The question of ends was a genuine controversy that began to rage long before the term “teleology,” coined by Christian Wolff in his Philosophia rationalis sive logica of 1728, was invented. It is a controversy that continued through the ages in a highly articulate debate that extended beyond the classical world, accompanying scholasticism from its beginnings, to be pursued in the early modern period with particular intensity – as I will attempt to show in this paper.
Nonetheless, the number of works in the history of philosophy devoted specifically to the question of teleology is limited.Footnote 1 After the early, unfinished attempt by Georges–Louis Le Sage during the eighteenth century, it is not until the end of the nineteenth century that we find a book entirely dedicated to final causes. Paul Janet published an interesting work halfway between philosophical inquiry and historical reconstruction entitled Les causes finales.Footnote 2 The reason I mention Janet in this context is because one of the principal merits in his defense of teleology was that it did not “water down” the concept by diluting it in pursuit of an acceptable compromise with his opponents, the supporters of antifinalism, as had done many other writers before him.
Taking up the Hegelian concept of vorherbestimmte, Janet sketches out a definition of the final cause based on how it is given to experience “as an effect which, if not planned, is at least predetermined, and because of this predetermination it determines and controls the series of phenomena that it apparently results from: it is thus a fact … that may be considered as the cause of its own cause.”Footnote 3 Echoing Kant’s thinking, the series of final causes can be considered to be the exact inverse of the series of efficient causes, with one in descending order and the other ascending.
Although thinkers of every period had attacked the legitimacy of this argument with the tools available to them in their time, not one of them, according to Janet, had succeeded in offering a definitive solution to the problem. The optimism that Koyré evinced when he wrote that, in passing from a closed world to an infinite universe, modernity banished final causes and violently expelled them from the new science, does, in effect, appear to be excessive when viewed from this perspective.Footnote 4 His optimism lacks justification, unless one is willing to relegate such figures as Gassendi, Leibniz, or even Newton himself to the old ontology, saving only Descartes (and even he is not completely out of the woods) or Spinoza or, more to the point, the physician and philosopher Guillaume Lamy, who forms the subject of this article.
Still relatively unknown and unexplored by scholars, Lamy is one of those figures for whom the gap between posthumus fame and the strategic importance or role they played in life is most evident: no monographic works have been dedicated to him.Footnote 5 My intention in this essay is to show that Guillaume Lamy — some of whose positions recall the most profound and enduring conclusions of materialism — represents a “radical” current of antifinalism, devoid of weaknesses and far from compromise with his adversaries. He was one of the key figures among the followers of atomism, and especially of Lucretius, in the seventeenth century. What will be shown is that his interest was directed toward the philosophical debate on the classics — especially on the three pillars of classical finalism, Aristotle, Galen, and Lactantius — just as much as it was toward the medical–anatomical debate with his contemporaries such as Galatheau and Cressé. I also intend to show that in spite of his critical, original formulations of Lucretian Epicureanism and despite his complex relationships with Descartes and Gassendi, Lamy represents a separate current of classical French philosophy in the last quarter of the century. This stature is based on his radical antifinalism and on his conception of chance as an explanatory principle for the formation and evolution of life. Taken together, these two elements function as a genuine “materialistic war machine” at the heart of an epoch during which no one was yet willing to take the leap of abandoning some of the cornerstones of the old finalistic and providentialist metaphysics.
This radical antifinalism and his conception of chance make of Lamy not a proto–Fideist — a sincere supporter of the unknowability of God’s ends — so much as a radical Lucretian materialist, whose aim is to openly distance himself equally from the partial Cartesian rejection of final causes and from the sugar–coated Epicureanism of the Gassendists.
The Classical Tradition
If we give credit to the opinion of Henri Busson, one of the first modern–day historians to “rediscover” Lamy, it is difficult to overestimate Lamy’s importance in the Paris of the last quarter of the seventeenth century. Along with Malebranche’s Recherche de la verité (1674), Jacques Rouhault’s Traité de Physique (1671), and the Nouveau cours de medecine (1669), Lamy’s De principiis rerum (1669) contributed to the “massive” penetration of Cartesianism into France.Footnote 6 Lamy’s is perhaps the most interesting of these texts because while offering a critique of Cartesianism, at the same time it constitutes both a rejection of finalism and an open admission of belonging to the Lucretian tradition.
