1934: Spain: A Democracy in the Making
My first visit in a parliamentary capacity to Republican Spain was in the autumn of 1934. I had heard on reliable authority that a rising of the miners in the Asturias had been suppressed with extreme brutality. The Spanish Foreign Legion had been brought over from Africa, and they had meted punishment on wives and families as well as on the militant miners. It was therefore suggested that Miss Ellen Wilkinson M.P.Footnote 216 and I should go to Spain on a humanitarian mission, and to point out to the Spanish authorities that much harm was being done to our relations with Spain by the atrocity stories appearing in the British press.
We travelled directly to Madrid to make our representations to the Spanish government. We were surprised, considering our political insignificance, to find that we were received with the utmost friendliness and courtesy at the highest level, and immediately invited by Senor Lerroux,Footnote 217 the Prime Minister, for an interview at his official residence. When we told him that we would like to visit the Asturias to see for ourselves the conditions prevailing in the mining villages, he made not the slightest objection, and said repeatedly that ‘la porte est ouverte’.Footnote 218 We had a long talk about the political situation, and it was clear that he did not under-estimate the difficulty of sustaining the fragile and comparatively new system of parliamentary government against the growing menace of the revolutionary extremes on the left and right. He was, however, more than willing that we should go everywhere and see everything, and wrote a letter of introduction to Commander Doval,Footnote 219 the officer in charge of military operations in the Asturias, commending us and including the words ‘I would like to ask you to help [Listowel] in any way possible, and it is in your hands that he fulfils the mission that brings him here.’ At the same time Senor Gil Robles,Footnote 220 leader of the conservative right, was denouncing me as an ‘undesirable’ and demanding the expulsion of our party from Spain.
We travelled by train overnight from Madrid to Oviedo, and after breakfast at a cafe in the town, prepared ourselves for a meeting with Commander Doval at 11.00 am in the town hall. We had a long wait, and noticed while we waited a small crowd was gathering outside the town hall. We knew that Oviedo was under martial law, and was surprised to see what appeared to be some sort of demonstration. At last we were ushered into Doval's office, and explained exactly what we wanted. He tried to persuade us to leave the town, on the ground that he could not be responsible for our safety in view of the indignation of the people of Oviedo. When we persisted, he eventually agreed, provided that we accepted a strong police escort. As we walked down the steps from the main entrance we found that our police escort was directing us to our waiting car. We were then told that the instructions to our driver were to take us, escorted by the National Guard, not to the town, but straight to the frontier. As the purpose of our mission was in this way frustrated, our forcible expulsion from the Asturias gave a clear impression to the outside world that the military authorities were hiding the evidence of their persecution of the miners, and that they, not the civil government in Madrid, were the effective rulers of a large area of northern Spain. Something had been accomplished; if not what we had intended.
My abrupt return to London was another but lesser problem with my family. My uncle by marriage, Sir Ralph Glyn, was a Conservative MP, and he told me that he had been button-holed by the Foreign Secretary, Sir Austen Chamberlain,Footnote 221 who complained that he had heard his nephew had been interfering in the domestic affairs of a friendly country. This reproof from a cabinet minister had upset my uncle, but he was too kindly a person to be angry with me, and I think regarded the whole thing as no more than a youthful escapade. We were also censured by the National Executive of the Labour Party for acting without their authority. It was not until 1937 that the Party sent a delegation led by Attlee to support the Republic.
This party criticism did not however prevent Lord Snell,Footnote 222 who had taken over from Arthur Ponsonby as Leader of the Opposition in the Lords in June 1936, from inviting me to sit on the Front Opposition Bench. The Letter is so charming and characteristic that I would like to include it:
11th June 1936
Dear Listowel,
As you know, it is one of the tasks of the Leader of the Opposition to select the personnel of the Labour Front Bench, and it is my desire to carry the members with me in any changes which I think desirable.
You have now had considerable experience in the work of the House and in political life generally, so I need not remind you that occupancy of the Front Bench imposes penalties as well as privileges. Its members have to surrender some of the freedom which the back benches afford, and they have to consider much more closely whether what they do and say may help or compromise the position of the Party. These obligations are so trying at times that men like Arnold, Buxton, Ponsonby (and now Sanderson) do not care to assume them, preferring the greater freedom of the back benches.
I would not personally press anyone to change back bench freedom for Front Bench reticence and circumspection, but I should like you to consider whether or not you cared to do so. If you thought that you could stand the yoke (and I have not found it too difficult) it would be a pleasure to me to tell the members of the Party that I proposed to ask you to join those who sit on the Front Bench.
Will you please let me have a private line on the matter during the next few days.
Yours sincerely,
Snell
Needless to say, I was delighted by my promotion to the Front Bench.
