During the Qing dynasty (1644-1911), young boys and men voluntarily underwent emasculationFootnote 1 to become eunuchs. Envisioning a life of power and wealth working in proximity to the emperor or at the very least a job providing room and board, the benefits of emasculation appeared to outweigh the costs of genital mutilation. Once inside the palace though, new recruits faced the realities of the eunuch system, namely restrictions on their mobility, harsh working conditions, and punishments. Moreover, if a eunuch was unhappy with his work environment, he rarely had the option of quitting or leaving the system as terms of service were for life. During the Qing, eunuchs were not released from service unless they were deemed too ill or too old to serve.Footnote 2 For many eunuchs, running away from the palace provided a much quicker, albeit more dangerous, exit from the palace eunuch system.
Official records of palace eunuch flight, capture and confessions, and the punishments imposed on runaway eunuchs reveal that restricted mobility and harsh punishments often became too oppressive for the palace eunuch work force to endure. Faced with impending beatings for often minor infractions, for eunuchs, flight from the system represented an act of agency in a life filled with rules and regulations set by others. However, as will be seen, the difficulties that eunuchs faced trying to survive outside the system ensured that escape from the palace and attempting to sever ties with the eunuch system without authorisation would prove exceedingly difficult.
The abundance of cases of runaway eunuchs in the historical record reflects poorly on the Qing dynasty's treatment of its eunuchs and effectiveness at times in controlling its eunuch population. By exploring such cases, this paper aims to contribute to understandings of unfree status during the Qing and more broadly to the reconstruction of the social history of eunuchs. As the majority of palace eunuchs were illiterate, these reports give voice to eunuchs and reveal: (1) the tensions that characterised labour relations between the imperial household and its eunuch workforce and (2) that eunuch status does not fit neatly into the binary of free or unfree status, but rather is something more complicated that lies on the continuum in between.
Sources
Cases of eunuchs running away cited in this paper are based largely upon archival documents found in Beijing at the First Historical Archives and in Taipei at the National Palace Museum Library. Here, one can find an abundance of documents in the Secret Palace Memorials (Gongzhongdang 宮中檔) and the archives of the Grand Council (Junjichu 軍機處) which record cases of palace eunuchs running away during the Qing. While numerous, records of runaway eunuchs do not lend themselves to a statistical analysis of eunuch runaways (i.e. the numbers of eunuchs running away during particular reign periods or from different departments). The archives appear to have preserved interesting cases rather than lists of runaway eunuchs and those captured. With few documents detailing the numbers of runaway eunuchs at a given time, it remains unclear if the extant documents in the archives are complete or only those that have survived in the historical record. This lack of statistics also makes it difficult to ascertain how many eunuchs did not attempt to run away. Not all eunuchs wanted to leave the system. For eunuchs in the upper echelons of the eunuch hierarchy, life as a palace eunuch presented opportunities to amass power and wealth. However, this was life for a select few. As will be seen, for the majority of unranked eunuchs, those who made up the majority of eunuch runaways, life would have been quite different and much more challenging. Despite the lack of statistics on runaway eunuchs, these archival records are vital for understanding eunuch social history and labour relations within the Forbidden City.Footnote 3 In particular, confessions of runaway eunuchs provide scholars with one of the few instances in which we can hear eunuch voices and obtain first-hand information about their life experiences.
The Palace Eunuch System
The practice of emasculating males was intended to produce “the ideal servant”. As can be seen from the Chinese colloquial term for emasculation, chu jia 出家 (leaving home), genital mutilation was intended to sever more than body parts; the act also symbolised the destruction of former familial and social bonds.Footnote 4 The stigma of physical disfigurement from emasculation was considered to be so powerful that it would lead society to ostracise eunuchs and their families to disown them, thereby increasing the dependency of the eunuch upon his masters.Footnote 5 In sum, the social ostracism and reproductive death that accompanied genital amputation was intended to create a loyal and submissive workforce for the Chinese emperor and his household.
In reality, relying on eunuchs to serve the emperor and his court was not without its challenges. Well aware of the problems associated with employing eunuchs and their perceived contribution to the downfall of the Ming dynasty (1368-1644), the Manchus drastically reduced the number of palace eunuchs once they established the Qing dynasty (1644-1911) within China proper. The Manchus would only employ a fraction of the previous 100,000 Ming eunuchsFootnote 6 and officially limit palace eunuch numbers to 3,100 at a given time.
The Qing palace eunuch population would rise up to and fall below this maximumFootnote 7 throughout the dynasty as supply and demand rose and fell. In the late Qing, as a series of young emperors came to the throne, eunuchs were not needed in such large numbers as these emperors were too young to need harems. Qing regulations would also fluctuate throughout the dynasty as eunuch applicant requirements concerning age, ethnicity, native place, and form of emasculation (professional or self-emasculation) were eased or tightened according to supply and demand.Footnote 8 In the early years of the Qing dynasty, as the Manchus worked to establish their empire, they would continue to rely on traditional Manchu practices to staff their imperial household. With a well-established Manchu bondservant systemFootnote 9 in place, eunuchs were returned to the role they were uniquely qualified for, ensuring the purity of the imperial lineage and serving in the private apartments of the emperor. The services of eunuchs were seen as necessary for the functioning of the Qing imperial court but only if eunuchs were employed in reduced numbers, kept in menial positions, and managed well. As time progressed, these original guidelines were relaxed resulting in eunuchs working in a variety of roles within the palace but always with the caveat that they were to be prevented from rising in power and importance so as to prevent a resurgence of eunuch power as had occurred during the Ming dynasty.
