In London's Grand Guignol and the Theatre of Horror, Richard J. Hand and Michael Wilson promote the virtues of a popular early twentieth-century performance practice that has been largely overlooked by scholars tracing the development of modern theatre. Following the argument of their first book, Grand-Guignol: French Theatre of Horror (2002), Hand and Wilson claim that, as in Paris, London's Grand Guignol presented “a radical challenge—in both its formal structure and its treatment of narrative and characterisation—to the conventional popular theatre of its time” (24). London's Grand Guignol and the Theatre of Horror is structured in much the same way as its predecessor—divided into two parts, a concise historical overview and a compilation of ten distinctive playtexts—and it shares many of the strengths of the original. Grand Guignol is usually remembered as the theatre of horror, filled with thrilling special effects calculated to fascinate and appall spectators. But Hand and Wilson are careful to remind us that the degree of hyperbole in the advertisements was not necessarily matched by the theatrical experience; the form was actually more diverse, not quite avant-garde but not quite boulevard either.
Founded by José Levy in the aftermath of the First World War, London's Grand Guignol was modeled directly on the Théâtre du Grand-Guignol in Paris. Levy housed his Grand Guignol productions in the Little Theatre in John Adam Street, a venue already well known to London audiences for controversies surrounding presentations of politically advanced and theatrically experimental works by diverse companies. In comparison to the longer-lived, more extreme French Grand-Guignol (1897–1962), the British experiment was brief (1920–2); but it was no less prodigious, presenting eight seasons and a total of forty-three plays during its two-year history.
In London, each night's entertainment comprised four to six short plays, comedies as well as thrillers, bundled together. Many of the plays presented were translations from the French originals, chosen for their provocative subject matter: often sexual intrigue culminating in violent gestures of madness and awful bloody acts. However, constrained in content and aesthetics by both the censorship of the Lord Chamberlain and the (thus conditioned) tastes of London theatregoers, London's Grand Guignol was a “much more genteel, indeed British affair” (3) than its Parisian role model.
Describing Paris's Grand-Guignol, Hand and Wilson attest: “Very often it was a theatre of restraint, punctuated very carefully with well-placed theatrical trickery and sleight-of-hand, but held together by meticulously crafted dialogue which suggested acts of horror that were not always enacted. It was always a theatre of the Unseen, as much as a theatre of the Seen” (49). This was even more true in London, where its topical and technical limitations served to push José Levy's Grand Guignol toward theatrical innovation, especially (and paradoxically) those associated with the development of realism onstage. In particular, Levy's exploitation of the one-act form in the intimate setting of the Little Theatre aligned it as much with the relative radicalism of J. T. Grein's Independent Theatre Society as with the more conventionally bourgeois theatres of the West End.
The proximity of audiences to actors meant that the experience of the performance, its success (or failure), rested primarily on the virtuosity of its company, especially Sybil Thorndike, who appearing with her husband and brother, was the theatre's star attraction. In balancing realism against melodrama, and the demands of characterization against those of plot, London's Grand Guignol actors appear to have utilized the fundamental tools of psychological acting to produce the heightened displays of emotion for which they were best known.
Hand and Wilson argue that in taking theatre “to the very edge (but not transgressing it) where horror meets comedy” (45), Levy's Grand Guignol offered London audiences a kind of cathartic respite from the trauma of the war and its aftermath. Over the course of an evening's entertainment, the performance of incipient violence was periodically shown to have the potential to provoke laughter; the audience's anticipation of bloodshed turned to pleasure at being in on a rather risqué joke, teetering teasingly close to but safely within the censor's boundaries.
The ten plays that constitute more than half of the book confirm both the possibilities and the limitations of London's Grand Guignol, and represent the diversity of what was on offer, including Noël Coward's wonderful one-act play The Better Half. Each play is briefly but carefully contextualized, with photographs and tantalizing tidbits of information about performance. The advantage of having these texts to hand is that we are, in effect, invited to bring them, and the Grand Guignol, out of obscurity and back to life onstage. However, the emphasis given to these texts also puts a literary face on the Grand Guignol and ultimately contradicts the assertion that this was above all a theatrical form.
Read together with their earlier book, London's Grand Guignol allows Hand and Wilson to make a persuasive case for Grand Guignol's place not only in modern theatre history, but also in the film history of thrillers and horror films. This book will be useful as a hands-on theatre history and practice text for programs where one might imagine offering students an opportunity to apply their creativity to the same challenges José Levy faced. However, just as London's Grand Guignol never really escaped the shadow of Paris's Grand-Guignol, so too this new book sits uneasily in the shadow of the earlier, more groundbreaking work of Grand-Guignol: French Theatre of Horror. Too often, the authors diminish their analysis of what happened in London by leaning back on their previous descriptions of what happened in Paris. We are tantalized by assertions about the theatricality of London's Grand Guignol, but despite some wonderful photos and descriptions (the introduction to The Nutcracker Suite shows how actors interacted with the progressively lowered curtain to achieve the effect of the shrinking room), often more questions arise than are satisfied in this brief history.
