Nearly 20 years after advancing the field of Latin American cultural history with her study of negotiation and resistance in rural Mexican schools, Mary Kay Vaughan once again uses a path-breaking approach to education in her new book. This biographical study of the successful, if not internationally famous Mexican artist, José ‘Pepe’ Zúñiga explores how modern subjectivities were made during the most stable period of the Mexican twentieth century. Born in 1937, Zúñiga's childhood and youth coincided with the decades of the ‘Mexican miracle’, when the country experienced rapid economic and demographic growth and saw the expansion of Mexican consumer culture. In this context, Vaughan contends, young Mexicans formed their identities by drawing from a range of cultural sources to be found in the home, the church, the barrio, the school and the cinema. At each site, children like Zúñiga absorbed new and traditional ideas about work, class, love and the self, ideas that Vaughan extracts for the reader through close readings of cultural texts. She also explores how Zúñiga understood and interpreted the messages that these texts transmitted to him. Vaughan is able to address this thorny question of reception because of the enthusiastic collaboration of Zúñiga, who asked her to write his biography and developed a close friendship with the author.
Vaughan sought to write a narrative, not analytic, biography and limits her explicit theorising to an introductory study. Building on the most historical recent scholarship on popular culture, youth, and education in Mexico, she identifies several key themes in twentieth-century Mexican history as particularly salient in the biography: the growing social, cultural, and political role assigned to children and youth, the growing significance of mass media and its influence in the public sphere, and the emergence of new ideas about gender and the modern self. As her main argument, Vaughan posits that the same ‘freedom-seeking subjectivity’ that propelled Pepe Zúñiga to create introspective paintings also mobilised a generation of young people in the 1960s to struggle against state violence and repression (p. 27).
The biographical narrative begins before Zúñiga's birth with his family in Oaxaca. His father, and later the rest of the family, migrated to Mexico City when Zúñiga was very young. They settled in in Colonia Guerrero, a working-class barrio, where Zúñiga's father worked as a tailor. Vaughan describes the extended Zúñiga family network and details the survival strategies of the residents of the Colonia Guerrero to show the family and neighbourhood values that Zúñiga was taught: honour, popular Catholicism and hard work. He would later reject the poverty, alcoholism and violent masculinity that he observed as a child, and Vaughan explains that his youthful aspirations were also shaped by the songs he listened to, the textbooks he read and the films he watched. The modern man in these cultural representations was a consumer. His sexuality was not violent but tender, and perhaps most importantly, he was a member of the middle class.
As the family's fortunes improved over the course of his youth, social mobility became increasingly viable for Zúñiga. Indeed, his formal artistic training began in his early twenties when he had already established a promising career as a radio technician, an eminently modern profession. He enrolled in evening drawing courses at the Escuela Nacional de Pintura, Escultura y Grabado La Esmeralda, a public art school founded for the popular classes after the Mexican Revolution. At La Esmeralda, Zúñiga's teachers encouraged him to find his personal voice by tapping into an eclectic, international range of influences. Zúñiga was able to support himself as a working artist within a few years of finishing his studies. His technical ability and reflexive approach to Mexican themes brought him employment in state-sponsored projects and prizes in corporate-sponsored competitions. The story ends in 1972 when Zúñiga, then in his mid-thirties, secured a scholarship to study in France where he remained for some years before returning to Mexico in the 1980s.
Vaughan contends that Zúñiga and his artistic peers, born between the mid-1930s and the 1940s, quietly but powerfully contributed to opening the public sphere in the last decades of the twentieth century. In keeping with the most recent literature on student activism, she shifts the focus away from the highly visible vanguard of the 1968 movement. For Vaughan, Zúñiga and his cohort constituted their own ‘rebel generation’ that did not, at least on the surface, seem particularly rebellious. Already out of school by 1968, they sympathised with student demands but did not directly participate in student movements. Neither in the 1960s nor later did they directly critique the state, militate on behalf of any particular political ideology or dramatically upend artistic conventions, as younger artists would do. Still, Vaughan insists that Zúñiga's overlooked generation was propelled by ‘an anti-authoritarian sentiment … every bit as important to a democratizing public sphere as rights-claiming poster art or antipatriarchal performance art’ (p. 222).
Vaughan is more successful in showing how Zúñiga's subjectivity was formed than in demonstrating that the ethos of his generation changed Mexican political culture. Yet the former accomplishment is no minor feat. The children of the Mexican miracle grew up in a world made not only by the Mexican state, so often the primary mover in the historiography, but also by the growing influence of mass media and the persistence of folk traditions that the state could not eradicate. Fortunately, Vaughan is equally adept at analysing textbooks and Hollywood films, and she leaves no doubt in the reader's mind that both were crucial for making Pepe Zúñiga who he is. Vaughan's book suggests that the roots of political resistance in Mexico can be profitably explored at the level of individual subjectivity, and her work should influence future scholarship by Mexicanists and historians of youth movements in Latin America and beyond.