1937: China: A Victim of Aggression
In 1934 and 1936 Republican Spain had been the first victim of aggression in Europe. In 1937 China became the victim of aggression in Asia, when it was invaded by Japan. I was almost immediately involved when invited in the autumn to join a group from the left wing of the Party which decided to organise support for China. The main object of this group was to mobilise public opinion and sympathy for the cause of China, and to provide humanitarian aid for the national resistance to the Japanese.
On September 30, 1937, the first meeting of the China Campaign Committee took place at the Whitfield Tabernacle, at the invitation of its pastor, the Reverend Belden. There were messages of support from Lord Cecil of Chelwood,Footnote 223 Mrs Pat Koo,Footnote 224 the daughter of the distinguished Chinese diplomat, Dr Wellington Koo,Footnote 225 Madame Chiang Kai-ShekFootnote 226 and Professor Harold Laski.Footnote 227
The Chairman of our Committee was Mr Victor Gollancz,Footnote 228 the Vice-Chairman was Miss Margery Fry,Footnote 229 and I was asked to be its President. Margery Fry, Quaker sister of the art critic Roger Fry,Footnote 230 was one of the most dedicated internationalists I can remember. Victor Gollancz was often absent, and she did most of the work with untiring energy and superb efficiency.
Our most outstanding parliamentary supporter was the Nobel Prize winner, Lord Cecil of Chelwood, who not only supported us in the House of Lords but addressed many public meetings in London and elsewhere on behalf of China. His Opposition to the foreign policy of the Government was so strong that he moved his place on the Conservative benches to join us on the Opposition Front Bench, where he sat somewhat uncomfortably, because he disliked our domestic policy, which at the time included several measures of nationalisation, almost as intensely as he disliked the foreign policy of his own party.
We also advocated a boycott of Japanese exports, encouraged by the example of the Southampton dockers, who had refused to unload a Japanese ship, and a boycott of exports of war materials, particularly oil, to Japan.Footnote 231 I am glad to say my words, on behalf of the China Campaign Committee, congratulating the Southampton dockers on their ‘splendid example of political courage and determination’ were noted in the press on December 12, 1937. The article went on to my attack on the Government which ‘had not protested against the violation of the solemn international treaties to which Japan had adhered and which she had broken by invading China. The Government has not even prohibited armament firms from sending military planes and guns to the Japanese. It was time that England had the courage to stand up to fascist aggression.’
We raised funds at public meetings by press appeals and even by an art exhibition. I remember organising with Ruth GollanczFootnote 232 an exhibition of ‘Chinese Art in London’, which included the finest pieces from the two best private collections in the country, those of Sir Percival DavidFootnote 233 and Mr Eumorphopolos,Footnote 234 shown at the Royal Institute of British Architects. Both collections were bequeathed to the nation, and are now divided between the Victoria and Albert and the British Museum. Perhaps the day will come when the world can admire both collections in a single London Museum.
Most of our funds were spent on medical supplies for the International Peace Hospitals in different parts of China. I was pleasantly surprised to read in Arthur Clegg's excellent booklet on Aid to ChinaFootnote 235 that one of these hospitals still exists in Hopei Province. In recognition of the Committee's work the Chinese Ambassador in London told me that General Chiang Kai-ShekFootnote 236 would like to give an Honour, I think it was the Order of the Chrysanthemum. I consulted the Foreign Office, and was told that Ministers of the Crown (by that time I was a Junior Minister) could not accept Honours from foreign Governments. So I declined the flattering offer without, I hope, causing offence.
I will conclude this account of our work for China with a quotation from the Introduction to Arthur Clegg's book by the distinguished scientist and sinologist, Dr Joseph Needham.Footnote 237
The China Campaign Committee was a great feature of life in the England of those days in the 30s, and I believe it really did much towards making China that great ally in the Second World War, which it afterwards became.
So perhaps we did some good for our own country as well as for China.
1938: Spain: A Struggling Democracy
I believe that my 1938 visit to Spain is best described using extracts from my diary.
January 30th
The opportunity for which I have long waited had arrived. I was invited a few days ago to attend the opening of the Cortes on February 1st in Barcelona; it had not met since the seat of Government had been moved to Catalonia, and its last session had closed in Valencia in October of 1937. I accepted immediately, both with a view of doing my bit for the Spanish Republican Government and in order to get into direct contact with the relief problem in Catalonia. It was hoped we might be an all-party group, but the Conservatives as usual were only half-hearted. So I set out this morning from Victoria in the following company: Dick Acland (Liberal M.P.), Mrs Barbara Ayrton-Gould,Footnote 238 (Vice-Chairman of the Labour Party), and F. Montague M.P.,Footnote 239 the official delegates of the Labour Party, and Rev. Woods M.P.,Footnote 240 the representative of the Co-operative Movement.