The Qing imperial court distanced itself from the emasculation process, preferring to leave the practice of excising the external male genitalia to hereditary specialists (daozijiang 刀子匠) who operated outside the walls of the palace. The palace relied on these specialists to bring forth suitable candidates for selection by the palace. During the Qing dynasty, the majority of eunuch recruits had volunteered to become eunuchs.Footnote 10 The actual act of becoming a eunuch while termed “voluntary”, should be prefaced with the fact that when the specialist asked for consent before starting the procedure, by asking the soon-to-be-emasculate whether or not he would regret it, the parent(s) would respond on behalf of the child.Footnote 11 Once the parent's permission had been obtained, the specialist would proceed with the emasculation, an act that would physically mark the young male's body for life. While the Qing preferred eunuchs who had been emasculated prior to the onset of puberty, not all eunuch applicants met that criterion. Archival records show that the Qing did accept applicants who had undergone emasculation as adults.
Once selected to serve inside the Forbidden City, eunuchs found themselves ranked within a distinct hierarchy where only a select few managed to rise to positions of power. During the Qing, eunuch title and rank were as Evelyn Rawski notes, “highly stratified”,Footnote 12 with the chief eunuch occupying the position at the top of eunuch social pyramid. The next rung down was occupied by the assistant chief eunuchs (zongguan taijian 總管太監) who assisted their superior in the management of palace eunuchs.Footnote 13 Next came the supervisory eunuchs (shouling taijian 首領太監) and the assistant supervisory eunuchs (fushouling taijian 副首領太監). The majority of eunuchs, classified as taijian 太監, did not possess rank.
The “proximity” of a eunuch's duties to the emperor also determined his status.Footnote 14 Two main categories divided the palace eunuch work force: inner court eunuchs (neigong taijian 內宮太監) and outer court eunuchs (waiwei taijian 外圍太監). According to Tang Yinian, inner court eunuchs, averaging in number from 400–500 at a given time (or 20–25% of the palace eunuch population), served the emperor and his family.Footnote 15 Outer court eunuchs only indirectly served the imperial court and as a result had a lower status in eunuch society. While eunuchs and their families might have aspired to become wealthy and powerful, very few ever achieved such status.
The palace eunuch system was based on the premise that eunuchs were created to serve the emperor and his imperial court. As we will see, labour relations between eunuchs and their masters reveal tensions. According to Rawski, James Scott's analysis of domination and resistance exemplifies this relationship or the “silent struggle” between the emperor and the palace eunuch population. Rawski writes,
As long as the dominant group successfully projects the appearance of overwhelming coercive force, implicit rejections of the public discourse tend to remain underground. In the imperial discourse, eunuchs and bondservants should be hardworking and efficient, utterly loyal and devoted to the emperor. Yet the criminal cases display lazy, thieving, gossiping betrayers of the imperial trust, whose existence contradicts the central tenet of the Qing social order, namely that the emperor's persona commands complete obedience.Footnote 16
While from the emperor's point of view, some eunuchs undoubtedly did “betray the imperial trust”, cases of runaway eunuchs reveal there is more to the story; here one finds clues to eunuchs’ motivations behind their actions. As palace eunuchs spent the majority of their lives behind the walls of the Forbidden City, many endeavoured to balance their expected submissiveness with a degree of agency in their own lives. Flight from the system was just one of the ways eunuchs did just that.Footnote 17 Running away, for many eunuchs, was a direct response to their treatment by their employers. The following analysis is designed to take the reader through the course of a eunuch's flight from the palace, commencing with possible escape routes and ending with his capture and punishment.
Running Away: Eunuch Escape Routes
Little information appears in the historical record concerning eunuch escape routes. Due to the highly restrictive nature of entry and exit from the Forbidden City, eunuchs intending to flee from the palace had to look for opportunities to facilitate their escape. Running errands such as going to buy vegetablesFootnote 18 or wontons often provided eunuchs with the pretext they needed to get beyond the watchful eye of their superiors and outside of the palace walls.
Going to have their head shaved by one of the barbers who set up shop outside the palace walls also created opportunities for eunuch flight.Footnote 19 The frequency with which eunuchs shaved their heads before running away is intriguing. Eunuchs, like other men in Qing society, wore their hair in a queue drawn from the hair at the top of the head (a style that requires the front and sides of the head to be regularly shaven). Xin Xiuming, a eunuch during the late Qing, notes in his recollections that eunuchs of the inner court could visit the barber as well as have something to eat at one of the shops (tatan 他坦) that lined the western river located outside the Inner Right Gate (Neiyoumen 內右門).Footnote 20 One can speculate that these tatan, located outside the walls of inner court, might have provided eunuchs with an excuse for leaving the heavily guarded residence of the emperor and his family and placed them one step closer to their attempted unauthorised exit from the palace.Footnote 21
Eunuchs also ran away while on leave from the palace. During the reign of Jiaqing (1796-1820), the failure of eunuchs to report for duty after having been on leave became such a problem that the emperor stipulated that eunuchs were to have an escort to and from the location they would be staying at during their leave.Footnote 22 However, these measures did not prevent eunuchs from escaping during the interim. This problem persisted into the Xianfeng reign period; in XF6 (1856), Li Dongji, a twenty-two-year-old (sui 歲)Footnote 23 Yuanping native serving as a eunuch in the Yuanmingyuan 圓明園, requested leave and ran away for the second time.Footnote 24 During the same year it was reported that Zhang Ming, a forty-six-year-old eunuch in the service of the Skillfully-worked Jade House (Yulinglongguan) in the Yuanmingyuan, had still not returned from leave. This was also his second time running away.Footnote 25
The palace considered eunuch flight as a dereliction of duty and immediately launched searches for missing eunuchs. Descriptions of the runaway's face and body (mianmao shenzhong 面貌身中, also known as a face placard mianmao tie 面貌帖) provide glimpses into how the Qing endeavoured to capture escaped eunuchs. It is interesting to note that aside from mentioning the colour of a eunuch's facial skin and whether or not it was pockmarked, the remainder of the description detailed only the clothing or uniform the eunuch would have been wearing at the time of his escape. For example, Li Yi, a eunuch from the Palace of Benevolent Prospect (Jingrengong 景仁宮), was described as having: “a yellow face, and wearing a spring hat, a blue cotton robe, a green cloth unlined outer coat, and green cloth boots”.Footnote 26 In another case, escaped eunuch Wang Xiangshui's description lists the following information: “wearing a spring hat, a blue robe and green outer coat, spring cloth boots, and white skin without pock marks”.Footnote 27 The lack of distinguishing physical characteristics besides skin colour or blemishes suggests that the eunuch may have been seen in social rather than physical terms in this instance. This is noteworthy since a eunuch's social role and identity stemmed from the physical feature he lacked, namely his genitalia. However, here a eunuch's clothing rather than physical features differentiated him from the rest of the population. In the case of escaped eunuch Zhang Feng, the authorities were told to circulate his age, appearance, clothing, disguise and coloring (nianmao yizhuang yanse 年貌衣裝顏色) to help aid in his capture.Footnote 28 In QL28/6/chu3 (July 13, 1763), Chao De, a eunuch assigned to the Yuanmingyuan, was so bold as to escape by horse. The thirty-five-year-old Yuanping native's escape caused an announcement to be circulated noting his clothing and his mode of transportation, namely riding a black horse.Footnote 29 In each of these cases, wanted posters focus on a eunuch's clothing more than his physical attributes.
