What did work mean to Romans? And can extant depictions of labour from the Roman Mediterranean — transmitted on funerary steles, on dedicatory reliefs, on shop signs, through painted scenes, with stamps or inscriptions, and via numerous other ancient media — help modern viewers to uncover this meaning? The newest book by archaeologist and art historian Iain Ferris makes a number of bold claims from the outset, in a quest to connect art, workers and professionals within the Roman cultural landscape. In the preface, Ferris purports to present the ‘first recent book’ (8) to provide an extended analysis of the roles and self-identities of Roman workers to be framed in cultural rather than purely economic terms. He also states that The Dignity of Labour is intended to address an ‘evident gap in the market’ (10) by introducing ancient images of work and labour to an undergraduate-level audience. Over the course of a preface, nine chapters, numerous illustrations, notes, a bibliography and an appendix of named workers, Ferris carves out his own distinct image of Roman workers, albeit one predominantly focused on the Latin West rather than the Roman Mediterranean at large.
From the first chapter, Ferris points to the ways in which art, image and text allow us to define and to maintain identity even today — and how Roman workers such as builders used similar methods. Ferris provides a crucial truth in his extended critique of museums as continuing to champion the luxuries of the 1 per cent over the quotidian wares of the 99 per cent that lived and worked in ancient Rome day by day. By focusing on emperors, gold and jewels within a museum context, curators signal the significance of the elite within the historical record. In ch. 2, Ferris moves from building the city to feeding the city, looking to the well-studied monument of Eurysaces the baker (as well as his wife) outside the Porta Maggiore in Rome, built around 30–20 b.c. In ch. 3, it is on to clothing the city, with a focus on the textile and leather trades, followed by ch. 4, which homes in on metalworking trades.
In looking to the ‘word as image’ in ch. 5, Ferris is perhaps most successful in bringing the ancient Roman artisan back to life. He does this through examination of stamps, marks and signatures left particularly upon Roman ceramics. The blurring of image and text is explained in a straightforward manner that allows readers to question modern ideas of literacy and theories surrounding aesthetics in important ways. It pairs well with ch. 7, which looks at illusory art and the idea of performing identity through images. While ch. 6 looked at business people and transport, ch. 8 dips into the formation of professional networks and associations. A final chapter looks to how other, modern cultures have employed workers’ images, both real and metaphorical.
Throughout the Roman antiquity sections, most of the epigraphic and artistic evidence comes from Rome, Italy, Gaul and Germany during the late Republic and Empire, rather than Egypt or the eastern Mediterranean. The dynamic shift into the period of Late Antiquity is hard to discern except in terms of the food supply, and the late Roman Empire is not a direct focus of the book. More disquieting is Ferris’ stated avoidance of an in-depth discussion of the economic dynamics behind the Roman system of enslaved labour. There is much more to say here, not only about the freedpersons, which he touches upon briefly, but also about the depiction of enslaved labourers on everything from mosaics to reliefs of gladiators. The book itself is accessibly written and lavishly illustrated. Although there are numerous colour images to relish, there are no maps for students to use to geolocate the named cities, roads and transport systems articulated within the sections on travel and transport. Ferris does, however, deftly interweave art and epigraphy in a manner that will be attractive to teachers looking to bring Roman daily life to the modern classroom.
The Dignity of Labour stands uneasily upon the shoulders of predecessors such as Sandra Joshel (1992; 2015), John D'Arms (1981), and John R. Clarke (2003). Ferris dismisses the work on Roman invisibility within Robert Knapp's Invisible Romans (2011), a book written for a similar, general audience to great acclaim. Unlike Ferris, however, Knapp did not shy away from more fully addressing the lived experiences and exploitation of enslaved workers within the Roman economy. Moreover, Ferris’ declaration from the outset that he wrote the book in part because studies of Roman work have often ‘not extended to the workers themselves’ (14) perhaps accidentally belittles the ground-breaking recent research of scholars like Steven J. R. Ellis (2018), Claire Holleran (2012), Miko Flohr (2016), Cameron Hawkins (2016), Seth Bernard (2018) and Koenraad Verboven. Far too many predecessors are cast en masse as inaccessible and too economically focused. The problem with The Dignity of Labour is, then, not that it fails to provide dignitas to Roman workers. It succeeds in this endeavour without doubt. Rather, in framing the book as a wholly original approach to the world of Roman workers, it is perhaps the modern scholars of ancient labour who are denied the dignity they deserve.