In 1669, at the time the first of his three most important works were published, Lamy, originally from Normandy, was thirty–five years old and a Maitre aux Arts in Paris, where he had studied and taught philosophy. He also began his medical studies in the capital, becoming both a doctor and a member of the faculty in 1672. His two later works — the Discours anatomiques (1675, with later editions in 1679 and 1685) and Explication mécanique et physique des fonctions de l’âme sensitive (1677) — deal with medical subjects from a Lucretian perspective.
Lamy’s intention is to make it quite clear that he is not simply adding to the generalized renewed interest in atomism in the watered–down form provided by, for example, Gassendi. Hence, if the influence of the Latin poet and the reading of his works can be only vaguely posited for many of the Cartesians, the continual paraphrases and citations from Lucretius that Lamy provides, in spite of some significant revisions he makes to the Lucretian theory of the atom,Footnote 7 make him perhaps the most faithful follower of the period.
One of the most explicitly Lucretian arguments at the core of Lamy’s reasoning is his notion of “chance.” It is on this front that Lamy undertakes a well–mounted theoretical attack against chance understood as cause, directed not only toward his contemporary adversaries but also toward some of the greatest philosophers (and physicians) of antiquity who were engaged in the anti–Epicurean campaign. Chance is, naturally, both the main object of controversy for the supporters of finalism and the battleground in the conflict between Epicurean atheists and materialists. This was the case starting from the time the concept was first formulated, beginning at least with the assertion by Leucippus — as reported by Aetius — that “nothing happens in vain, everything happens for a reason and out of necessity.”Footnote 8Ex logou, in the fragment by Leucippus, does not signify a rational force or an ordering principle but rather a mechanical condition or cause. Maten especially, generally translated as “by chance,” has the meaning of “in vain” (corresponding to the Latin adverb frustra) in this context. The confusion develops further with the oft–quoted words by Democritus that everything existing in the universe “is the fruit of chance and necessity.”Footnote 9
Various sources show that Democritus, as well as the later atomistic tradition, spoke about things that arose automatos; namely, spontaneously and according to natural necessity. The Democritean automaton, therefore, has nothing to do with a lack of causes and is nothing but another name for necessity, completely foreign to any sort of end or purpose. Now, when Aristotle developed his critique, especially in the Physics II, 4–6, he included the Democritean notion within his own system, in which the cause par excellence was precisely the final cause.
Aristotle’s intention is to establish how automaton and tyche can be seen as causes. He “appropriates” the term and filters it through the system of final causes, thereby emptying it entirely of the meaning it had been given by Democritus. The automaton is no longer the spontaneous, but rather that which occurs whose end is different from its aim.Footnote 10 The way is thus open for Aristotle to enclose automaton within his system of final causes and bend it toward the idea of the failed accomplishment of an end.Footnote 11 With an elliptical reference to the etymology of the term, Aristotle thus unites chance (automaton) to that which is in vain (maten).Footnote 12 His intention in doing this is to subordinate both the accidental and chance to the final cause.
For purposes of simplification, one might say that, other than Aristotle, the two thinkers who represent the fundamental nodes in the theory of finalism and whom Lamy explicitly engages with in his works are the physician Galen and the theologian Lactantius. Galen makes use of the notion of “sympathy,” which he connects to the pre–established harmony in the universe. The key notion from this point of view is precisely that it is pre–established. For Galen, the organs of the body function together according to a deterministic mechanism, just as do the movements of the stars, which, however, are the work of a wise Ruler.Footnote 13 At the origin of this “mechanism,” then, we find an intelligent being who has endowed bodies with structures and movements that are suited to their functions. This is where Galen lavishes his praise on the “Creator of Man.”
The theme of the universe as a “machine” created by God the Craftsman or Architect also returns in the De opificio Dei by Lactantius.Footnote 14If an able architect considers the future of a building in its entirety before constructing it and performs calculations on its static properties, the distribution of the spaces, and its facilities, then why, when God is occupied in fashioning creatures (in machinandis animalibus), would He not plan in advance the conditions necessary for their lives? In opposition to Epicurus and Lucretius, then, Lactantius denounces chance (fortuito) as the cause of things and places all things under the aegis of divine Providence.
Mechanism and Finalism: The Ambiguities of the Cartesians
By putting forward the mechanistic world picture, modern Cartesian and post–Cartesian thinkers revitalized the debate by introducing elements of tremendous novelty. The clash between the exponents of this tradition and their opponents was extremely bitter because the admission or denial of ends put the entire conception of Nature and philosophy itself into question.Footnote 15
Before looking more closely into Lamy’s radical version of antifinalism, then, it behooves us to understand some aspects of the complexity, ambiguity, and, in the final analysis, excessive caution of the extensive school of thinkers represented by Descartes and his followers. These included complex, influential figures like Malebranche on the one hand and, on the other, the supporters of the atomistic revival in the seventeenth century, including Gassendi.