When contrasted with descriptions of non-emasculated fugitives, this becomes even more apparent. For example, the Qing Code of 1740 required authorities to provide a detailed record of a fugitive's age, appearance, place of origin, the presence of facial hair and/or a mole, etc.Footnote 30 According to Susan Naquin, during the Qing, lists of wanted criminals contained “. . . the name (including aliases), age, residence, physical description, and crime of men wanted by the government. Pictures might even be drawn to aid in the identification”.Footnote 31 For example, the fugitive Liu Shih-ming (aka Lo Shu-t'ou) who had escaped from exile was described as, “. . . 39 sui, of medium build, of light complexion, without pockmarks, with slight whiskers and a tattoo on his face (branding him as an exiled criminal)”.Footnote 32
More likely, the absence of detailed physical markers on eunuch runaway notices may be attributed to the fact that eunuch physical characteristics were a given in Qing society. While young eunuchs could and often did pass as non-eunuchs, adult eunuchs would have exhibited physical characteristics that marked them as such. Adult eunuchs who had been emasculated prior to the onset of puberty would have had extremely low levels of testosterone and would therefore have lacked secondary sexual characteristics. These eunuchs would have exhibited a lack of facial hair, high voices, longer hands and fingers, and increased height.Footnote 33 If a eunuch was still a child at the time of running away, many of these markers would not have appeared yet and the young eunuch might have been able to successfully pass as a non-emasculated boy. However, in the case of older eunuchs, the above-mentioned physical changes may have made eunuchs appear more noticeable in a crowd. Such physical markers may have contributed to the arrest of the eunuch Bao Desheng. During DG22 (1842), while attempting to flee exile in Dasheng Wula 大牲烏拉,Footnote 34 Bao aroused the suspicions of the Shanhaiguan border guards. What gave Bao away? According to the arresting guards, he simply “looked like a eunuch (xing si taijian 形似太監)”.Footnote 35 In the end, official descriptions of eunuch runaways based on their attire may have proven useless since as we will see later, eunuchs often sold their clothes once outside the palace in order to obtain money for food.
One disguise that did prove successful for some runaway eunuchs was to pretend they were monks by shaving their heads and donning religious attire. Since eunuchs often retreated to monasteries after retirement,Footnote 36 the presence of eunuchs at temples or among society would not have aroused the suspicions of the authorities. For example, Zhu Xiang, a eunuch in the Imperial Library, tried to hide so that he wouldn't have to endure a beating. Unable to find a hiding place, Zhu cut off his queue, took the alias of Li Fang, and joined the staff of the Hall of Ten Thousand Virtues (Wanshandian 萬善殿) as a monk.Footnote 37
Surviving Outside the System
While records indicate that many eunuchs succeeded in the initial act of running away, surviving outside of the palace walls and/or the eunuch system proved more difficult. As stated above, the eunuch system was based upon the premise that emasculation rendered Han Chinese males into ideal servants who were totally reliant on their imperial masters. Emasculation marked the body and made eunuchs into social outcastes and thus increased a eunuch's reliance on his master.Footnote 38 As a result, eunuchs would have found it very difficult to survive outside of the eunuch system. The high instances of repeat offenders in cases of eunuch flight, especially cases in which eunuchs had run away up to five or six times, suggests that providing for themselves while on the run, evading capture, and ultimately surviving outside the system proved challenging.Footnote 39
Once outside of the palace walls, the eunuch's immediate concerns were with obtaining travel money and food and avoiding arrest. In their confessions, captured eunuchs repeatedly mention selling their clothes in order to have money to buy food. During JQ24 (1819), five-time runaway Sun Yongan, ran out of money and fearing arrest, turned himself in. In the following deposition, Sun recounts the events leading up to his fifth escape attempt and his surrender to the authorities:
I am a forty-four sui native of Wuqing District. Formerly, when I ran away for the fourth time, I was sent to Heilongjiang to be a slave. During the ninth month of JQ18 (Sept. 24 - Oct. 23, 1813), having completed my six year term of exile, I was freed and sent back in to the Department of Ceremonial. Later, I was transferred to the Cooking Fire Department to serve. This year, my shouling taijian [supervisory eunuch] Xu Jinxi sent me to accompany the hunt (suiwei). I did not have the money to buy a saddle or the [necessary] clothing and I could not borrow [the money] because I am usually not on friendly terms with my co-workers, and since [my] starting date was drawing near and [I] still had not yet borrowed [the money], I came up with the idea to run away. This year on fifteenth day of the second month (3/18), I ran away to a neighbourhood outside of the Gate of Proclaimed Military Strength (Xuanwumen) where I found a small inn to stay and hide out in. Every day I moved and was without a fixed location. When I met people who questioned me, I lied and said that I was a eunuch on leave from an outer palace (waifu) who was unable to enter the city because it was late. Since it appeared that I had already used up the money [I obtained] from selling the clothes off my back to buy food and fearing that the punishment would be harsher if I was captured, I turned myself in to the Department.Footnote 40
Clearly, Sun had no set destination in mind other than leaving the palace when he escaped. Never staying in one location more than one day, Sun's primary focus revolved around avoiding capture and feeding himself while on the run. Attempting to evade the authorities, Sun did not find other forms of employment but rather relied on money he obtained from selling the clothes off his back to support himself.
