Books are ambitious when they tackle one of academia's hottest topics: sex, class, race, gender, capitalism, or the nation state. Anna M. Agathangelou's The Global Political Economy of Sex takes them all on, demonstrating the many ways in which peripheral nation states facilitate the use of female labor in the desire industries and illustrating the reasons for states' participation in those industries. Agathangelou has several goals here. First, she seeks to uncover the nation state's role in the sale and purchase of female labor. At the same time, she determines to uncover the connections between “the expropriation of racialized reproductive labor, or sex and domestic work, and the relations to gender, sexuality, race, desire, and identity” (p. ix). Claiming that most theories in international political economy (IPE) and feminism obscure the ways that “gender relations, sexuality, desire, constitutions of people's personhoods are part and parcel of issues like labor, exploitation and projection of hegemonic power,” (pp. ix–x) the author offers Cyprus, Greece, and Turkey as examples of the role that the “productive economy of reproduction” (p. ix) plays in constituting state, self, and survival.
The nation state is Agathangelou's bête noire, and uncovering its role in the facilitation of the desire industry and in the expropriation of female labor serves as her organizational leitmotif. Five well-developed and well-illustrated ideas constitute The Global Political Economy of Sex. First, the activities of domestic and desire workers must be viewed within the context of the state's grasp and not that of the private household, to understand the full local and global impact of their labor. Second, states such as Cyprus, Greece, and Turkey—enriched by service industries rather than heavy industry—maintain and sustain capital power in the hands of owning classes by facilitating the movement and availability of desire workers. Third, the capital classes in Agathangelou's test states seek to “whiten” themselves by drawing on the labor of lower income and further peripheral states such as Sri Lanka, Rumania, Myanmar, Russia, and Belarus. (Agathangelou argues that these not fully white classes become white through the labor of “white but not quite” or lower class workers from elsewhere.) Fourth, domestic and desire workers play central roles in the definition of a white, middle-class self in Greece, Cyprus, and Turkey, “enabling their employers' middle-class desire of ‘having it all’—a full-time career, happy and healthy children and spouse, and a well-kept household” (p. 5). Finally, the state manipulates the racialized and gendered notions of “self” and “other” that result from the presence of desire workers to constitute national identity and to claim threats to national security.
Agathangelou explicates and illustrates each of these ideas through the use of theory; substantial secondary-source material about the region, its states, and economies; and substantial—and praiseworthy—field work. Indeed, each of the book's six chapters is loaded with remarkable interviews with sex workers, domestic workers, employers, and immigration and police officers. We hear, firsthand, of smuggling, trafficking, and coercion. We experience the disillusionment of women who came to work as waitresses only to find themselves as sex workers. We read domestic employers' accounts—sometimes patronizing, other times sincere—of their relationships to their hired help. A Cypriot immigration police officer speaks of desire (“The desire of man has changed, he is hungry…”) and of race (“The Filipinas are more educated and possess a better approach towards nurturing kids; they possess muscular power and nursing skills”) and of his role in their presence in his country (p. 63). Although each tells his/her own story, each also speaks to Agathangelou's agendas, illustrating the ways in which race, sex, and class shape self and state. Agathangelou's interviews with desire and domestic workers also illustrate the stark differences between the workers' goals of survival and the results of their trade on employers' self and national identity. “For everything…the Russian women are responsible…Their presence alone “excites” (erethizei) the young, resulting in the kinds of behaviors they currently exhibit” (p. 64).
If the strength of The Global Political Economy of Sex is its fieldwork, its weakness lies in Agathangelou's frequently impenetrable prose. I found myself reading entire paragraphs three and four times to discern their meaning. I also wished, on more than one occasion, that Agathangelou had relied less on theory. Giving more space to the recent histories of her test states, illustrating the development of their economies, problematizing their “peripheral” status historically, and linking the histories of the (peripheral) Mediterranean to the (even further peripheral) sources of its domestic workers would both anchor the text and make it less reliant on the jargon of the social sciences.
Such critiques notwithstanding, The Global Political Economy of Sex will find its audience among those who use feminist theory to teach or to examine the political economies of the region (indeed, Agathangelou is the Cynthia Enloe of the Mediterranean world). The book will also find its fans among those who seek to globalize “Middle Eastern” states such as Turkey and to situate them in contexts that transcend—or at least extend and complicate—the more typical and traditional frameworks through which those nations are viewed.