In Paris we met the other Parliamentary Delegates to the Spanish Parliament; they included men of all parties from the three Scandinavian countries and France, and were joined later by old Emil [sic] VanderveldeFootnote 241 from Belgium. It was good to be in the company of representative people from some of the most progressive countries in western Europe.
January 31st
We travelled overnight to Perpignan, and were met there by two buses under orders to carry us to Barcelona; we should have arrived by midday, but the inevitable Spanish dallying over and before the midday meal (we must have eaten Figueros out of provisions for a week) delayed us until shortly after dusk. The drive was exceedingly beautiful; in the morning through the Pyrenees, and skirting the Mediterranean during the last lap. The sun brought old women out to bask in their doorways, and cats and dogs curled up in its warmth, while the scenery varied from the rocky grandeur of snow-capped mountains to the bright spring verdure of the coastal plain, where almond orchards were already gleaming like scattered patches of pink mist. I understand now why people prefer the south of France to England in the winter months.
We reached Barcelona just after dark, and observed the precautions against air-attack; the street lights were all dimmed with a coating of blue paint, but there seemed to be no shade over the dazzling head-lamps of cars – which obviously guided the enemy planes to the main thoroughfares.
I was directed to the Ritz Hotel with a room and bath to myself; hot water was provided for our benefit, and the food was excellent.
En route I spoke to a bi-lingual Norwegian girl, Miss Gripp, who organised the Scandinavian delegates; she seemed to be quite fearless, judging from her stories about Bilbao during the bombing. The nearer to the Front, the happier she felt, she said. She was married at eighteen to an Italian and is now happily divorced. In Norway divorce by mutual consent is obtainable after one year, unilateral divorce after two years’ respite; the proceedings are strictly private throughout. Their commonsense has evidently not been warped by their Lutheran beliefs.
On arrival we found our fellow-guests somewhat shaken by a severe daylight raid delivered the very day before our arrival; 300 killed and 700 wounded, the heaviest daytime casualties since the war began. By way of giving us happy dreams we were taken after dinner to inspect the damage done by a bomb up the street – about 200 yards from the hotel. A six-story building had been sliced open like a slab of cheese, the bomb exploding on the ground floor and destroying the six floors above as well as the wall facing the street. Its force was perpendicular rather than lateral, and pictures and mirrors were visible, unbroken, on the walls of rooms without floors or ceilings at the top of the house. They were still clearing away the debris and expecting to find more buried corpses. One lay covered with some sacking on the pavement. The damage was done by not more than eight planes, but one can arrive by multiplication at what a larger number could have achieved in killed and wounded. There was no military target, so this was an early example of the bombing of open cities.
February 1st
We were told to be ready at 7.30 am, as the President of the Chamber, Martinez Barrio,Footnote 242 wanted to see us at eight. We actually started in a car from the hotel at eight, not bad for Spanish punctuality, and were given some tickets for the opening of the Cortes in the building that houses the Catalonian Parliament. Then, to our amazement, instead of being driven back to our hotels for breakfast, we found ourselves speeding away from Barcelona – whither we knew not – into the mountains of the hinterland. It was a wonderful drive, and I can only compare the scenery to what one sees from above the Gulf of Cotor on the road from Ragusa to Cetinje. Higher and higher we climbed, skirting deep ravines through which plunged mountain torrents, until at last we reached a summit two thousand feet above sea-level, and spread out behind us lay the plain we had crossed, while inland the serried ranks of foothills culminated on the distant horizon in the snow-covered ridges of the Sierras. We had reached our destination, the famous and austerely beautiful monastery of Montserrat; and there, on the plain wooden benches of a long refectory, hung with marvellous tapestries from the Royal Palace at Madrid, assembled the majority of members comprising the Cortes of Republican Spain. Here, in the shadow of the Holy Grail they were re-dedicating themselves to the salvation of their country and the freedom of their countrymen. The speeches were impressive because they gave a sense of absolute unity in a common purpose.