Eunuchs who chose to disguise themselves as monks appear to have had greater success in sustaining themselves for longer periods of time. Pretending to be itinerant monks, eunuchs would have met both the needs of eluding the authorities and obtaining food (through begging for alms). Other eunuchs such as the fifteen-year-old runaways, Zhao Rong and Zhao Yu, prolonged their freedom by hiring themselves out as labourers – cutting bramble, bundling sorghum, chopping firewood, and cutting grass.Footnote 41 Due to their young age, these eunuchs may not have exhibited the distinctive physical characteristics of eunuchs yet and found it easier to blend in with society and to obtain work outside of the system.
Some eunuchs tried to evade the authorities and lengthen their stay outside the palace by hiding out in relative's homes. For example, one eunuch stayed with his adopted son's daughter.Footnote 42 In another case a eunuch, who had been exiled for stealing from his employer, a prince, ran back to the capital and hid out at his uncle's house until poverty forced him to apply once again to become a palace eunuch.Footnote 43 However, a runaway's relatives were often reluctant to harbour the fugitive, especially one who worked for the imperial court. As will be seen, families of runaway eunuchs, whether they were involved in helping the eunuch evade capture or not, faced collective punishment. Some eunuch relatives may have never known that their eunuch relative was a fugitive as some runaways merely told them that they were out on leave.
Other eunuchs extended their period outside the palace walls by working in the establishments of princes, dukes, and grand ministers. Well aware of this practice, the Qing attempted to prevent runaway eunuchs from looking at princely establishments as safe havens. The Qinding zongrenfu zeli (Imperially authorised laws and regulations of the court of the imperial clan) announced that in JQ7 (1802), Hu Jinyu ran away for the second time, took an alias, and applied to work for a prince. After his arrest, Hu was exiled to Heilongjiang to serve as a military slave.Footnote 44 Later, the Qing stipulated that when receiving eunuch applicants, princes, dukes and grand ministers must look into the eunuch's circumstances and contact the Imperial Household Department to ensure that the applicant was not a runaway.Footnote 45
The practice of eunuchs running away from service at the palace only to then apply to serve as a eunuch at a princely establishment may have been attributed to the inability of eunuch runaways to sustain themselves outside of the system. In comparison to life as a palace eunuch, the salary of a eunuch in the service of an imperial prince (qinwang 親王), commandery prince (junwang 君王), beile or beile prince (beizi 貝子) was very low.Footnote 46 Since princely establishments varied in size and wealth, the salaries of eunuchs employed by princes would also have varied.Footnote 47 Moreover, one can assume that the prestige associated with serving in a princely household was certainly less than that of a eunuch assigned to the imperial court.
Sources from the late Qing reveal that life was not necessarily better for eunuchs serving in princely households. Pu Jie'sFootnote 48 recollection of an incident involving a eunuch employed by his family during the late Qing reveals that beating the servants was also a part of the daily routine in princely households. On one occasion, Pu Jie's mother ordered a eunuch to bring her some sugar (tang2 糖). Thinking that she said, “soup” (tang1 湯), he brought her a bowl of soup. That night, the eunuch received several tens of blows from the large flattened bamboo (daban 大板) for his mistake.Footnote 49 “[Thus] beaten, he could not sit down on a stool for several days, [and] at night when it was time to sleep, [he] had to lie down on his side or face down on the bed.Footnote 50 Like palace eunuchs, these eunuchs also lived in oppressive surroundings and operated under the same type of master/apprentice system in which collective responsibility ensured the perpetuation of beatings and the suppression of the eunuch population.Footnote 51
Service in a princely establishment did offer the eunuch some advantages. Restrictions on the eunuch's mobility would have certainly been relaxed giving eunuchs more freedom. Moreover, serving outside of the palace, eunuchs could have continued to have contact with society. It remains unclear how much palace eunuchs would have known about the lives of their counterparts serving in the princely establishments. The cases presented here reveal that for some eunuch runaways, princely households provided a source of food and money and a place to hide from authorities all of which heightened their ability to survive outside of the palace eunuch system.
Capture
The frequency of eunuch flight suggests that palace security was not without its flaws, however the numbers of eunuchs who were captured reveals that surviving and remaining hidden from the authorities outside the palace was challenging. Due to the nature of the source material, namely official notices of eunuch flight and documents concerning eunuch capture, it remains unclear how many eunuchs succeeded in permanently running away from the system. Sources in the imperial record either alerted people to a eunuch's flight from the palace so the authorities could be on the look-out, or recorded the confessions of eunuchs who had already been captured or turned themselves in.
