This is an ambitious and engaging effort to rethink at a theoretical level the meaning of blackness in Latin America. It seeks to explore the intersection between how blackness is represented and experienced, and to examine the multiple ways in which people of African descent have been mapped onto narratives of Latin America. Fox's primary concern is to rethink the centrality of slavery, and its associated tropes of ‘loss’, ‘lack’ and ‘survival’ to analyses of Latin American blackness, and to replace this with the twin paradigms of uprootedness and improvisation.
The book presents four main arguments as to how blackness in Latin America should be read. Firstly, it emphasises the permeability of uprootedness. Upheaval was the point of origin where the black community entered the historical record in the Americas, and it has been refocused and re-energised over time through processes such as emancipation and the move from the estates, and gentrification in urban communities. Improvisation emerged as a strategy developed to overcome uprootedness, yet far from being random, it is patterned by culturally bound and sanctioned ‘tools, tropes, and formulae’, which have been central to cultural resistance, allowing the development of an alternative worldview which rejects the dominant authority. Central to this culture of resistance has been a distinct sense of temporality, through which blackness has been marked by an inherently rebellious concept of time, and a strong sense of territoriality. Through these, Afro-Latin Americans have sought to establish their own communities and mark out a space for cultural expression, in the process refashioning identity and its relationship to power. However, improvisation and the cultural resistance implied therein, has necessarily meant that blacks and blackness have been excluded from dominant narratives, since its spontaneous nature has implicitly barred the cultural production of peoples of African descent from the realm of materiality.
The main strength of this book is its breadth of scope: it covers an impressively wide range of countries, writers and kinds of artistic production. The blending of analyses of artists as diverse as Adalberto Ortiz, Don Letts and Donna Summer is deft and skilful, and Fox moves from the popular to the canonical with fluidity and ease, integrating Latin American blackness into a more inclusive Americas-wide framework. She also presents a number of original and thoughtful insights. Fox's analysis of what she terms ‘land biographies’, in which geographic space and territory are used to ground the lyrical search for identity, provides a new way to read the artistic production of regions such as Esmeraldas, Palmares and Limón. Her examination of street calls, prison songs and work songs as literary texts provides an engaging deconstruction of the politics of transcribing and publishing black oral art forms, and the duelling discourses at work as the characteristics of mobility, flexibility and intertextuality are edited into modern printed formats. More generally, the paradigms she lays out suggest an interesting way to read the African Diaspora in Latin America.
However, at times Being and Blackness falls short of the goals it articulates. It presents itself as inter-disciplinary, but is firmly rooted in literary theory. When Fox does engage with social theory, it is often in an overly aggressive and un-nuanced way that often skews and misrepresents key ideas – few would agree with Fox's comparison between Paul Gilroy and the Argentine social Darwinist Vincenti Rossi (she argues both view blacks as ‘intellectually indentured automatons’ [p. 23]), while many might question her reference to ‘apologist historiographies which explain (away) the harshness of the slave trade and race relations’, and ‘critical ‘interruptions’ that subalternate and mechanise (that is, relativise or erase) the participation and contribution of peoples of African descent’ (pp. 3–4). A lot of the theory she engages with is somewhat outdated. Notably, she argues that race is routinely overlooked in theoretical models, and is not used in conjunction with gender, class and nation, overlooking a veritable outpouring of recent work on precisely these intersections.
These shortcomings speak to several structural weaknesses in the theoretical analysis advanced here, most importantly that ‘dominant discourse’ – a central focus of concern – is seen as something fixed and unchanging. Despite Fox's engagement with historical expressions of blackness, and with the history of the black experience, the book is strangely ahistorical in its engagement with narrative and representation, and reads in places as if the dominant discourse on blackness in Latin America has remained static since the beginning of the republican period. Fox often fails to distinguish between elite and academic discourse in discussions of concepts such as whitening, transculturation and syncretism. The distinction between representations of blackness and every-day lived experiences of the same are too often blurred, and in places it is difficult to ascertain if she is making reference to representation or reality. There are also puzzling theoretical omissions. The book is as much about mestizaje as it is about blackness, but yet the ideology is almost never explicitly mentioned. Moreover, while Fox repeatedly insists on the need to move away from slavery as the central facet of blackness: the experience of the Middle Passage is at the heart of her interpretation of the concepts of uprootedness and improvisation. More fundamentally, Fox argues her intention to show blackness not as something fixed, concrete or inherent, but as a ‘process’ which responds to new realities and situations, yet she often comes dangerously close to reifying blackness and freezing it in a colonial or nineteenth century context.
The book is also exceptionally heavy with jargon which renders it very difficult to read. As a result it is not really suitable for the non-specialist or student. This is a shame, as there are many innovative theoretical engagements in the book which could be useful well beyond the specialists' field. The book is undoubtedly a success in moving the comparative study of Latin American blackness forward, and in stepping beyond the ‘fall-back’ case studies of Brazil, Cuba and Colombia. It posits some interesting paradigms on the concept of Diaspora, and presents some elegant translations of a wide range of texts. For scholars working on literary representations of blackness this book will be extremely useful. Historians or social scientists working on the broader dimensions of blackness, however, may find it less appealing, despite the nuggets of valuable insight that lie scattered throughout.
