 Anatomy Act. Part of this trend and the material turn in Victorian studies, Morbid Curiosities eschews the sensational to concentrate on how human remains acquired meanings through collection, preservation and display. Situated within cultural and anthropological readings of the morbid body, Alberti offers a rich portrait of the complex conceptual and practical afterlives of the diseased body parts that made up these medical museums to ask how they came to be in a museum, what happened to them there, and who used them.
A product of the intellectual environment of Manchester's Centre for the History of Science, Technology and Medicine, and influenced by Pickstone's ‘ways of knowing’ and Strathern's anthropology, Alberti presents a nuanced examination of these medical museums from the Enlightenment ‘museum oeconomy’ to the Victorian exhibitionary complex. In thinking about the nature of collecting and collection, Morbid Curiosities charts the origins of medical museums in the eighteenth century and their dramatic expansion in the nineteenth century before considering their dismemberment and the impact of the 2004 Human Tissue Act in the conclusion. Sensitive to how these collections evolved and were used, and drawing on museum catalogues, the specimens themselves, autobiographical works, visual sources and medical journals, Alberti encourages us to re-view the medical museum and the specimens, communities and institutions that shaped them. Moving easily between collections in England, Ireland and Scotland, and careful to illustrate the wider contexts of museums and medicine, Alberti stresses how medical museums had an essential pedagogic role and were important sites in the creation of knowledge. If other historians have placed the patient at the centre of medical knowledge and the medical encounter, Alberti shows how the diseased and fragmented body, images and models, curators and elite medical practitioners, collections and museum spaces, were part of a cultural cartography of the clinical, educational and exhibitionary sites in which they circulated. The result is a history of medical knowledge and display less ‘from below’ and more ‘from within’ as patients are rendered into fragmented and fungible parts and subsumed into anatomy and pathology collections, while the museums which housed them become vital sites for understanding nineteenth-century medical education and the production of medical knowledge.
In assessing the range of contexts that produced these medical museums, and the connections and comparisons between them, the book recovers what went on behind the scenes of these now disappearing and fragmented collections. Always striving for the complex meanings behind how diseased bodies were fragmented, circulated, preserved and displayed, Alberti views the medical museum as a vehicle for understanding how the abnormal was constructed and how it shaped what he sees as the new geography of disease. In adding another layer to Foucauldian interpretations of the move from the monstrous to the abnormal, Alberti presents the idea of the dividual – the partible body – as crucial in interpreting the collections he discusses. If at times the empirical takes a back seat to theoretical discussion, in recovering the tales of diseased body parts, models and illustrations that made up collections, Alberti shows how specimens were harvested from post-mortems, how they were preserved, how they were displayed, and the problems encountered in each part of a process he associates with industrial production. While Alberti's use of the medical-marketplace model owes more to current trends in medical history than to the subject matter, he shows how body parts became specimens that were circulated and sold. In pointing to this dimension, he emphasizes the importance of curators and elite practitioners in shaping and organizing collections, though often it is the latter than dominates the discussion.
Where we might want to hear more about the curators, porters and other workers in order to explore the museum as a social institution, Alberti is not simply happy with presenting the specimens and medical museums as objects to be viewed and interpreted. While objectification was integral to these collections, Alberti provides important insights into the more visceral dimension of the medical museum. The production and display of specimens was, after all, a messy and smelly business. In discussing how specimens were created, and how museums were scenescapes, Alberti moves beyond a dry reading to recover the hidden lives of the specimens and the constant work of maintaining museums before turning to how particular audiences experienced them. While the recovery of the visitors' voices is necessarily fragmentary, and specimens often matter more than the institutions that housed them, in reminding historians that medical museums were dynamic pedagogic environments and that the specimens within them were visceral objects of display and knowledge, Alberti succeeds in moving beyond ideas of disgust and awe. He shows how it is important to understand the medical museum as part of a disciplinary landscape in which the afterlives of diseased bodies acquired meanings through collection, preservation and display. In doing so, Alberti's book is an intellectually lively and valuable study that shifts attention away from bodies to those body parts which made up museum collections.