Descartes and Gassendi embodied the reaction against scholasticist concepts that were still widely prevalent in the first half of the century.Footnote 16 Their relationship perfectly represents the situation vis–à–vis finalism. Descartes, for example, does not exclude the existence of ends in Nature, but he does exclude the possibility of human reason’s coming to know them purely through its own efforts. With a move that is typical of his way of thinking, Descartes accedes on this physical and metaphysical point: Since man cannot know the metaphysics of final causes, their study is entirely useless for physics unless the Christian concept of Providence is eliminated and the God of the theologians with it (something that only Spinoza will manage to do, in the seventeenth century). Consequently, final causes must be preserved, at least in the relationship between God and His creation.
In spite of the bitter division that opposed the two thinkers, Gassendi’s conclusion on this point is not all that different from that of Descartes. Firstly, as Olivier Bloch has observed, we note a rigid unity in the metaphysical perspective that traverses Gassendi’s major works and which coalesces around a few themes, such as the defense of finalism.Footnote 17 The most interesting and original chapter of Gassendist philosophy, we might say, is the one reuniting the guiding ideas of atomistic mechanism on the one hand and finalism on the other.
This reciprocity also provides a certain hierarchy for Gassendi, because if it is true that man is destined to grasp only the surface of the great “Theatre of Nature,” thus remaining ignorant of the real mechanisms of efficient causes, it is precisely from considering the ends that we are able to draw the most knowledge. The seeking of efficient causes is not, therefore, a vain pursuit, but pursuing the final causes is even more commendable and productive.Footnote 18 As Bloch insists, it is Gassendi’s theory of the semina rerum that provides us with the most mature meaning of this watered–down version of atomism and its reconciliation with providentialist finalism. It is the semina rerum, the principles of organized things, that demonstrate the wisdom of a creator God and thus deny the vain idea of a spontaneous, natural necessity born of chance. In this section, the idea is put forward of a separation (typical of cautious mechanism) between the initial act, governed by divine wisdom and providence; and the subsequent natural course of the world, as if the final causes were ontologically and chronologically prior to the efficient causes.
Gassendi specifically aims to overcome the apparent contradiction between not understanding God’s work (for example, the fact that the creatures could have been created more perfectly than they are) and understanding their ends. What Descartes maintained, that the ends are all hidden and unfathomable, is not true. Some ends, especially those concerning the workings of living bodies, are known and evident. This is where Gassendi takes up one of his most interesting arguments: A simple glance at the world is not sufficient to understand the creation and wisdom of God. The world — just as it is — could appear to a careless observer as an effect of chance, thereby plunging both the efficient and final causes into an unknowably abyss.Footnote 19To know the final cause, however, enables us to know the efficient one as well. This argument is highly significant, because it reverses the “burden of proof” that the materialists (both Lamy and Spinoza will be included in this label) imputed to the “superstitious” followers of final causes. A distracted gaze on the world does not lead essentially, as it shall for Spinoza, to the superstition of finalism, but rather to materialistic atheism. This is why the forceful establishment of the priority of final causes as an ontological premise is so absolutely necessary to Gassendi, because its function is to enable a watered–down reabsorption of a certain version of mechanism and atomism.Footnote 20
Another illustrious example of the way mechanism was accommodated to finalism in the new philosophy is provided by Malebranche, for whom the descriptive set of laws of mechanism agrees perfectly with the prescriptive normativity of creationism. All the laws of creation are already included in the first act of divine creation. Physics clearly responds to the new mechanical principles in the form of simple and necessary laws. But we should give thanks to God for this, for the magnificence of the creation and the beauty of these laws, which are the means for God’s ends. These laws are necessary and sufficient for the movement of all things and for the general order of the universe, but they are insufficient for the creation of the universe, which depends, rather, on the act of the Creator.Footnote 21
One of the strategies typical of this odd and almost paradoxical “accommodation” that mechanist philosophers manage to make between mechanism and finalism is to reserve final causes to the moral sphere and to the freedom characteristic of man, while limiting efficient causes to the physical and material realms. This sort of separation between the physical on the one side and the moral on the other, is what I would define as “spatial.” But the example of Malebranche — and of Gassendi as well, to some extent — seems to point to a different kind of accommodation and a separation which we might define as “temporal” or “chronological” between the discrete time of the fiat and of creation, during which God conceives of the design in view of its ends, and the time when this mechanism is brought to life and is functioning, which is to be interpreted in accordance with simple and necessary laws and can be explained without direct recourse to finalism.
