Japan’s economic integration into world markets in the nineteenth century has long fascinated historians, economists, and policymakers, and in recent years has received renewed scholarly interest. How did an isolated, peripheral economy become an exporting dynamo over the span of a few decades? Yasuhiro Makimura’s book on silk exports from eastern Japan in the second half of the nineteenth century vividly describes this transition, combining economic statistics with anecdotes from personal diaries and other sources. Together, these allow the author to identify the various conditions and relationships underpinning the expansion of the Yokohama silk industry, and to show that its success (and by extension, the country’s) was by no means predictable or guaranteed.
In its eight chapters (including an introduction and conclusion) and four data appendices, the book provides a largely chronological account of the early modern Japanese economy, pre- and post-Meiji restoration political reforms, key figures in government and commerce, and context specific to eastern Japan. Leading up to its forced opening to western trade in the 1850s, Japan faced the domestic challenges of maintaining a feudal economy faced with famines, commercialization and specialization by region, and increasing civil unrest. Thereafter, Japanese silk production benefitted from the contemporaneous collapse of its European and Chinese competitors and the shift toward the American market spurred by the latter’s westward expansion.
The unifying thread among these factors was the silk export sector, which Makimura argues played a crucial role in financing the country’s economic transformation by facilitating its integration with global markets. Raw silk exports grew by an order of magnitude from 4.4 to 44.7 million yen between 1870 and 1900 and were centered on Yokohama in eastern Japan. The latter characteristic is particularly surprising since Yokohama was neither the historical locus of domestic textile industry (Kyoto) nor a port with existing trade ties (Nagasaki). Rather, it was chosen for its deep-water port, allowing ease of access for foreign merchants, as well as its relative isolation from the political capital of Edo (later renamed Tokyo). Political economy considerations continued to affect the industry and region, with the government attempting to regulate access by local merchants and foreign traders to the agricultural hinterland. In the middle three chapters, Makimura persuasively uses accounts from notable individuals like Nakaiya Jubei, Yoshimuraya Kobei, and the Hoshino brothers to show how formal and informal channels were used to create local networks among officials, merchants, and producers.
The biographic histories provide welcome detail to the broader picture of the silk industry’s emergence in the region, which Makimura supplements with statistics from municipal archives. In part because of the focus on individuals, activities, and data from the region, somewhat obscured is their relation to the national economy and other geographic areas of Japan. Since Yokohama was one of initially five treaty ports that were opened to western commerce, readers may be curious as to how other ports and surrounding areas fared, how deliberate were the policies to restructure the distribution of economic activity from the traditional commercial areas of western Japan to the east, and how persistent were the effects. These questions may be prompted by the development of Japan’s cotton textile industry, which became the dominant export sector in the early twentieth century and was based in the Osaka region. While the author does not extend his analysis after the turn of the century, some discussion of how these separate, but related, textile industries would provide a more balanced treatment of the effects of export finance on the country’s economic development. Moreover, a discussion of how the proceeds of silk exports were used would also lend support to the author’s claims that there was a virtuous cycle of development for the country.
Makimura’s emphasis on the personal accounts of those involved in silk export commerce means that changes in technology and transport infrastructure and the contribution of labor are relatively unacknowledged. For example, would silk supplies have been able to meet burgeoning demand without innovations in silkworm refrigeration and multiple harvests in the same growing season? How important was faster access to ports via railways for perishable items like silk eggs, which the author explains were time sensitive and thus subject to price volatility? What about the roles of female labor in silk filatures and traditional artisans confronting increased mechanization and the use of inanimate energy sources? While the author makes good use of earlier contributions about Japanese and international sericulture, a useful reference not cited is Shin’ya Sugiyama’s monograph Japan’s Industrialization in the World Economy, 1859–1899 (London: Athlone Press, 1988), which provides in-depth analysis of the silk industry and its broader relationship with domestic industrialization.
Relying on one source of data, the Yokohama Shishi, also means that comparisons with other comprehensive and official estimates of trade and output (for example, the Ministry of Finance’s annual customs data or the Statistics Bureau’s Historical Statistics of Japan) are difficult. In particular, readers may wonder why there are substantial differences between these sources in the nominal values for the early years of silk exports, why certain products are aggregated together, and why currency units in the book’s tables and appendices change over time. Since dates also appear in both the lunar and Gregorian formats, it would have been helpful to have converted these for consistency as well as to have provided graphic timelines of key events in the development of both the industry and region. Finally, the author’s frequent use of speculative assertions and qualifiers raises some concerns about the robustness of the conclusions. These caveats notwithstanding, Makimura presents a compelling and multi-faceted discussion of the emergence of a regional industry that had far-reaching consequences for Japan’s remarkable modernization.