Runaway eunuchs who managed to get outside the palace walls faced many obstacles, the first of which was the Inner City police. Having memorised the faces of the inhabitants of the ten-household groups assigned to them, Inner City patrolmen could easily have spotted anyone who did not belong to the group, such as “persons of unclear background” and “idlers”.Footnote 52 Runaway eunuchs would have undoubtedly raised suspicions. Those who made it to the Outer City stood a greater chance of “disappear[ing] into the crowd and escap[ing] official notice” since this part of the city was “far less heavily policed”.Footnote 53 However, even to reach this point, eunuchs would have had to pass through numerous gates and check points many of which had jails on site for holding suspicious people passing through.Footnote 54 Without a travel pass (luyin 路引) and I.D. card (zhizhao 執照) issued by the Imperial Household Department, runaways would have found it exceedingly difficult to pass through the city unnoticed.Footnote 55 George Carter Stent writing during the late Qing, mentions the presence of a special police corps, called the Palace Squad (Neidaban'er 內大班兒) whose duty it was to capture runaway eunuchs.Footnote 56 Stent notes,
The men composing this force are not eunuchs themselves, but know all the eunuchs of the palace; and it is rare that one of them succeeds in escaping, for no sooner is the flight of one reported than the members of the force — (who are adepts at disguises, and may be considered detectives) spread themselves all over the city, and speedily recapture the deserter. . . .Footnote 57
In sum, the tight security within the capital created many obstacles to impede eunuch escape and greatly contributed to the capture of most runaways.
Fear of the punishments waiting for them if captured led many runaways to even turn themselves in. Understanding that once captured they would receive a punishment more severe than the beating they might have fled, some eunuchs created elaborate lies to avoid punishment. During the reign of the Kangxi emperor (1662-1722), Cui Zilu a eunuch in the Hall of High Heaven's music troop, was very familiar with the Qing punishment system. In KX53 (1714), Cui had dropped his flute while playing it and was sentenced to forty blows from the heavy bamboo rod and transferred to the Department of Ceremonial (Zhangyisi 掌儀司). Three months later, fearing that he would receive a beating for not studying well, he fled the palace but was caught. In order to avoid punishment for running away, Cui first lied in his confession, claiming,
I used to be a eunuch in the service of the Hall of High Heaven's music company. On the first day of the third month of the 52nd year (April 14, 1714), I dropped my flute while playing it and received forty blows from the heavy bamboo and was issued a discharge certificate and sent back to my native place. I sold my certificate to my Department of Ceremonial co-worker, Cui Jinchao for five taels. When I hired myself out for work, I was arrested. I am really not a runaway eunuch. . . .Footnote 58
In the end, Cui revealed the truth and was sentenced to wear the cangue for three months and to receive 100 blows.
Punishment
The imperial court did not take eunuchs running away from the palace lightly. A runaway eunuch faced punishments varying in severity according to the length of time spent outside of the palace walls, where he fled to, whether he was captured or turned himself in, and how many times he had run away previously. For example, the Qinding gongzhong xianxing zeli (Imperially authorised laws and regulations of conduct within the palace),Footnote 59 hereafter referred to as the QDGZXXZL, records that first time offenders who turned themselves in would receive sixty blows from the flattened bamboo (ban) and be sent back in to serve with a reduction in food and salary for one year. First time offenders who were caught and second time offenders who turned themselves in would receive sixty blows from the flattened bamboo and be sent to WudianFootnote 60 to cut grass for one year. Second time offenders who turned themselves in one of the times they had run away would receive eighty blows from the flattened bamboo and be sent to Wudian to cut grass for one and a half years. Second time offenders who were captured in both attempts would receive 100 blows from the flattened bamboo and be sent to Wudian to cut grass for two years. As the number of times the eunuch ran away increased so did the number of blows from the bamboo and the length of time cutting grass.
These strict punishments did not prevent eunuchs from repeatedly running away. Clearly, the punishments were not an effective deterrent if it was necessary to have specific regulations for eunuchs who had run away three, four, or even five times. For example, the QDGZXXZL states, eunuchs who ran away three, four, or five times, no matter whether they turned themselves in or not, when caught were sentenced to 100 blows from the flattened bamboo and sent to Wudian to cut grass for three, four, and five years respectively. When the term of punishment was fulfilled, these repeat offenders were re-employed by the Qing but restricted to positions in the outer court. Concern about security leaks and eunuch loyalty after they had been exiled and had the opportunity to be in contact with people outside the palace led to prohibitions against exiled eunuchs from serving in the inner court.Footnote 61
Sentencing eunuchs to perform manual labour such as cutting grass appears to have only increased the desire of some eunuchs to flee. Eunuchs arrested for running away from Wudian before completing their sentences and eunuchs who had fulfilled their five year sentences of cutting grass only to run away again were sentenced to wear the cangue in perpetuity. This was not the case with the above-mentioned Zhang Fu indicating that the system allowed for flexibility in sentencing runaway eunuchs. Four-time offenders, who ran away from Wudian, would receive even more beatings and be sent to serve as slaves to regular soldiers in Wula for three years.
Running away to destinations such as Henan, Shandong, Shanxi and Heilongjiang, Jilin, and Fengtian (Dongsansheng) elicited even stricter punishments from the government. All eunuchs who ran away to these places, regardless of the number of times they ran away or whether or not they had been captured or had turned themselves in, were sentenced to wear the cangue for a year and sent to Heilongjiang to serve as slaves to officials.Footnote 62 In addition, if there was an amnesty, these eunuchs were not to be pardoned. As seen earlier, such sentences were usually reserved for repeat offenders who had run away from exile. The harsher punishments for eunuchs who ran away to these destinations can be partially attributed to the prohibition against Chinese immigration to Manchuria, a policy that aimed to both maintain Manchu political control and lessen sinicisation in the area.Footnote 63
Eunuch natives of Zhili who fled back to their home province also faced closer scrutiny and harsher punishments. Eunuchs who had run back to Zhili were to be closely questioned. Eunuchs found to have lied in their confessions would have their punishments increased in severity by one degree. Eunuchs who ran away to departments or counties within Zhili which were located more than 500 li Footnote 64 from their native places, regardless of whether they had been captured or turned themselves in, would be sentenced to wear the cangue for six months and be sent to Dasheng Wula and given to an official as a slave for three years.
