The outcome of a conference held at Heidelberg University in 2004, this collection of twenty-one essays by an impressive line-up of contributors offers an array of investigations of “manners” in American literature, from the colonial era to contemporary fiction. Through its choice of manners as a promising lens for a renewed understanding of American culture, the volume, as Dietmar Schloss explains in his rich introduction, sets itself an even more ambitious goal: a revival and critical reassessment of the somewhat outmoded notion of “civilization,” as discussed by Norbert Elias in his well-known study of The Civilizing Process (1939), which would provide the potential foundation for a new cultural sociology. The “new civilization studies” (xxxi), which Schloss advocates as a viable alternative to current cultural studies with their prevalent view of culture as an inherently coercive social construction, would instead envision the cultural fashioning of the subject through manners and conduct as an asset for the individual and a creative force for society – a tool for creating consent and avoiding conflict, but also an impulse for change. In other words, it would embrace Norbert Elias's idea of civilization as a creative process and manners as a civilizing force, instrumental in fostering the modernization of Western societies: an idea lately shared by other students of early modern European culture (as confirmed, in the first section of this volume, by Manfred Hinz's and Vera Nünning's essays) but hardly ever adopted in American studies.
It would be ungenerous to offer a critique of “civilization studies,” which the introduction clearly presents as a tentative project rather than a fully fledged theory. While certainly promising in its ability to foreground the wealth of nuances of social life and call new attention to their literary significance – a focus which can successfully complement an analysis of larger power dynamics and enrich our understanding of their operation – “civilization studies” is in many ways problematic as a general claim. Possibly its most problematic trait is its heavy reliance on an inevitable, strictly Eurocentric notion of the civilization process, which severely limits its potential as a theoretical alternative to cultural studies; also dubious is its lack of an explicit theoretical connection with the question of class and/or with an overall theory of society (one thinks of Pierre Bourdieu, whose insights on habitus and on the composite nature of capital in modern societies are germane to many of the issues discussed in the volume). A concept that is as all-encompassing and pervasive as difficult to define univocally, “civilization” provides an inevitably slippery theoretical basis for a new account of the social process; nor does the notion of “manners,” linked as it is to the emergence of modern bourgeois culture and its struggle to establish itself, offer any firmer ground for generalization.
And yet, the very culturally and historically specific traits that hamper the usefulness of civilization or manners as a theoretical category turn out to be instrumental to its success as a critical tool capable of enhancing our understanding of social life and literary representation within the purview of its historical framework – especially in those places and at those times when communal self-definition is in progress and cultural authority is up for grabs, as has been the case for much of United States history. Tackling texts, authors, or cultural phenomena that self-awarely foreground manners as crucial, thematically or historically, to their cultural concerns or intentions, the case studies analyzed in Civilizing America persuasively demonstrate Schloss's claim of the relevance of this category to an understanding of American culture and of the need to address it as part of the pursuit of American studies.
Focussing on crucial junctures of American history, the last four sections of the volume demonstrate the complex imbrication of the question of manners with all layers of social and political life: matters of savagery and civilization, of orthodoxy and heresy, of social hierarchization and local literary production in colonial and early Republican America (J. Fliegelman, M. B. Purucker, D. Schultz, D. S. Shields, W. Verhoeven); questions of ethics and character in its philosophical dimension (H. Friedl on Emerson); and questions of local, regional, religious, and national belonging and their differentiation along lines of gender in the early nineteenth century, with the accompanying implications in terms of linguistic and literary representation (J. T. Richter, J. McWilliams, T. Clark, C. Mulvey). In turn-of-the-century America, the object of the third section, manners operate as part of a new social technology of self-fashioning and self-regulation, deployed as a touchstone of innate moral value in a (supposedly) classless society, as a performance of self on a social stage, or else as simultaneously a tool and an object in a complex semiotic negotiation, which involves both the characters and the narrative economy of the “novel of manners” itself in a complex play of authenticity and duplicity (S. Winnett, B. Friedl, S. Perosa, G. Scharnhorst, K. Müller). Finally, the last section, devoted to the twentieth century, offers two readings of texts that rewrite “manners” from a dissensual, critically racial stance (J. Klinkowitz on I. Reed and D. Fischer-Hornung on L. M. Silko), framed by two sweeping surveys investigating the relationships of manners with modernity and American studies (W. Fluck) and with alienation, identity, and contemporary fiction (H. Ickstadt).
While it does not quite bear out its more ambitious general claims, Civilizing America, in its array of informative, documented, and sometimes downright fascinating essays, does make a convincing case for its focus on manners as an approach capable of providing new insights on American literature in its relentless engagement with American society.
