The period covered by this volume (425–600) used to be one of history's orphans: too late to be properly classical; too early to be properly medieval or Byzantine; too obscure to be of more than passing interest to historians of theology, at least once one got to Chalcedon, which was assumed to have settled christology once and for all, ipso facto ruling out the relevance of anything that succeeded it. The previous CAH, unsurprisingly, ended a full century before this volume begins.
In the latter half of the twentieth century, however, what is now widely known as late antiquity was rediscovered. The editors, with considerable justice, see the beginning of that rediscovery among English-speaking scholars as the publication of A. H. M. Jones' The Later Roman Empire 284–602 in 1964, and of Peter Brown's World of Late Antiquity in 1971. The term ‘late antiquity’ is significant in this context: both works saw the world that was emerging as growing very clearly out of the earlier Mediterranean world demarcated by the borders of the Roman Empire; both saw it as transforming that earlier world in ways both dramatic and subtle. Both applied to it the methods of historical analysis proper to any secular historian and, long honed by classical history, Brown, moreover, pioneered the application to it of the sorts of sociological, psychological and anthropological modes of analysis that are reshaping, often radically, much contemporary historiography. Many of the best of that generation, and of the generation who followed, have contributed to this volume, and it represents a monumental compendium of what is now thought – or, more correctly, what was thought by the end of the twentieth century – about the once-neglected period.
The emergence of Christianity upon the world stage was certainly one of the most important phenomena of late antiquity, and a major factor in the transformation of the Roman world into what was to be medieval Europe in the West, and Byzantium in the East. Christianity, the Christian church and Christian theology, all have their place in this volume, but they do not enjoy pride of place, the privileged place they are accorded in church histories. The central narrative here – the ‘chronological overview’ of part I – is provided by a series of chapters on the Roman Empire and its rulers, from Aetius to Maurice. Attention is paid equally to East and West. To choose the Empire for the central narrative thread implies, of course, a privileging of political history over other narratives that might have been chosen, though in a work that locates itself within the great traditions of classical historiography one would hardly expect any other choice. The predominant interest in things political and, in that sense, social continues in part II (Government and Institutions), part III (East and West: Economy and Society) and part IV (The Provinces and the Non-Roman World). Nonetheless, anyone seeking, for instance, to come to terms with the three ecumenical councils which took place during this period (Ephesus, Chalcedon, Constantinople II) will find very useful background here. Again, in a bow in the direction of the burgeoning area of social history, part III includes a section on the family and another on the family and friendship, areas of life dramatically affected by the growth of Christianity. The way to use a volume like this effectively, clearly enough, is to track down all of the rich background information provided through the quite extensive single index (sixty-five pages long).
We are over 700 pages into the volume before, in the final part, part V, we reach the subject (Religion and Culture) likely to be of primary interest to readers of this journal. Here there are well-thought-out chapters by acknowledged experts on the organisation of the church, monasticism, holy men and doctrine. These are solid analyses, more likely – as might be expected – to cap the achievements of the twentieth century than to pioneer new approaches for the twenty-first. ‘Orthodoxy’ is still used without the quotation marks, for instance, that have become customary in first- and second-century studies to indicate that the word denotes not an objective reality we the readers are assumed to accept, but the self-definition claimed by the victors. On the other hand, groups traditionally dismissed as ‘heretical’, such as those who resisted the Council of Chalcedon's statement of faith, are sometimes described as ‘Monophysites’ (with the welcome quotation marks). The point is not to criticise these chapters, which are very fine indeed, but to indicate that viewpoints that still could be sustained at the turn of the last century are already more likely to be challenged than they were five years ago. It should be noted that part V includes chapters on philosophy, education, the visual arts and building and architecture, all with significant content for the church historian.
An indispensable reference work for anyone interested in the Roman world during the period, CAH, vol. 14 belongs on library shelves and in the studies of all serious students of late antiquity.