Eunuchs exiled to the remote edges of the empire even ran away from these distant locales. During KX54 (1715), the Imperial Household Department noted that eunuch Li Fang, previously exiled to Weng Mountain for gambling, broke free from his iron chains and fled. Although the officials from the Imperial Household Department recommended sentencing Li to wear a large cangue weighing fifty jin Footnote 65 (approximately 33 pounds) and incarceration in the city gate prison with no possibility of release, the emperor ordered that Li be excused from wearing the cangue and delivered back to Weng Mountain.Footnote 66 As the number of repeat offenses increased or the eunuch ran away from his location of exile so did the remoteness of his next exile destination. Eunuchs who fled from Wula received sentences of exile to Heilongjiang.
According to Tang Yinian, during the reigns of Qianlong (1736-1795), Tongzhi (1862-1874), and Guangxu (1875-1908), eunuchs ran away in large numbers.Footnote 67 It remains unclear though whether or not this statement is based upon the numbers of documents that have survived in the historical record from these periods or if in fact there were more eunuchs escaping during these periods.Footnote 68 As the Qianlong emperor is often descripted as relying on “coercive and punitive”Footnote 69 measures to manage his eunuch staff, one could assume that Qianlong's management style may have contributed to the higher number of eunuchs fleeing during his reign. In contrast, Kutcher, in his study of Yuanmingyuan eunuchs, argues that eunuchs stationed at this palace had less restrictions placed on their mobility, thus making it easier for them to run away.Footnote 70 In either case, as more and more eunuchs fled, their contact with society increased and thus so did the likelihood of the realities of eunuch life becoming common knowledge. Their illusions of the eunuch lifestyle shattered, many eunuch applicants may have reconsidered their decision to become a eunuch which in turn may have contributed to a decrease in the eunuch supply. Faced with a demand for eunuchs that exceeded the supply, the Qing relaxed the age and native place restrictions and filled vacancies with eunuchs taken from the princely households.Footnote 71
The failure of supply to meet demand during this period may also have necessitated leniency in the punishment of runaways. Despite the severity of the punishments for runaways as listed in the QDGZXXZL, not all eunuchs served their entire sentences. A record from the First Historical Archives in Beijing suggests that runaways might be sentenced to strict punishments only to have their sentences reduced and be sent back into the palace to serve.Footnote 72 Spared from wearing the cangue in perpetuity, six-time runaways Li Shoutong and Zhang Fujun were resentenced according to the legal precedent and discharged from service after wearing the cangue for a period of only four years. Moreover, three-time runaways sent to Wudian to cut grass for three years, Wu Degui and Jia Defu had their sentences reduced to 100 blows after which they were sent back to the palace to serve in the outer court. Records from the Xianfeng reign period even reveal that five-time runaways were sent back to serve at the palace, albeit restricted to service in the outer court, after only four years in exile in Heilongjiang.Footnote 73
The possibility of obtaining their freedom from the system by paying off their bondage upon reaching their destination of exile and slavery also motivated some eunuchs to run away. In his work on the Manchurian frontier, Robert H.G. Lee notes that criminals exiled to Kirin (Jilin) could purchase their freedom from their masters.Footnote 74 An imperial decree from 1810 reveals:
Eunuchs who were exiled for criminal causes also lived in freedom after paying their ransoms. Some of them bought business properties. When they were released, they deliberately recommitted crimes in order to be sent back to exile. Thus the intent of the national code for the strict punishment of criminals was being grossly violated through the practice of private redemption, which mitigated the criminals’ fear of punishment and encouraged them to look upon the land of exile as paradise.Footnote 75
Informed of this loophole in the exile system, the edict instructed the military governor to prohibit the purchase of freedom by exiled criminals.
Eunuch Unfree Status
The abundance of cases of eunuch flight by repeat offenders in the historical record reveals the ineffectiveness of the Imperial Household Department's policies aimed at stemming the outward flow of eunuchs with harsh punishments. While the practice of reducing sentences for eunuch runaways may have been an immediate fix for the problem, it ultimately decreased the effectiveness of harsh punishments as a deterrent factor. The desire of eunuchs to escape the system continued unabated through the end of the Qing dynasty. After the fall of the dynasty in 1911, eunuchs ran away in great numbers.Footnote 76 The weakness of the imperial court and the new-found political rights of eunuchs as citizens of the Republic favoured the ultimate success of eunuchs in their escape attempts.Footnote 77
The use of slavery as a punishment for runaway eunuchs also reveals the complexity of eunuch unfree status during the Qing. The majority of eunuchs during the Qing voluntarily underwent emasculation and then applied for service as an imperial court eunuch. Once admitted into the system, eunuch terms of servitude were essentially for life with discharge authorised only for illness, old age, or death. Eunuchs who chose to make an unauthorised exit from the system faced two options: suicide or running away.Footnote 78
Eunuchs received salaries but lived out their lives governed by strict rules regarding deportment and mobility. Eunuchs assigned to the Forbidden City found themselves subject to more restricted rules than those assigned to other palaces or princely establishments due to the palace being the seat of imperial power. These rules when coupled with an environment in which corporal punishment was used as a tool to ensure compliance made daily life difficult for many eunuchs, especially low-level eunuchs, to endure.
Moreover, the term used to refer to eunuchs discharged from the palace eunuch system, weimin taijian 為民太監 (commoner eunuch), clearly reveals that eunuchs were clearly regarded as different from the rest of the population. The inability of eunuchs to leave the system of their own volition before being deemed unfit to perform their duties suggests that they were not free. However, the use of slavery as a form of punishment for runaway eunuchs further indicates that there were degrees of unfree status during the Qing. In other words, punishment of banishment to the frontiers of the empire to serve as a slave was considered more restrictive than the life of a palace eunuch.
