Sherene Seikaly's Men of Capital is based on her dissertation, “Meatless Days: Consumption and Capitalism in Wartime Palestine 1939–1948” (New York University, 2007). It engages mostly with the Palestinian Arab economic leadership under the British Mandate, mainly businessmen and entrepreneurs (“men of capital”) who were also politicians, such as Rashid al-Hajj Ibrahim, Ahmad Hilmi Pasha ʿAbd al-Baqi, Fu'ad Saba, and others. Thus, this work sheds light on a newly made elite group that has garnered less scholarly attention than the traditional landowning elite from “notable” families. According to the author, this new leadership formed alternate “men of the nation” (26), who viewed themselves as the vanguard of “an interesting stage of economic evolution” in the Arab world (49). The study draws on a variety of sources, including Arabic press of the period and British official documents, mainly in a qualitative approach that positions the book within the field of social-political economic history, or rather the history of capitalism, in addition to the history of the Palestinians under the British Mandate.
The book is divided into an introduction, five chapters, and conclusion. The introduction, beyond a declaration of intent, some historical background, and quite a lengthy survey of most of the relevant literature, aims to situate the rise of the Palestinian “men of capital” as a part of the Arab Nahda (revival), a socio-cultural movement that encompassed the Arab Middle East. The first chapter, “Men of Capital: Making Money, Making Nation,” depicts this class, drawing heavily on the economic magazine al-Iqtisadiyyat al-ʿArabiyya, an Arab economic journal. This bi-monthly, and later a weekly, first appeared in Jerusalem in 1935–7. Its circulation was quite limited, probably just several hundred copies distributed to regions “ranging from Baghdad to Muscat.” al-Iqtisadiyyat’s pan-Arab style stands in contrast to the main Palestinian newspapers of the period, Filastin and al-Difaʿ, each with 7,000- 10,000 copies distributed daily within Palestine itself (55). Seikaly suggests that the economic journal's importance lay in defining itself as the organ of an alternative group, or class (30). Still, its low circulation is a weak point in the book's thesis that “Men of Capital” constituted an important segment of a growing national consciousness.
The second chapter, “Women of Thrift: Domesticity and Home Economics,” engages with issues of home and family, or as the author puts it “a Palestinian domestic awakening, or nahda manziliyya” (53). Questions of domesticity connects this study to the growing body of scholarship on the intersections between the middle class and modernity in the Middle East during the colonial period, such as Keith Watenpaugh's Being Modern in the Middle East (Princeton University Press, 2012). Seikaly's arguments in this chapter are based on “The Family Budget,” an article published in al-Iqtisadiyyat al-ʿArabiyya in 1935, and on “The New Arab Home,” a nine-part radio series that was aired by the Palestine broadcasting service between 1940–1. This radio program was also transcribed in Filastin, thus reaching an even greater audience, and thereby drawing the attention of contemporary scholars. The series was composed and presented by Salwa Saʿid, a native of Beirut and daughter of the city's mayor. She held a bachelor's degree and moved to Palestine following her marriage (there were sometimes inter-marriages between Palestinian and Lebanese elite families in the colonial era, e.g. that of ʿAnbara Salam of Beirut and Ahmad Samih al-Khalidi of Jerusalem).
Saʿid's series encapsulated the spirit of the emerging Palestinian Arab middle class under the Mandate, and its particular forms of modernity. She portrayed the modern, “rational,” well-organized home of a nuclear family as one that possessed a radio and a housemaid (65-67). The precise management of the home budget was, according to Salwa Saʿid, a female responsibility (69-71). European influence a-la-bourgeoisie is clear here, but Seikaly does not engage much with characteristic features of bourgeois identity, let alone their potential influence on the national consciousness.
The third, fourth, and fifth chapters are dedicated to scarcity in food supplies, textiles, and other commodities in Palestine during World War II, or “the crisis of supply and the specter of scarcity that came at the heels of the Great Revolt (1936-1939)” (105). These chapters also explore how the revolt and British reactions to it shaped the lives and fortunes of the Palestinian “Men of Capital,” and thus is of direct interest to economic historians.
Most of the third chapter, “A Nutritional Economy: The Calorie, Development, and War,” deals with nutrition during the the period and relies primarily on British documents. Chapter four, “A Public Good: Palestinian Businessmen and World War II,” describes the struggle of businessmen and the chamber of commerce in which they were organized to cope with a situation of scarcity. Here, as elsewhere, the Seikaly points to the inter-relations between economics and politics, concluding that “In the face of growing Jewish consolidation, economy took shape as a site of national battle” (126).
Chapter five, “The Vegetable Racket,” engages with the British policy of austerity and rationing during the war. Seikaly argues that the British economic policy's main benefactor was the Yishuv (the Jewish community in Palestine). This was a consequence of prioritizing organized production that gained “Tnuva,” the main Jewish Zionist food production and distribution cooperative, vast advantages vis-à-vis Arab farmers, who in turn became identified with the black market. Indeed, as Mandate and 1948 historians point out, the Jewish organizations and institutions of the time, which were considered more efficient than those run by local non-Jewish Palestinians, emerge again as an important factor in “turning the tide” in Jewish favor. However, Seikaly suggests that the British applied a set of double standards to Jews and Arabs, prioritizing economically the Jews who, during the war, were generally considered more supportive to the British authorities. Scholars such as Tom Segev in One Palestine, Complete (Holt and Co., 2000) and Rashid Khalidi in The Iron Cage (Beacon Press, 2006) previously demonstrated the existence of British favoritism towards Jews under the Mandate on political grounds. Palestinian Arab speakers during the period insisted on the prevalence of British favoritism toward Jewish organizations on economic grounds as well. However, historians have seldom addressed the existence of economic discrimination. In fact, in The Divided Economy of Mandatory Palestine (Cambridge University Press, 1998) Jacob Metzer presents data suggesting that while the Jewish sector economy under the Mandate was the fastest growing in the world, the Arab sector economy was the second. Seikaly works to debunk Metzer's thesis, but it does indicate a debate concerning the relationship between politics and the economy during the Mandate period.
As for the basic features of the book, the lack of a bibliography is an impediment for the scholarly reader, and the inclusion of a preliminary explanation and archival abbreviations at the beginning of the notes section does not compensate for that. While most likely this stylistic choice was not the fault of the author, it is rather unexpected from such a distinguished press.
Despite the aforementioned shortcomings, this book is an interesting contribution to the growing literature on Palestine and the Palestinian Arabs under the Mandate, especially in highlighting the entrepreneur class of “Men of Capital” and socio-cultural aspects of the growing bourgeoisie, and should be read as such by its students.