After the Government had had their turn – Negrin,Footnote 243 Prime Minister and ex-professor of physiology at Madrid University; Alvarez del Vayo,Footnote 244 the socialist Foreign Minister; PrietoFootnote 245 (who entered Teruel in a tank before the heights of Santa Barbara had fallen) emphatic, bald, and immensely fat; Jiralt [sic],Footnote 246 bespectacled and mouse-like – representatives of the different political Parties rose from their seats. I could only understand completely when translated the speech of Dolores Ibarrure [sic],Footnote 247 the wife of a Bilbao miner. She had six children before she entered politics in 1930 or 1931, and her remarkable eloquence lent courage to thousands of luke-warm Republicans at the beginning of the Civil War. Known as ‘La Passionaria’ [sic], she spoke first for the Communist Party. She had a fine presence, a lovely voice, and perfect enunciation, but unfortunately her speech affirming loyalty to the Government of the Communist Party was read and not spoken. In all the qualities of the orator save spontaneity she infinitely surpassed the others. She was followed by a member of the Republic Union PartyFootnote 248 – the Party of Barrio and Lerroux, the extreme right of the present Cortes – who spoke in exactly the same vein. Then a small and wiry Basque rose to his feet, a Catholic from the north of Spain, and his words of loyalty to the Government were echoed by the leader of the Catalan Esquerra who followed him. The picture of a people united in self-defence against a common enemy would not have been complete without an intervention from the Left Republicans – the Party of Azana,Footnote 249 President of the Republic – and from a spokesman of the Socialist Party. Possibly for the first time in the history of Spain I was witnessing the spectacle of unanimity between people who had seldom before been able to agree, a complete sinking of personal, political, historical, and religious differences in order to resist as one man the military rebels and foreign invaders. The key-note of the proceedings was the unity of all parties, creeds, and nationalities in the common cause of national defence, and of course the purpose that united them was not social revolution or class revolt but simply the determination to defend the independence of Republican soil, and to preserve their liberal and democratic institutions from overthrow by a military dictator.
The secret of this strange meeting of the Cortes in the refectory of a monastery was so well kept that the deputy for Montserrat had gone to Barcelona, and was not back in time for the Assembly! Secrecy was obviously desirable to prevent FrancoFootnote 250 from using the meeting place as a target for his Italian planes from Majorca.
The adjournment was followed by the longest lunch I have ever attended, a typical Spanish orgy lasting from two till five in the afternoon. The foreign deputies were invited by the Prime Minister to attend this Government function, and I had the good fortune to sit next to the Minister for Economic Affairs. He told me that the main reason for the strength of the Franco PesetaFootnote 251 as compared with the Government Peseta was not the poverty of the Government, but the fact that well-to-do Spaniards had gone abroad and sold their pesetas for anything they could get in foreign currency. He also said that, since Teruel,Footnote 252 the credit of the Government had slightly improved; instead of paying for their imports beforehand, they were able to pay on delivery. The absolute necessity for them is to have foreign currency, and they are very strict about forbidding the export of even the smallest quantity of home produce without payment in the local currency. I gathered that the foodstuffs most sorely lacking were milk – they are cut off from the main dairy-farming area of Spain in Galicia, sugar, and meat. – Relief organisations abroad should therefore concentrate on condensed milk, sugar, and tinned meat. He added that the total volume of relief that had come from abroad had made no appreciable difference to the food situation. What could demonstrate more forcibly the inadequacy of voluntary effort when faced with calamity on so vast a scale, and the necessity for Government action, independent or concerted, to stave off starvation and epidemics? An American woman, who acts for the Co-ordination Committee in Paris and has spent one million dollars from the United States in relief work, told me that the diet of the refugees consisted of chick-peas, beans, a little rice and wine, and the plight of the natives, who get a minute fraction of poor bread as well, is little better. She says the food shortage is diminishing as they are using their own farms to produce what they need at home. The shortage of clothes and blankets for the refugees is still acute. The country is mainly wine-producing and too dry to grow corn; but the peasants are starting to cultivate potatoes.
Let me return to the afternoon orgy at Montserrat. The Prime Minister proposed the health of the foreign parliamentarians and old Emil Vandervelde answered for us all. His eloquence soared above the conflict of the moment to the great historical themes it exemplified – la lutte pour la paix, pour la liberté, pour la patrie humaine.Footnote 253 In passing he mentioned the Belgian adherence to non-intervention as the reason for his resignation from the Cabinet, a statement greeted with thunderous applause. The old boy is now on his way to the Madrid Front! The venerable, white-haired Valladarez [sic],Footnote 254 the Liberal Prime Minister at the time of the last Election resulting in the victory of the Popular Front, was also at the luncheon; and he described how, as soon as the results were known, the Conservative leaders and chiefs of the General Staff came to him and offered to establish his dictatorship. He is an aristocrat, a Marquis, I think; and the only nobleman whom I have heard of on the Government side. And so back to Barcelona for the night.
The morning before we came over a hundred children had been killed by one bomb – they were refugees huddled in the crypt of a church in which they were sheltered; the bomb came in through the roof but didn't explode till it reached the crypt, and the only children that escaped were those who, instead of taking cover, had stayed in their beds. A bad moral, but the value of a basement refuge depends of course on the amount of building above it. At about 7.45 that evening, having emerged from a lovely hot bath, I had just shaved one side of my face when the lights suddenly went out; knowing that this was the usual precursor of an air-raid, I groped my way to an electric torch and joined my fellow guests downstairs, clad as I was only in pyjamas and a dressing-gown, and adorned with one half of a promising beard. The darkness and preoccupation of the moment were not unwelcome. After thirty-five minutes the lights went on again, and it transpired that the enemy planes had not visited us at all but had unloaded their bombs upon another town further down the coast.