After this excursus, needed to fully appreciate the complexity of both the Aristotelian–Galenic–Christian tradition and that of Cartesian and post–Cartesian mechanism, it is now time to turn our attention to Lamy’s contribution to this debate.
The Cast of the Dice: Chance and Necessity
It is interesting to note that one of the first meanings Lamy gives to chance (hazard) is precisely the one he intends to refute: chance understood as lacking a cause, as a name for “the unknown” in which man seeks to discern the known. Stressing the semantic complexity of the term, Lamy implicitly hints at the ambiguity inherent to the word “chance.” In the first Discours, speaking about the skin of the hand, he suddenly interrupts his scientific analysis to criticize people who search for signs of the future in the lines of the palms. This criticism of divination provides the first meaning of the term. The use of the skin, he writes, is to transmit the sensations of the bodies that surround us, out of which arise the sensations of pain and pleasure. Some believe, however, that this creates a “register” in which the destiny of man is written and what they desire is to “divine their good or bad fortune” by reading the lines of the hand.
Lamy is not the first writer to criticize divinatory practices: skepticism has an illustrious tradition starting at least as far back as Lucian and Cicero. But Lamy mainly uses this argument to emphasize the role of chance, understood as a lack of causes and relations between the two events, the lines of the hand and the future of its owner.Footnote 22
The term “chance” thus shows itself to be equivocal and a legitimate vehicle in the language of the time for the concept that Lamy is attempting to criticize; namely, the lack of a causal relationship. Nevertheless, one of the final chapters of the De principiis ends with the conclusion that omnia casu fiunt Footnote 23 — which is in no way absurd, Lamy points out, as long as “necessity is not opposed to chance.”Footnote 24
Starting from this first work, Lamy “travels back” down the current of interpretations and (more or less intentional) misunderstandings regarding the concept of chance in atomism. In a certain sense, without venturing into the problem of the translation from Greek, Lamy “reconstructs” the original meaning of the concept: If today “chance” can also signify that which is in no way a cause but purely a “mode” of defining how often or how something occurs, then chance is also a cause – not in the sense that Aristotle would have it, as an accidental cause subordinate and posterior to the final cause, but as a natural cause that is necessary and exhaustive in explaining natural phenomena.
Chance intended as unpredictable or as something necessary whose cause, however, remains unknown, thus takes on a primary importance in Lamy’s system and in his critique of final causes. The example of the cast of the dice, especially, put forward in the De principiis, will become the most important metaphor in his subsequent works and the “outpost” from which the attack on final causes will be launched.
Now, it is true, as Landucci points out, that Lamy asserts that God and not chance is at the origin of things.Footnote 25Although Lamy’s God does not act like a craftsman, it is nevertheless from his intellect and will that the design of the universe originates; He knows with certainty all the effects that will arise from His creation; and, in the final analysis, ends exist in God but they are not knowable by man; hence, physics should not be concerned with them. Yet, if we carefully consider the arguments that Lamy cautiously uses to stay within the limits of permissible discourse, it seems to me reductive to force him into a position that is often found in the mechanists who sought to stay within the boundaries of faith. Employing a widely used model — what I earlier referred to as a “spatial” distinction alongside a different “temporal” distinction — they posited an initial fiat in which the supreme end of creation plays a role, and only subsequently a “machine” universe that operates solely according to the laws of motion and rest, in which it is neither necessary nor, in the final analysis, possible to know the ends that lie behind its creation.
For Lamy, the issue that really matters is not so much the ignorance of final causes as the ignorance of the laws of necessity, making him a rather unusual thinker on the seventeenth–century scene, one who is much more unusual than most of his modern commentators are willing to acknowledge.Footnote 26 The problem for him lies not in having knowledge of the final causes but rather in obtaining the kind of knowledge of things occurring in Nature that he characterizes as natural and necessary — or in other words, “by chance,” in the sense of automaton, the spontaneous. This is why the cast of the dice that Lamy uses as an example to explain his own idea of “chance as a cause” goes beyond a simple metaphor. The example appears once again, even more significantly, in the Discours.