Motivations
Clearly aware that harsh punishments were not stemming the flow of eunuchs fleeing the palace, those conducting the investigations appear to have been very interested in the reasons why eunuchs fled. The imperial court feared that eunuch runaways could become involved with people on the outside who might wish to utilise or exploit the eunuch's knowledge of and access to the Forbidden City to gain entry into the palace or to obtain classified information. Alluding to this, the interrogators of five-time runaway, Sun Yongan, asked him whether or not he had owed money and thus been coerced into running away.Footnote 79 This suspicion extended even to eunuchs in the service of princely establishments who applied to work in the palace. In the case of Gao Sheng 高升, a eunuch who ran away from his exile in Wula (for stealing clothing from his employer) only to return to the capital to work as an inner court eunuch, the Imperial Household Department desired to know who had encouraged Gao to obtain employment within the palace.Footnote 80 This fear of eunuchs acting as counterintelligence agents proved well founded in 1813 during the Eight Trigrams Uprising in which eunuchs facilitated the entry of rebels into the palace.Footnote 81
While interrogations of captured runaways clearly reveal an interest in ascertaining whether or not the eunuch could pose a security risk, they also show that the Imperial Household Department was well aware of the more common causes behind flight. For example, during JQ23 (1818), Jingshifang 敬事房Footnote 82 officials closely questioned eunuch Jihua about why he fled: “. . . was it that his shouling taijian had cursed at [him], or that he had gotten into a fight with eunuchs or others, or that he had habitually broken the rules against drinking alcohol and gambling, etc”.Footnote 83 Kutcher argues that runaway eunuchs, when questioned about their reasons for running away, would choose “from a repertoire of excuses for their misdoings that conformed to the expectations that others had of them”.Footnote 84 As Kutcher notes, the circumstances in which the confessions were made or recorded are unknown. This study finds that without this information and more importantly, any evidence to suggest otherwise, eunuch professed motives, rather than being “forumulaic”, actually reveal that eunuchs were running away due to problems endemic to the eunuch system. The repetition of eunuch motivations for running away suggests that reasons such as fear of being beaten were indicative of problems eunuchs faced in their daily lives and those that were plaguing the eunuch system as a whole. Last, it is important to also recognise the purpose of recording these confessions in the first place. The imperial court's motives for ascertaining why eunuchs fled the system did not stem from a desire to improve the welfare of the eunuch population but rather the need to maintain the security of the emperor and his family.
This distrust of eunuchs appears evident in searches to make sure nothing had been stolen after a eunuch had fled. Memorials often cite whether or not official items or the eunuch's personal effects were missing.Footnote 85 These searches of the premises suggest that eunuchs fled because they committed theft. The historical record does reveal that eunuchs commonly fled after stealing items to avoid suffering the consequences for their crimes. Eunuchs such as Ye Fu fled after failing to cover up instances of petty theft. In QL35 (1770), Ye Fu, otherwise known as Xiaode, a eunuch in the service of the Summer Palace's kennel, turned himself in after attempting to flee. While Ye's shouling taijian, Wang Lin was away accompanying the hunt, Ye had used 2,000 wen of the kennel's operating budget (gongfei qian). It is unclear what Ye spent this money on. In an effort to replace the money, Ye stole Wang's silk outer coat and sold it, replacing six strings of cash. Still short of the remainder of the money and fearing that Wang would want his coat upon his return, Ye fled and hid out for two days. Despite Ye's confession about running away after misappropriating money and stealing from his superior in order to cover it up, the memorialist, a Vice Provincial Commander-in-chief (futidu) remained suspicious of the motives behind Ye's flight and feared there were other factors involved.Footnote 86
Suspicions of eunuchs fleeing after committing theft were not unfounded. Eunuch Ma Yu stole silver vessels to pawn, was captured, and sent to Heilongjiang to serve as an armoured soldier's slave. Ma's family was forced to pay for the items he had stolen. Palace of Earthly Tranquility eunuch Ma Sheng fled after stealing several pearls. Ma later turned himself in and was exiled to Dasheng Wula to be a slave.Footnote 87 The possibility also exists that the items were stolen in the first place to do just that, to facilitate an escape from the palace by providing funds for travelling expenses and food. Some eunuchs during the Daoguang reign period were arrested after having run away from the palace when accused of selling opium.Footnote 88
In addition to beatings, Tang Yinian attributes eunuch flight to a desire to see the outside world. Eunuchs who entered the palace at an early age essentially grew up inside the palace walls. Tang argues that later on in life these eunuchs desired to get out of the palace. Leave from the palace and time outside the palace only increased this desire.Footnote 89
Eunuch runaways appear to have been more desperate than this. The historical record shows that more commonly eunuchs ran away to avoid being beaten or having to deal with harsh working conditions. Eunuchs who confessed that they couldn't bear the suffering anymore clearly reveal that they just wanted out of the system. Three-time runaway Yang Dehai ran away from his punishment of cutting grass at Wudian because his “. . . daily grain ration was not enough and he was suffering”.Footnote 90 In the KX55 (1716) case of Li Guoqin, a runaway from Rehe, he states: “Since my leg was hurting I requested a leave of absence from my zongguan taijian, Chen Qitai. My shouling taijian, Wang Taiping, urged me to return [to work] and rudely insulted and cursed at me. I got in an argument with him. Fearing being beaten by him. . . I ran away”.Footnote 91 Other eunuchs such as Zhao Rong, a fifteen sui eunuch learning a trade in the Prospect Hill's palace lower school (Jingshan xiaoneixue) was struck 29 times with the flat bamboo (ban) by shouling Shao Guoqin after which he became depressed. Footnote 92 Zhao, feeling melancholy after his punishment and desiring to avoid any future beatings, readily agreed to accompany two of his fellow eunuch co-workers who were planning an escape.Footnote 93 Eunuchs such as Gao Jingrui, a eunuch in the Jingshifang even ran away due to losing his eunuch supervisor's dog.Footnote 94 Fear of being punished for returning late from running errands outside of the palace also contributed to the high incidence of eunuch flight.Footnote 95
Labour Relations during the Qing
Cases of eunuchs running away from the palace provide important insight into labour relations between the Imperial Household Department and the eunuch workforce. Confessions from runaway eunuchs reveal that the eunuch hierarchy reinforced a management system based upon coercion and punishment. Eunuch runaways were commonly from among the largest population of palace eunuchs, those who were known simply as taijian who at the bottom tier of the eunuch hierarchy did not carry any rank. While the Imperial Household Department was officially in charge of the management of eunuchs, they relied heavily on the upper echelons of the eunuch hierarchy to supervise the majority of these unranked eunuchs.