Wednesday, February 2nd
A day without highlights passed in Barcelona. In the afternoon we visited one elementary school and two homes for children who were refugees or orphaned by the war. The school was most interesting; it amazed one that they could be spending so much on education while engaged in a life and death struggle. The children seemed to have everything except sufficient food; the standard of equipment was first-rate, and even included the teaching of pottery and printing and illustrating magazines and programmes of their own work. Two ‘model’ homes – one which was housed in the residence of a former managing director of the Catalonian Railways who had left his country mansion to a monastic order – were less interesting than others serving the same purpose, because the atmosphere of plenty was so obviously exceptional.
Our little guide, formerly a prosperous dentist in Oviedo, told me quite by accident that bull-fighting had been stopped in Republican Spain. Why do they not make the most of this humanitarian spirit in their propaganda? I am sure that 99% of English people were as ignorant as I was of this bold attack on a brutal but very ancient Spanish custom.
Thursday, February 3rd
Started in the morning, not more than half an hour late, on our drive to Valencia. The scenery was admirable, and the weather perfect. So far every day has been warm, sunny, and cloudless – just what England ought to be like in May but seldom is. The Catalonian coastal region is thickly set with vines and olives, but here and there a whole orchard of almond trees was in blossom, and an occasional solitary cherry in a cottage garden. In the neighbourhood of Tortosa the spur that runs down from Teruel reaches the sea, and one winds along the mountain side with deep gorges below and precipitous heights above. Then the coastal plain resumes, and passing from the province of Castellon to that of Valencia one finds oneself among the orange groves that stretch right down to Alicante and Malaga. They are a lovely sight at this time of the year, the golden oranges thickly clustered round the branches and gleaming brightly against the dark green leaves. On the road to Tarragona one is reminded of the Roman colonies on the Levant coast of Spain by a magnificent triumphal arch in honey-coloured stone, a feast of colour when viewed in the sunlight against the deep blue of the sky. At Benicarlo we stopped off for another Spanish lunch, and did not get under way again till five o'clock. As we approached Castellon just after sundown a range of cobalt hills was outlined sharply against the pale lemon of the western horizon. It was dark when our cars deposited us at the Hotel Victoria in Valencia. During the last lap we stopped at a hospital of the International Brigade to chat with the convalescents and slightly wounded and to give them the cigarettes for which they pined. I chatted with Asturians who had been driven out after the civil war, with German emigrés, with Americans and cockneys; they were for the most part genuine idealists, though there were some adventurers too. For instance, a long-haired Irishman from Limerick boasted that he knew the best pubs in every town from Malaga to Madrid, and didn't care a damn about politics. We were asked to address a gathering of wounded men who assembled in the main hall after supper. It was extraordinarily difficult to say anything: their courage and suffering and sacrifice spoke more eloquently than our poor words, and choked us with shame at our own miserable non-intervention. There was a young Canadian nurse – the only one in Spain, who had tremendous difficulty in getting permission to work out here; what spirit had moved her to risk her life for the cause of these unhappy strangers in a land so far from home?
Friday, February 4th
Before we started in the morning for Teruel the sirens sounded their warning against an air-raid. The townsfolk ran into the houses from the open streets and squares but there was no sign of panic or stampede. It wasn't long before the all-clear followed, as the raiders had gone to Sagunto – Roman Saguntum sacked by HannibalFootnote 255 – ten miles up the coast.
As we climbed from the coastal plain, with its sub-tropical vegetation, up towards the high plateau of Central Spain, the sturdy stone pines multiplied in place of the olives and vineyards. We were soon surrounded in all directions by a barren expanse of heath and stone. Nestling in small fertile patches were the villages we passed on the road, where peasants could be seen through their open cottage doors, feeding their chickens and suckling their young. We stopped at last at a railway embankment, and though we were several miles behind the lines our three cars were strung out so as not to present a tempting target from the air. Our little guide led us along the railway line into the pitch darkness of a tunnel, and after we had groped our way for about a hundred yards we were told to scale the stationary coach standing beside us. We were then ushered into a compartment equipped as an office, and introduced to General Sarrabia [sic],Footnote 256 Commander-in-Chief of the Teruel forces, for this was General Headquarters on the Teruel Front. The General was an officer of the regular Spanish Army who had opted for the Republic, and won one of their few victories at Teruel. He explained that he could not guarantee our safety if we pressed on to Teruel, but provided us immediately with a staff officer as guide when we intimated our desire to visit the Front.