Galen’s books, insists Lamy, are full of “ridiculous questions” that are unfailingly resolved by appealing to final causes. But the number of people who are blinded by this expedient for explaining things is so great that it is almost impossible to contradict them. Fortunately, the atomists, and Hippocrates among them, followed a different route, believing that “the shape, the placement and the number of the parts depend entirely on matter and its motions which, necessarily and with no decision involved, do whatever they are capable of doing.”Footnote 27 If we knew the size, shape, and motion of the atoms that make up animal seed, we would be able to see clearly the “why” and the “how” the parts are formed (but certainly not “that for the sake of which”). Lamy adds,
[J]ust as three dice cast onto a table necessarily result in a number included between three and eighteen, without being able to produce a larger or smaller number, similarly, the particles in the seed necessarily result in a certain man, without being able to produce a body of another species. Now these parts are formed by a blind necessity in the motions of the matter and, therefore, are not destined toward any end.
One is obliged to talk about the necessary and the contingent outside of any possible finalistic framework. The cast of the dice must necessarily result in a number between three and eighteen. It is impossible for the number to be higher or lower and, at the same time, it is necessarily determined by chance, understood as the lack of an end in Aristotle’s sense, but certainly not as a lack of any cause whatsoever, in the sense his successors interpreted the Aristotelian “in vain” (maten).Footnote 28
We recognize here the limited variety of beings produced by Lucretius’s combination of atoms which, as in the example of the dice, lies necessarily between a maximum and a minimum.Footnote 29 The meaning this “chance” takes on is precisely the automaton of the atomists, who believed the world to be formed through the “blind necessity of the motions of matter.” Lamy is extraordinarily effective at showing how the reduction of chance to the “in vain” and “devoid of cause” typical of the finalists is a false question, just as is their objection to a “world by chance.” The conclusion Lamy draws from the example of the dice is the one traditionally offered by atomism, in which the organs determine the function and not the other way around: we don’t see because we have eyes but rather, because we have eyes, we see. The finalists, instead, maintain that the end is known prior to the thing it is intended for. Hence, just as we build beds while knowing beforehand what rest is, and just as we build weapons while knowing beforehand what combat is, similarly, we have eyes that are made for seeing and ears that are made for hearing.
Yet it is impossible, Lamy retorts, paraphrasing the Lucretian criticism of final causes (a rather extraordinary stance for the time), for sight to be known before having eyes or hearing to be known before having ears.Footnote 30 The organs are not made for the function they perform; rather, they have “necessarily come upon” this function from their current use. Lanctantius, adds Lamy of his own initiative, does not seem to have understood what the atomists meant when he objected to them that if the parts had come upon their use as they say, without an end, why would matter not still form men who hear with their noses, smell with their eyes, and see with their ears? Once again, Lamy casts his dice onto the table: “The question is contrary to reason, as if you were asking them why when casting the dice you do not end up with nineteen or twenty, seeing as it is chance that makes one number come out rather than another.”Footnote 31
The cast of the dice thus explains in what way chance is a cause and certainly not a n’importe quoi as the finalists would have it. Above all, it offers the advantage of bringing chance back to its original meaning of a spontaneous, autonomous, independent, immanent cause devoid of finality. In response to the criticisms of M. Galatheau, who was quick to publish his attack, Lamy is forced to further clarify his opinion in the Reflexions.Footnote 32 Subsequently, he decides once again to take up the example of the dice and develop it further in his Réponse to Galatheau published at the end of the Explications mecaniques.
Galatheau had objected that the example of the dice and the comparison with human seed was used inappropriately inasmuch as seed necessarily comes from a man whereas a given number does not necessarily come from a cast of the dice, but rather any number between three and eighteen. But this, insists Lamy, is precisely the meaning that should be given to the word “chance” and its relation to the immanent and spontaneous “necessity” of remaining between certain limits, and the “freedom” to produce a particular result, which is also immanent and spontaneous. The difference here, explains Lamy, lies between the single individual and “man,” understood as the set of possible (and necessary) individuals:
If [Galatheau] could conceive that when we talk about making a man, without specifying an individual, we allow the event of production arising from the seed an incomparably greater diversity compared with that which may come forth in numbers resulting from the cast of the dice, he would probably find the comparison I offer to be apt. This is because a precise number is not determined to result from the dice, which depend rather on the motion that is impressed on them and on the bodies they encounter, which cause them to be placed on one side or another. Similarly the particles of the seed are not determined to produce this man in particular. Just as a number must result from the cast of the dice, similarly a man must be born from the placement of the particles of the seed. And since there are only a few numbers included between three and eighteen which may result from the cast of the dice, similarly there are only a few men who may be born from the motion of the particles of human seed. The example I gave perfectly clarifies the opinion of Epicurus, who I speak about in my book [italics mine].Footnote 33
The reference to Epicurus is made explicit through the idea of the “encounter” between each dice and with external bodies.
