No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 February 2005
Kathryn Babayan attempts to illuminate the way Persianate modes of consciousness, ethos, and religious practices have persisted in the Iranian world against hegemonic Arab Muslim (Sunni) cultural constructs. A “calcified” Persianate structure of thought and experience of the sacred, “entrenched for generations,” according to Babayan, has informed history, historical memory, and identity among Alid loyalists and “heterodox” groups labeled by shari

a-minded authority as ghulāt. Drawing on a number of theoretical and conceptual elements, particularly Yuri Lotman's emphasis on heterogeneity, Babayan emphasizes polyphonic traits and disharmony within what is misconceived as the collective culture of a single language. Along with investing the notion of heteroglossia, Babayan explores continuities and disjunction with the Iranian “past” and ways in which this “past” blended with the Islamic “present” or became transmuted. She explains historical change largely on the basis of a binary model, a dualist struggle between the religious landscape of late antiquity and a monotheist paradigm provided by Islam. Babayan draws historical links between “Safavid Islam” or “Qizilbash Islam” and earlier Alid movements, arguing that they all find expression in Persianate cultural constructs. Thus, she states that structural elements in the Qizilbash worldview in the 16th century “survive” in the Babi movement of the 19th century. Babayan adequately stresses the need to bring the narrative of “heterodox,” ghuluww groups to the center of Safavid history. The ghulāt version of spirituality and temporality empowers these groups against the dominant authority and challenges the official story of cosmology and faith.
This project may explain why the book is organized thematically rather than chronologically. Babayan argued that the early ghulāt of Islam entertained beliefs that continued throughout history to shape Shi

i and Sufi forms of experiencing the sacred, time, and prophecy. She argues that the religious symbolisms of ghuluww have vivid “Persian lineages” even when they appear in areas such as Bahrain and Syria. When she looks at the first century of Islamic rule, Babayan's conclusions are better argued than for later centuries. Her examination of Ferdowsi's Shahnameh, with its invocation of Mazdean cosmologies, is illuminating. But beyond this period, Babayan paints a static and somewhat oversimplified picture of Iranian history. Millenarianism is a global phenomenon, but it is unclear which manifestations of it are uniquely Persianate and which local social forces, material and spiritual, signaled its appearance and defined its particular Persianate flavor and color. Is the Qizilbash messianic revolt simply a prototype of revolts born out of a convergence of Mazdean (Persianate) and Abrahamic (Alid) apocalyptics? Moreover, there were different modes of consciousness during late antiquity, and they were undergoing change before the Arab Islamic invasion took place. Surely, there were internal societal changes in that world that pre-empted such developments, only to be augmented and hastened by the invasion. Not all modes of religious experience—be they of the Sasanid rulers or their subjects or even Jewish and Christian gnostics—were appropriated by advocates of heterodoxy in the Islamic era. That some of these modes appear in the Islamic era while others disappear is only partly caused by Arab Islamic political domination.
In Mystics, Monarchs and Messiahs, the complex and quite distinct circumstances that produced the shu

ūbiyya and the nuqtaviyya movements seem to collapse into one mythical moment—an anti-Islamic apocalyptic change that applies equally to “dispossessed Persians” in the 8th and 9th centuries and to betrayed Qizilbash Turks in the 16th century. When Babayan discusses the use of Zoroastrian legends and Alid themes in Abu Muslim Nameh, we are left in the dark as to the particular function of each of them beyond mustering a unified opposition to official Muslim interpretations. When discussing the fatwas that

Ali al-Karaki and his student Mir Hamavi issued against Abu Muslim's devotees and the debates surrounding the glorification of Abu Muslim, Babayan concludes that these debates are an enactment of a “millennium of friction” between two archetypal entities: the Alid ghulāt and legalistic Shi

ism. But surely fundamental changes have occurred between the social environment of such debates in the early Safavid period and those in the mid-17th century, as reflected, for instance, in the works of Mir Lawhi.
Without an analysis of the internal dynamics of Iranian history, all religious movements and ghuluww actors will look the same and mean the same, with a few variations on degrees of rejection and transmutation between the Iranian “past” and the Islamic “present.” The main problem with this is that it undermines the very nature of the “heteroglossia” that Babayan uses in this study and fails to unearth its dynamic expression and formations. The binary tension between an Iranian “past” and an Islamic “present” does not encompass the full reality of either Islam or what we label “heterodoxy.” The picture seems to me more of a creative redefinition and negotiation of that “past,” not a reproduction of a fixed set of immortal Persianate signs and symbols. We need an analysis of the multiple, changing heterodoxies as well as the Islams, the Shi

isms (tribal, rural, urban; folk and legalistic), and the Sunnisms in each historical period. Shi

i clerics such as al-Karaki sometimes faced accusations of ghuluww, and defended tabarra

iyyān against both Sunni and Shi

i clerics in Safavid and Ottoman territories—one group casting the practice as reckless, and the other as ghuluww. In addition, it is unclear how one is to identify what and who is “Persianate.” Babayan notes, for instance, that Qarmati Arabs entertained Persianate notions of cyclical time even though they did not invoke “the Iranian genealogies in which these precepts had converged.” Babayan defines “Persianate” as a multiracial cultural category, but it appears at times to be a religious category of a racial origin—namely, Alid/Shi

i/heterodox of Iranian qualities. There is also little consideration of socioeconomic factors. Does a Sunni Persian aristocrat from Qazvin share and have access to the same sets of cultural meanings as a Shi

i/Alid guildsman from Isfahan in the late 15th century?
Overall, Babayan's attempt to shift the emphasis from shari

a-based Islamic narratives to heterodox experiences in understanding Islamic history is a praiseworthy task, and a challenging one. Despite the questions I have raised, Babayan's study is a welcome attempt to integrate millenarianism and “unorthodox” notions of time and prophecy into the trajectory of Islamic history.