When we set out again in our cars we left a large interval between each vehicle, so as not to attract enemy planes. We were in the leading car, and our officer guide halted us a few kilometres short of the town to speak to a driver whose lorry had broken down coming from the opposite direction. He enquired about the enemy artillery, and was told they were shelling the approaches to the town. This had a magical effect on our chauffeur, who fairly ‘stepped on it’ until we were safely through the danger zone.
We found ourselves at last in the streets of what had once been a beautiful 18th century town, and had now become a derelict ruin in whose streets the shells and debris of houses alone remained. To be strictly accurate we saw three inhabitants, a woman and two small children, sitting at the black mouth of a hole leading downwards into the earth – an air-raid shelter – where she and her little ones could take refuge at the first sign of enemy aircraft. After dark they went back to the remains of their home. The landmarks of the historic victory of Teruel were pointed out to us; the bull-ring on the outskirts of the town, the first objective, the Bank of Spain in which for ten days the enemy had held out, until their stronghold was finally blown up by the dynamite of the Asturian miners; and the seminary in which the Bishop of Teruel and the last of the Franco Garrison, after their water supply as well as their food had been cut off, surrendered to the Republican Militia. The appropriate chorus that accompanied us as we marched round this scene of destruction and desolation was the rat-tat-tat of machine guns, the crackle of rifles, and the occasional louder bang of trench mortars that reached us from the Front Line just beyond the city. At places the enemy were no more than 1000 yards from the outskirts, and we had to be careful not to expose ourselves to fire from their lines. The destruction wrought by explosives was not quite as complete as I remember at Ypres when I saw it in 1918, just after the First World War. The battle had not lasted as long, and the artillery bombardment was certainly not as heavy.
A lovely Moorish tower in brick, ornamented with geometrical designs in faience, supposedly unique among the Moorish relics of Spain, was almost untouched. The carved rood screen behind the Altar of the Cathedral, an absolutely superb piece of Baroque craftsmanship, was also intact; and not a single book had been removed from among the volumes of philosophy, theology, and Latin poetry in the Bishop's Library. These treasures were being cared for by the Ministry of Culture, and were to be removed as soon as possible for safe keeping to the vaults of Valencia or Barcelona.
I talked for some time with a Scotch International Brigadier named Fraser, who had been out for over a year without receiving a scratch. This period included three months without relief in the Front Line before Madrid. He told the old, old story of Franco's overwhelming superiority in the air and in heavy artillery. During the battle for Teruel the Government planes had been outnumbered by three to one. The enemy method of attack was to shell the Front Line so heavily that they expected to blow it right away. This rattled the Spanish Militia, though the International Brigade was getting used to it.
The lack of planes and guns was the reason for their bitterness against the British and French policy of non-intervention, which prevented the Spanish Government from counteracting the equipment provided by Italy and Germany for Franco. It was to prove the deciding factor in the Spanish Civil War, which was the first victory for the dictatorships over the democracies in western Europe. Russia had sent some tanks and a few planes but no soldiers, and these not until October 1936, long after the armed intervention of the Fascist powers. Military supplies from the Soviet Union simply couldn't compare with what had reached Franco from HitlerFootnote 257 and Mussolini.Footnote 258 A dour Scot volunteer, Dunbar, whom I spoke to en route, had been twice wounded ‘but they haven't killed me yet’. Curious the types one meets in this cosmopolitan army; intellectuals, working men, adventurers and ‘professional’ soldiers – men who really enjoy a scrap, and go wherever a bit of fighting can be found.
We started back from Teruel just before dusk. We were still in the leading car, and, when a short distance from the gate we had left by, we observed the smoke of a shell bursting in the road about 200 yards in front of us. We were under fire from Franco's artillery! The little procession of cars was halted, and told to wait for a few minutes until the gathering darkness could hide us from the view of the enemy batteries. We then proceeded without any contretemps on our way, and passed strings of mules bringing supplies for the defenders of the city under cover of darkness.
At the second line we stopped to have a word with some men in the Lincoln and Washington battalions; they were bivouacking for the night on an open moor, spread out widely on account of hostile air-attack, and clustering in groups round little fires that warmed their limbs and heated their cans of hot soup. The icy wind that swept the high sierra after nightfall cut like a knife, and yet these men were not grumbling about another of their many nights spent in the open. We talked to an officer in an anti-tank battery, and one of my companions waxed enthusiastic about his guns. Personally, I could feel no spark of enthusiasm for these weapons of destruction, which appeared to me an infinitely deplorable necessity. Of course the amazing courage of men who risk their lives every day for months, living in hell without a murmur against their lot, and the camaraderie that shares the last crust and the last thimbleful of water, also belong to any true picture of war.