Lamy’s example is even more interesting if we contextualize it in the framework of his contemporary culture. The cast of the dice can certainly be seen as a topos that is unrelated to any specific scientific reference. Still, it does not seem far–fetched to me to look to the early circulation and enormous success enjoyed by De ludo aleae (1657) by Christian Huygens, the early modern founder of probability theory. The text perfectly represents the ideal bridge between the two cities of Amsterdam — where Cartesian philosophy and geometry in particular were widespread by that time, not only among scientists but also among influential figures such as the burgomaster Johannes Hudde and the Grand Pensionary Johan de Witt — and Paris, where Huygens became aware for the first time of the correspondence between Pascal and Fermat that led to the concept of “statistical expectation” Footnote 34 which gave form to his own work.
It cannot be excluded that Lamy chose his example thinking about the new science of probability. In any case, the “blind necessity” of his dice left very little space to Providence or, most importantly, to final causes. This opened the field up instead to a more complex question, at least for medicine and biology: What type of order can emerge from a world in which chance, as the spontaneous, is the sole immanent “creator” principle existing prior to the encounter between simple bodies? More specifically, given this framework, what are we to make of the sort of “exception” that had already been discussed by the ancients but which from the end of the sixteenth century and throughout the modern period variously tormented the theologian and the scientist and the Aristotelian and the Cartesianian alike? The exception I am referring to is, of course, the “monster.”
Philosophy and Teratology
To begin with, it is interesting to note once again that to a large extent Gassendi reproduces the traditional schema of Aristotle and Galen in his “weak” version of atomism. Gassendi contests, naturally, the idea of an Aristotelian form that actualizes through and in matter, yet without embracing the Epicurean idea that the question of a being’s “generation” is a false problem.Footnote 35 The atomists maintained that the whole does not exist prior to its parts, an absurd idea for Gassendi, who also diminished the Lucretian argument of organs without function, such as the sterile genitals of the mule. Nor does the use antifinalists make of the monster have any importance for him. The weakness of our intellect does not allow us to judge the monster and, in spite of its existence, the order of creation does not come out of this any lesser, any more than a botched statue reflected badly on Polycletus’s ability for Galen or the exception did not reflect badly on the divine ratio for Lactantius. Both these examples are taken up again by Gassendi and used against Epicurus and Lucretius in the Syntagma. The divine and intelligent design is perfectly recognizable in the universe, and even if it is true, as the Epicureans would have it, that some organs exist prior to the functions they perform, they do not, in any case, exist prior to their idea in the mind of the Creator.
It is precisely against this watered–down version of atomism that Lamy develops his argument on monsters, as an additional element in his refutation of final causes.Footnote 36Without Lamy’s being aware of it, his materialism echoes that of Spinoza, for whom no transcendent paradigm or model can be posited in Nature and for whom every realitas is perfectione. Lamy contests Galen’s ideal vision of Nature, as he does the idea that the monster is some sort of transgression. Bodies do not respond to a pre–established normativity; rather, they come into being in accordance with the laws of Nature and the possible combinations that matter can assume, exactly as in the throw of the dice, by chance, understood as spontaneous, in the Lucretian tradition.
