Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T02:58:24.283Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Alternative risk-based levies in the pension protection fund for multi-employee schemes*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 June 2009

WEIXI LIU*
Affiliation:
Xfi Centre for Finance and Investment, University of Exeter Business School, Exeter
IAN TONKS*
Affiliation:
Xfi Centre for Finance and Investment, University of Exeter Business School, Exeter
*
(e-mail: W.Liu@ex.ac.uk)
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This paper estimates the risks of financial distress in UK universities, and uses these estimates to examine the basis of the annual levies paid to the UK's Pension Protection Fund by the Universities Superannuation Scheme, a multi-employer scheme covering 391 universities and related institutions. The paper compares the payments between the two alternative participating arrangements for multi-employer pension schemes to the PPF, namely last-man-standing and segmented levies. Using an Ohlson (1980) logit model to predict the financial distress risk for HE institutions, we find that financially distressed institutions are smaller, with higher leverage and lower earnings. By comparing the implied financial distress probabilities from the PPF risk-based levy using USS accounts with the simulated probabilities using our logit model, we estimate whether USS levies are fairly priced. Our estimates suggest that in 2006/07 USS member institutions appeared to be paying less than the fair risk-based levy. However, this is because during the initial phase of the PPF the risk-based levies were much lower as a proportion of the total levy than the intended steady-state values. The implication is that if USS had paid the same total levy but where the risk-based component was four fifths of the total, then USS would have been paying substantially more than its fair risk-based levy. In addition, by looking at the distributions of individual university risk-based levies under a segmented PPF arrangement, we find evidence of significant cross-subsidies under the current last-man-standing levy between participating USS institutions.

Information

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © 2009 Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Panel A:Funding council grants

Figure 1

Panel B:Regression variables

Figure 2

Table 2.Prediction results for the logit modelThe table represents the results for the logit regression described in equation (5) with dependent variable as Pr (ABNMLt=1|X), where X is the set of explanatory variables. ABNML is defined as in equation (4) and is the measure of financial distress. LNSIZE is the log of total book assets (TA). WCTA is the ratio of working capital to total assets. CLCA is current liabilities divided by current assets (CA). CLTA is current liabilities divided by total assets. LLTA is long-term liabilities divided by total assets. TLTA is the ratio of total liabilities (CL+LL) to total assets. EBITTA is the ratio of EBIT (earnings before interest and taxes) to total assets. NEGTWO is set to be equal to 1 if EBIT is negative for the last two years and 0 otherwise. GROW is the McKibben (1972) growth ratio defined in equation (6). Specification (I) is the basic model as in Ohlson (1980). Specification (III) adds current liabilities in the regression and specification (II) excludes working capital from specification (II). Specification (IV) removes the size variable to check whether there exists any size effect. Specification (V) splits TLTA into CLTA and TLTL to look at the effects of different liabilities. Specification VI adds in a pre-1992 university dummy. Specification (VII) is the one used in the simulation in Section 7. Robust t-statistics are reported in the parenthesis and *, **, *** stand for 10%, 5%, and 1% significance levels, respectively.

Figure 3

Table 3.Accuracy matrix for the logit modelThe table depicts the performance of the logit model defined in equation (5) by looking at how many observations are correctly identified by the model as being financially distressed or non-distressed. The empirical specification used is Specification (VII) in Table 2. Predicted is the projected financial conditions identified by the logit model using a cut-off point of 0.5. Actual is the financial condition of an institution defined by the value of ABNML.

Figure 4

Table 4.Pension Protection Fund underfunding levy

Figure 5

Table 5.Comparison of USS membership statisticsThis table shows the composition of USS membership and the USS members that can be matched with the HESA HE Finance Plus dataset for year 2005/06. Under the column labelled Number of institutions, HESA is the number of institutions that are within the HESA Finance Plus dataset and are also USS participating institutions, and USS is the total number of USS participating institutions. The number of PPF members is the sum of active and pensioner members; High and Low are institutions with the highest and lowest number of PPF members.

Figure 6

Table 6.Statistics for estimated probabilities of financial distressThis table reports the yearly simulated probabilities of insolvency for UK HE institutions (that participate in the USS) estimated by the logit model defined in equation (5) using the coefficient estimates in specification (VII) of Table 2 from financial years 2001 to 2004. Low and High stand for the lowest and the highest value, and 25% and 75% stand for the 25 and 75 percentile of the estimated values, respectively.

Figure 7

Figure 1.Histogram and density for the simulated risk-based levy (per member) against normal distribution

Notes: Simulated using data for 2004/05 under the formula set by PPF for 2006/07. Results using Specification VII in Table 2. Levy value represented by the horizontal axis which is scaled in £ sterling.Source: HESA HE Finance Plus.
Figure 8

Figure 2.Distribution of the simulated risk-based levy against normal distribution

Notes: Simulated using data for 2004/05 under the formula set by PPF for 2006/07. Results using Specification VII in Table 2. Levy value represented by the horizontal axis which is scaled in £ sterling.Source: HESA HE Finance Plus.
Figure 9

Table 7.Robustness tests using continuous negative earnings as the financial distress predictorThe table represents the results for the logit regression described in equation (16) with dependent variable as Pr (NEGTWOt=1|X), where X is the set of explanatory variables. LNSIZE is the log of total book assets (TA). WCTA is the ratio of working capital to total assets. CLCA is current liabilities divided by current assets (CA). CLTA is current liabilities divided by total assets. LLTA is long-term liabilities divided by total assets. TLTA is the ratio of total liabilities (CL+LL) to total asset. INCOME and COST are as defined in equation (16). Specification (I) is the basic model as in Ohlson (1980). Specification (II) adds working capital in the regression and specification (III) includes current liabilities from specification (II). Specification (IV) only includes long-term liabilities as compared to specification (I). Robust t-statistics are reported in parenthesis and *, **, *** stand for 10%, 5%, and 1% significance levels, respectively.