Beatings of eunuchs at the bottom of the eunuch hierarchy by their eunuch supervisors (shouling taijian) reveal that violence was a frequent management tool within the palace. While intended to be a deterrent to keep the eunuch workforce in line, it often proved too much for some eunuchs to bear and contributed to deteriorating labour relations within the palace. While eunuch beatings by their imperial court masters was a common practice, cases of eunuch flight add to our understanding of corporal punishment within the palace. The prevalence of unranked eunuchs running away from the system suggests that Qing's reliance on collective responsibility created a culture in which eunuch supervisors abused their subordinates. In sum, eunuch upon eunuch beatings and fear of collective punishment were a practice used by the palace in its attempt to control its eunuch population by intimidation and force.
Descriptions of life within the palace by palace women and even the last emperor, Pu Yi, cast the realities of life within the palace in a negative light. In A Palace Woman Talks about her Recollections of the Past (Gongnu tan wanglu), Rong'er, a palace woman during the late Qing recalls, “In reality, there was no happiness within the palace. . . People were just like wooden people, going along according to the rules, nobody being allow to make a mistake or differ”.Footnote 96 In his autobiography, From Emperor to Citizen, Pu Yi provides insight into the lives of eunuchs, revealing that eunuchs would make offerings to the palace gods (snakes, foxes, weasels, and hedgehogs), the protectors of eunuchs, in hopes “. . . that the palace gods would protect them from the beatings and other forms of ill-treatment from which they often suffered”.Footnote 97
What do repeat offenders and laws addressing eunuchs running away up to six times say about Qing labour relations and management of palace eunuchs? Clearly, the palace's management style (characterised by beatings and corporal punishments) was not resolving the problem of eunuchs running away from the palace. The imperial court maintained a policy that dereliction of duty would not be tolerated. Harsh regulations and punishments were intended to show that the emperor's power was absolute and that any attempt to try to place one's independent will above the needs of the emperor and his family would be faced with swift punitive action. Such shows of force and dominance were not always effective.
Ultimately, runaway eunuchs created a drain on the system for skilled servants for the palace. During reign periods such as Daoguang in which supply was not meeting demand, harsh punishments were ineffective as deterrents and had to be relaxed in order to ensure that the imperial court had the necessary number of eunuchs. Security demands, however, dictated that repeat offenders could no longer serve within the inner court of the palace. Even these though could be relaxed if the demand for eunuchs outweighed the available supply.
Conclusion
The palace eunuch workforce served the imperial court in an oppressive work environment designed to ensure complete submission to the imperial will. Relying on coercion and punitive measures to manage its eunuch staff, the Imperial Household aimed to keep the palace eunuch population under control. Despite their efforts, the Imperial Household's management techniques and use of harsh punishments as deterrents for unwanted behaviour had the unintended result of becoming too oppressive for some eunuchs to bear. Han Chinese young boys and men voluntarily submitted themselves to undergo emasculation to apply for service as a palace eunuch. Once inside, some eunuchs who had initially wanted to enter the system soon desperately wanted out. Subject to frequent beatings, often restricted in their mobility, and deprived of the freedom to terminate their term of service of their own volition, running away presented eunuchs with a degree of agency rarely afforded to them in their daily lives.
During the Qing dynasty, eunuchs ran away repeatedly, some in excess of six times. The ability of eunuchs to escape from the palace and their duties suggest that the palace security was severely flawed. Running away appears to have been the easy part; what proved most difficult for runaway eunuchs was surviving outside of the system. Eunuchs who managed to get beyond the palace walls soon faced a host of obstacles which had the potential to impede their ability to sustain their escape: tight security within the capital, obtaining travelling expenses and food, and even the threat of receiving a harsher punishment if eventually captured as opposed to choosing to turn oneself in.
Despite the inherent difficulties in permanently running away from the system, eunuch flight continued unabated. Confessions from captured eunuchs reveal that for many eunuchs serving in the palace proved too restrictive and too oppressive to endure until old age or sickness enabled them to end their term of service. The repeated flight of eunuchs suggests that for some eunuchs, punishments such as a year of manual labour cutting grass in Wudian, were preferable to serving as eunuchs inside the palace. Eunuch confessions provide insights into the tense labour relations between eunuchs and their supervisors/superiors and overt acts of eunuch resistance to the system designed to keep them submissive. While flight from the palace empowered eunuchs and allowed them the opportunity to attempt to determine their own fate, this freedom often proved short-lived and led to much more oppression in the form of punishment. Concerns over the safety of the empire ensured that unauthorised exits from the system would be met with capture, followed by beatings, wearing the cangue, forced labour and in more severe cases, slavery and exile.
Cases of eunuch runaways also add to our understanding of unfree status during the Qing and reveal that in the case of eunuchs it was complicated. On the one hand, palace eunuchs collected salaries. Service in the palace even offered a small number of eunuchs opportunities for upward mobility. Eunuchs were not considered slaves but in many ways shared restrictions on their freedom and mobility like slaves. Moreover, eunuchs could not terminate their employment of their own volition. Eunuchs had few options for leaving the system; approved exits from the system such as sick leave, retirement, and death were all determined by others.Footnote 98 To the Qing, eunuchs occupied a type of unfree status outside of slavery as that classification was reserved as a punishment for repeat runaway offenders. Many eunuchs discovered only after entering the palace that life as a eunuch was much more restricted that they originally imagined. In an act of agency, some eunuchs attempted to determine their own exit from the system by running away from the palace. For eunuch runaways, this taste of freedom was only fleeting.