For Lamy, just as for Lucretius, the generation of beings, whether monstrous or not, necessarily follows the principles inherent to the formation of the world. The necessity of the movements of matter generated a “large number of animals of various species, some without eyes, others without mouths, and others without the parts needed for reproduction.” It followed that
many of them did not have the necessary parts, or they had too many, or they did not have them properly arranged; and thus they perished because they were not able to feed themselves or reproduce through coupling. The rest, who were well disposed, were able to preserve themselves and became the species we see today.Footnote 37
Lamy, who is evidently thinking of Empedocle’s man–faced oxen,Footnote 38 places himself decisively in the Lucretian current of thought, starting from the primordial elements that combine together without a design, “multa modis multis mutata,” after countless changes in countless ways.Footnote 39Once the organisms were formed, the individuals made use of the organs they had; hence, those that had feet walked, those that had wings flew, those that had fins swam, and the strongest lorded it over the weakest. There is no reason to seek an end because this story has no end. If anyone is to insist on the order and beauty of the creation formed by the Creator, must they not at the same time admit to Nature’s error and blindness in creating monsters?Footnote 40
Lamy takes up Lucretius again in his negation of Providence by referring to the countless “evils” that afflict the world: tanta stat prædita culpa!Footnote 41 Man is wretched in his natural condition, the Earth is hostile to him, the animals his enemies. And even with the progress of civilization, he will never be able to enjoy the advantages that the animals have been endowed with by Nature. If God creates and governs through Providence and according to an end, why was man not created with wings, for example?Footnote 42
If men of this sort existed, even Galen, if he were brought back to life, would compose a huge tome in praise of the Creator to celebrate His perfection. But, of course, there is no such thing as men with wings. Going back to this example in his Réflexions, Lamy insists on his version of realitas as perfectione. The complexity of his conclusions does not achieve the wealth and originality of what Spinoza would ultimately accomplish: in the final analysis, Lamy is clearly not interested, or does not succeed, in redefining the concept of God as Spinoza will do while continuing to call Him by the same name. Lamy does, however, go so far as to completely negate final causes. God did not make men with wings: we shall certainly not infer from this that He is imperfect but, rather, that it was not His will to do so. This is the true concept of Providence, not the one his opponents put forward.Footnote 43
Since Galatheau had chosen this example as his main point of attack, Lamy returns to this argument at length in his Réponse. The idea of a man with wings does not imply any contradiction in itself. Therefore, if we deny the existence of winged men but at the same time avow finalistic Providence, the Creator’s omnipotence is implicitly put into question since He could surely create them if He so willed. The reasons that Galatheau offers in support of his thesis, continues Lamy, are “ridiculous” and unworthy of a doctor.
Galatheau, who strikes the modern reader as a shockingly untalented and imprudent polemicist, objected that crimes would be committed with impunity and there would be no justice because criminals would be able to fly away and escape from the police. Obviously, Galatheau failed to realize that the forces of law would also have wings. But the second reason, notes Lamy, is even more ridiculous: If women had wings, wrote Galatheau, there would be no way to keep them tied to the “conjugal society.” The Spaniards and the Italians, who are “jealous by nature,” would never feel secure. This point is really beyond the pale for Lamy and we can almost see the mocking grin on his face as he prepares to play with his naïve adversary like a cat with a mouse. In this passage, Lamy’s open–mindedness when speaking about women comes to the fore, as it does on other occasions:
Now this really makes things difficult. Nevertheless, since jealous people have the right temperament for tormenting themselves and tormenting others, they would be able to keep their women under wraps, I suppose, by plucking the feathers from their wings, or by shutting them up in cages and extending the sole liberty to the curious of whistling at them behind bars. As Monsieur Galatheau knows well, young women can escape from the hands of their fathers, and wives can get away from their husbands even without wings. To prove him right, I imagine we would also have to cut off their legs. But personally, not being a jealous type, I would rather they had feet and wings too, so that the only thing keeping them put would be love.Footnote 44
Lamy’s comments on women are a favourite point of attack for his finalist opponents. As the good anatomist that he is, Lamy is not shy about getting into details and putting forward arguments of extaordinary lucidity and sensitivity. The dissection that provided the basis for his Discours was of a female corpse. When he reached the genitals, Lamy noted that “the Clitoris resembles the male member in almost all respects.”Footnote 45 It is similar in consistency, similar in form, and similar in the sensations it transmits, since “it is primarily there that women feel sensual pleasure.” At this point Lamy enters into an argument meant to attack the idea of a providential nature, but at the same time to make a suggestion regarding female sexuality: something rather unusual for the sensibility of the time.