Saturday, February 5th
My driver appeared this morning at the hotel in Valencia three quarters of an hour late, excessive even for Spain, and I had to abandon the idea of driving through to the Frontier in the day. The further one gets from the Front, the more inefficient organisation becomes. We had just passed through Sagunto when some bombers arrived from Majorca. I stopped and watched the raid from the road; one could see against the blue sky the white puffs of bursting shells, but the planes themselves were too high to be visible.
We didn't reach Barcelona until about four. My driver had two oranges and a dry roll for lunch and offered me an orange; it was difficult to refuse without hurting his feelings, so I said I generally lunched later – it was then at least three o'clock! Our little guide had been a prosperous doctor [or dentist, if same man as mentioned earlier] in Oviedo and he told me that he used to visit the military prison after the miners had been crushed by the foreign legionnaires in 1934. The brute Doval was still in charge of the troops in the town, and he used to torture the prisoners – giving them, for instance, salt fish to eat and nothing to drink. The little man added that ‘he invented things’ – what, I did not care to ask. His own escape from the rebels, after living for weeks in a dark underground cellar, was an amazing tale of adventure.
Sunday, February 6th
It was lucky I had an extra morning in Barcelona as I was able to attend a conference of foreign relief workers. They were representatives of England, the Scandinavian countries, Switzerland, the U.S.A., France and even Chile, Argentina, and Egypt. Curiously enough the Swiss seemed to have done more work than anyone save the French. They had their own lorries for distributing milk and other foodstuffs among allotted colonies of refugee children. But their magnificent efforts appeared as a drop in the ocean when compared with the magnitude of the food shortage; the problem is so enormous that voluntary organisations, unassisted by Government money or support, cannot possibly solve it. The food situation will deteriorate rather than improve as the war goes on. This strictly humanitarian conference, presided over by a representative of the rather more than half pro-Franco General Relief Fund, passed a resolution protesting against the bombardment of open towns. An admirable band of warm-hearted humanitarians, many of them sustained by belief in the Christian quality of their work, ministering so far as their own limited powers would allow, to the sufferings of a war-stricken population. They kindled hope and kindness and enthusiasm among all who met them. It is good to know there are such loveable and dedicated people in the world.
In the afternoon my driver took me straight through to La Jonquera on the Pyrenean Frontier, which we reached by the light of a marvellous moon. We chatted awhile before parting – or rather he talked and I listened. He had been with a tank for a whole year on the Aragon front near Belchite, it was hell of course, especially when he had a whole battery of anti-tank guns firing at him and ‘he thought he was dead’. But now he had something – pulling a dirty slip of folded paper from his wallet – that General MiajaFootnote 259 himself was proud to have; it was a certificate of valour, corresponding to a military decoration. How lucky, poor fellow, that those few words on a slip of paper were balm for all the misery of that year at the Front. He was sharing the glory of Miaja, and what else could matter.
It was a real pleasure to taste butter once more in the French Station restaurant at Perpignan and to drink coffee with milk. But lying snugly in a luxurious sleeper and roaring through the night towards the comfort and safety of a great material civilisation, one felt a little like a deserter who slinks off home while his comrades are still in the damp dug-outs of the front line.
I was kept in touch with the tragic decline of the Republic by their charming Ambassador in London, Senor Azcarate,Footnote 260 who invited me several times to his house in Belgrave Square. We also set up a National Joint Committee for Spanish Relief of which I was Vice Chairman, which sent medical and food supplies to Spain, and helped the increasing flood of Spanish refugees. The Chairman was the Duchess of Athol[sic],Footnote 261 the ‘red’ Duchess of her critics, while the indefatigable secretary was Miss Eleanor Rathbone M.P. We were able to send a medical unit to Spain with the financial support of the Trade Union Congress. We also arranged for hospitality and ultimate repatriation for about 4000 Basque children.
The bombing of Barcelona, an open city, continued after we had returned, as is testified by a telegram I received at the House of Lords from Del Vayo, the Foreign Minister, on March 28th, 1938: –
I am sure that the whole of Great Britain will have shuddered with horror on reading the news of the most recent bombardment of Barcelona. But I can assure you after having visited the entire city in which 2000 people have been killed and an equal number wounded that the worst predictions of the coming aerial warfare have been converted here into the most abominable reality.
The Spanish people turn towards Great Britain and ask you to raise your voice against the extermination of this civilian population of Barcelona and against the policy which prevents the Spanish Government from acquiring the means necessary to defend itself against this murder of more than 1000 women and children in a single day.
Signed: Alvarez del Vayo
The air attacks on Barcelona and, before that, the total destruction of Guernica, were indeed a rehearsal for the far more horrifying bombing of open towns in the World War that soon followed, and the policy of non-intervention exposed to Hitler and Mussolini the fatal weakness of the democracies. Had the legitimate Spanish Republican Government with their assistance won the Spanish Civil War, the Allies might not have had to fight the Second World War. The European Union of today is an acknowledgement of the fact that defence is indivisible.