The clitoris, he says, becomes so long at times that women “abuse” it, as a number of authors have written. Now, if this were true,
I would like ask my Esteemed Opponents, whilst we are at it, if they intend to conclude that nature gave women a clitoris in order to make use of it in this way. They must surely admit this to be so, or else give up on their principles, or else continue with their obduracy. Because if they continue to construe the use as an end, they will have to admit that nature had criminal intentions when it created parts that can be used in such an abominable fashion.Footnote 46
Something of this sort which is common and real, suggests Lamy, would have to be considered morally monstrous according to their logic.Footnote 47 Yet, according to the same logic, it would also have to be considered providential, inasmuch as all things partake of God’s ends. While demolishing the logic of finalism, Lamy at the same time removes the phenomenon of female masturbation from the paradox his bigoted adversaries had placed it in. Everything real is perfect and there is nothing abominable in this phenomenon, just as there is nothing finalistic in its origins.Footnote 48
If this were not enough, Lamy then redoubles his counterattack by denouncing the practice of clitoridectomy. Several authors had reported that female “circumcision” was practiced in the Orient. Indeed, the clitoris allegedly had become so long and noisome in Oriental peoples that to prevent the distress that it might cause, cautery was applied. But it is truly strange, Lamy continues with bitter irony, that Nature, who according to the finalists put every care into preventing hair from growing on the forehead so as not to block sight, thereby relieving men from such an easy and painless operation as shaving,
should instead have imposed such a painful operation on the women of the Levant. If we are to follow [their] principle, we must admit either that in these countries nature is less kind, or less wise, or that these poor women committed some unforgivable crime against her before they were even born.Footnote 49
Lamy is thus satisfied that his position has been securely protected and that he is able to stay within the limits of permissable discourse on God and Providence through these arguments. If God is omnipotent, nothing hinders Him from creating men with wings. He did not do so, because it is not His will and because these ends do not exist. The criticism directed at Epicurus that was put forward in De principiis is somehow used against the superstitious, in the sense that Spinoza also used the term, namely, the finalists. It is true that Epicurus made God indifferent to the world of men, thereby erring in a sort of anthropocentrism. Lamy remains consistent on this point throughout his works, both in his defence and in his critique of Epicurus. Yet, this too is an ideal opportunity to invert the argument against the Galenists. By lavishing praise on the Creator; by celebrating the wonders of creation, the order of Providence, and the perfection of the design, the true wisdom and will of God are demolished as soon as the culpæ of the world are taken into account.
The Discours thus concludes with a theodicy which is integrated into and founded on the rejection of final causes. Descartes had also taken his stance against finalism in a theodicy in the Fourth Meditation. It seems likely, then, that an enlightened cleric like Malebranche, in giving primacy to divine Wisdom over all other attributes when defining his own positions, was responding both to Descartes and to the “libertine” Lamy.Footnote 50 The “strong Epicurean spirit” in the pages of the Conversations Chretiennes of 1677 is at the same time a Cartesian, as if Descartes and Epicurus converged in Malebranche’s eyes in their negation of final causes. This figure must therefore be sacrificed to divine Wisdom and to that particular form of theocentric teleology that Malebranche gradually refines over the course of his works. The disorders of creation are necessary, from this perspective, not because they are part of the unfathomable divine will, as Lamy put it, but because they are part of the wider theocentric teleology. “My goal,” he will go on to write in his Traité de la nature et de la grâce, appearing not long after the Discours, “is to justify the wisdom and goodness of God in spite of monsters, sinners and all the disorders that exist in the world.”Footnote 51
Lamy’s Discours, which caused an uproar in the Paris of its day, does appear to be one of the most important targets, if not the primary one, of Malebranche’s polemics. In his Conversations, Malebranche raised the issue of wings as an example of the vanity of the antifinalists.Footnote 52 Although the argument is not original,Footnote 53 it seems highly likely to me that Malebranche was thinking precisely of the impious physician who was raising the hackles of half the medical faculty in Paris. Nonetheless, the gross simplification that Malebranche makes in forcing the “strong Epicurean spirit” into a Cartesian mold seems interesting to me, especially as it regards Lamy. By doing so, the “caution” exercised by both the Cartesians and Descartes himself in rejecting final causes is entirely disregarded. In fact, as we have seen, the rejection of substantial forms did not correspond at all to the rejection of final causes. In addition, a perspective on the complexity of the “atomistic” movement as it unfolds in the seventeenth century, at least starting from the De vita moribus Epicurii, is lost, including the work of Gassendi. Indeed, Gassendi had toiled his whole life to keep the critique of final causes and the revaluation of atomism — a particular version of atomism — separate from each other.
The identification of the errors of Epicureanism with those of Cartesianism, therefore, is representative of the mentality and vision of the problem that Malebranche had, rather than of the radicalism of Lamy’s thought. The radical materialism and antifinalism of Lamy points more in the direction of Part I of Spinoza’s Ethics than to Descartes’s Fourth Meditation, and, naturally, in an original way, as I hope to have demonstrated, to Lucretius’s poem on Nature.