1939: The Soviet Union: Alliance as Last Hope for World Peace
When the danger of World War was becoming more and more acute with every concession to Hitler, I became convinced that the only way to stop him was by a defensive alliance with the Soviet Union, as the one thing he really feared was a war on two fronts. I was criticised at this time for my association with communists and ‘fellow travellers’, as near communists were then called, but I was very glad to work with anyone and any organisation that wanted a closer relationship with the Soviet Union. One of my best friends was Mrs Isobel [sic] Brown,Footnote 262 a member of the Communist Party, with no more than an elementary education but an extraordinary gift for tear-jerking platform oratory that brought in a great deal of money for the victims of aggression.
For this reason in 1937 I served as Chairman of two conferences, one in London and the other in Birmingham, called the Congress for Peace and Friendship with the U.S.S.R.
My speech in Birmingham, was reported in the Birmingham Post on November 29, and set out our alternative policy of collective security:
The first aim of the Congress was to stress the necessity for this country to co-operate as closely as possible with the Soviet Union in defence of peace. They believed very strongly that the best chance of peace in Europe lay in co-operation between this country and the Soviet Union and France, and all those democracies anxious to preserve their own liberties and to maintain peace throughout the continent. It was obvious that by standing together and obtaining collective security they stood a good chance of avoiding another war, which might otherwise be started by some great Power which felt that it could fall upon a defenceless and isolated victim. It was clear from the part that Russia had played in the League of Nations in developments in Europe and the Far East, that Russia stood for those principles of collective security to which we were pledged and which alone offered a real hope of lasting peace.
The following year. I wrote a letter to the Manchester Guardian saying that ‘the one and only way of preserving the balance in favour of the peace-loving and democratic nations, who are now the trustees of European civilisation, is to be as neighbourly with Russia as we are with France’.
It seemed to me that every concession would increase the Fascists’ demands, and lead inevitably in the long run to war. The alternative advocated by the Labour Party was to make a reality of collective security by international action in support of the Covenant of the League of Nations. This of course would depend on a credible threat of the use of sanctions, in the first place, economic; and in the last resort, military. I had no idea at the time of the extent of our failure to modernise our armed forces, although I did my best to persuade my party to support re-armament. Their annual opposition to the Army estimates seemed to me the height of folly, and I think my only speech at a Party meeting was against this disastrous practice. I was relieved to find that Hugh DaltonFootnote 263 agreed with me, and that as shadow Foreign Secretary was doing his best to convert the Party. It did not help us that our most powerful supporter in the House of Commons was Winston Churchill.Footnote 264
However, ChamberlainFootnote 265 and Halifax were desperately afraid of the spread of communism. Indeed, Halifax praised GöringFootnote 266 for his anti-communism when he visited Germany as a fellow sportsman. Litvinov,Footnote 267 the Soviet Foreign Minister, had offered a tripartite alliance in the spring of 1939. But this offer was turned down. It was only in the early summer that a Foreign Office official, Sir William Strang,Footnote 268 was sent to Moscow to negotiate the terms of a common front against further Nazi aggression. This was a half-hearted effort that never looked likely to succeed. Instead of sending the team of negotiators in a naval vessel through the Baltic, they travelled on a slow merchantman. Having no authority to decide, they were constantly referring back to the Foreign Office. Negotiations dragged on through the summer months until StalinFootnote 269 lost patience, and Hitler sent RibbentropFootnote 270 to do an unscrupulous deal which gave him much more than we could or would offer. Halifax's worst mistake was to give the last opportunity for an alliance with the Soviet Union so little chance of success. I asked my Leader in the House of Lords, Lord Snell, to make this clear in a debate in the House: –
We struggled hard against appeasement because it encouraged the dictators to ask for more. But since the Government abandoned this policy in March, it has failed to replace it by the system of collective security we have advocated all along. Our idea of collective security in Europe always included the Soviet Union as one of the senior partners, and the failure to build up an effective European alliance against further aggression is due to the disastrous bungling of the attempted agreement with Russia.Footnote 271
Mr Roberts, in his admirable biography,Footnote 272 points out that Halifax wanted to avoid giving the impression that we were anxious for a deal. But the Soviet Union, like us, was animated by the strongest form of self-interest, self-preservation, and our own anxiety for a deal would not have made the slightest difference. After weeks had passed without any progress the Russians began to doubt our sincerity. Halifax ought at least to have gone himself, or sent a Cabinet Minister with plenipotentiary powers, instead of a bunch of civil servants without the political weight or authority to conclude the all-important defensive alliance. The opportunity for such an alliance, which would have faced Hitler with – a war on both fronts, East and West, the threat he most feared, was lost by the anti-communist prejudice of Halifax and Chamberlain.
