In recent years, scholars have periodized the history of modern Jerusalem and treated separately the years of modern reforms during the 19th century, the end of Ottoman rule in Jerusalem during World War I, life during the war, and the onset of British rule in December 1917. Roberto Mazza's Jerusalem: From the Ottomans to the British moves this literature forward in important directions by examining the history of modern Jerusalem as whole from the period of late Ottoman rule to the British occupation.
Mazza's work deals with three topics: the transition from Ottoman to British administration in Jerusalem, the experience of Jerusalem's residents during World War I, and the question of sources and historiography. Many works have devoted attention to Jerusalem either in the late Ottoman or in the British period, but Mazza's focus on the transition from Ottoman to British rule as a distinct phase of history is unique. His attention to the experience of World War I in Jerusalem contributes to a growing body of literature on the difficulties that residents of the city faced during these years. Mazza's discussion of sources and historiography has two related goals: first, to expand the use of Western sources in languages not traditionally accessed by scholars working on Jerusalem, such as French, Italian, and Spanish; and second, to include the production of narratives about Jerusalem in languages other than English, Arabic, and Hebrew, so as to allow for greater communication between scholars of different linguistic backgrounds. His interest in drawing upon a broader field of Western sources is vindicated by his impressive use of Western consular records and rarely used European memoirs and diaries, which allow him to provide interesting vignettes on Jerusalem's administration in the late Ottoman period or the difficulties the city's residents experienced during the years of World War I. Although these sources in European languages, such as French, Italian, and Spanish, contribute to our understanding of the period under study, Mazza's treatment of various topics, primarily the fate of Jerusalem's residents during World War I, could at times benefit from personal and intimate accounts by local residents and officials, which were written in Arabic, Ottoman-Turkish, Hebrew, as well as the various European languages of Jerusalem's Jewish population.
Chapter 1, “Modernising Jerusalem: Administration and Population,” opens with a discussion of the modern reforms enacted during the 19th century. Although Mazza constructs a narrative familiar to most students of Jerusalem's modern history, he introduces non-English European sources that animate his account. For example, he uses Italian diplomatic records to explore a dispute over taxes in 1911 between the Italian hospital in Jerusalem and the Jerusalem Administrative Council (Meclis-i Idare), providing a valuable example of how Ottoman institutions functioned at this time. In this chapter he also provides careful demographic calculations of Jerusalem's varied ethnic and religious populations.
The second chapter, “Christianity at War,” explores the position of religious institutions in the city during the war years. One interesting example Mazza unveils is the case of the Catholic Custodia Terrae Sanctae (Custody of the Holy Land), the Franciscan order that had the responsibility of enforcing the Status Quo agreement meant to manage the religious sites in the Holy Land. Through memoirs belonging to two of its highest authorities (custos) that cover the years from 1914 to 1924, Mazza sheds light on how Christian institutions negotiated their relations with Jerusalem's Ottoman authorities during the war, as they faced seizure of goods and provisions as well as the occupation of religious buildings. The brief discussion of the growing alliance between Arab Christians and Muslims after World War I to confront Zionism raises methodological questions such as how a study of late Ottoman Jerusalem is related to the larger regional (i.e., Palestinian) and imperial (i.e., Ottoman) contexts: To what extent did the shifting nature of identity found throughout the empire in the years before World War I contribute to an emerging alliance between Christians and Muslims in Jerusalem after the war? And to what extent did these new forms of identity exist beyond Jerusalem, toward including all of Palestine?
Chapter 3, “Foreigners in Jerusalem,” examines Jerusalem's foreign residents, such as consular agents, before World War I. The author's use of the memoir of the Spanish consul Conde de Ballobar (1913–19), who intermingled with the city's political elite and Arab notables and lived in a “microcosm which reflected the larger context of the war in the Middle East” (p. 107), furthers our understanding of life in late Ottoman Jerusalem and the war years. Mazza's effort here is consistent with that of Salim Tamari, who has edited and translated the memoirs of two other Jerusalem contemporaries, Ihsan Turjman (Years of the Locust: A Soldier's Diary and the Erasure of Palestine's Ottoman Past [New York: Routledge, 2011]) and Wasif Jawhariyyeh (al-quds al-’uthmaniyya fi al-mudhakkirat al-Jawhariyya, vol. I, ed. Salim Tamari and Issam Nassar [Jerusalem: Institute of Jerusalem Studies, 2003]).
The overall impact of the war on the city is discussed in Chapter 4, “The War and the British Conquest of Jerusalem.” This chapter follows the increasing attention devoted to Jerusalemites’ experience of the war, the Ottoman mobilization for war, and the impressions Jerusalem residents had of British occupation. Readers might desire a deeper exploration of how Jerusalemites faced the hardships of the war, which can only be culled from the various memoirs, dairies, and other sources of local Jerusalem residents and institutions that the few scholars (e.g., Tamari and Abigail Jacobson) who have written about this period have used. Rather, the chapter focuses heavily on the still important discussion of how Britain initiated a propaganda campaign through the press to infuse a narrative that depicted a “Crusading spirit” (p. 143) to justify occupying Jerusalem and Palestine, helping to boost the morale of a war-weary British public and military.
The focus of Chapter 5, “British Military Rule 1917–1920 and the case of the Nebi Musa Riots,” addresses the transition of the British administration in Jerusalem from military to civilian rule. The author first looks closely at the career of Ronald Storrs, Jerusalem's military governor (1917–20) and civil governor (1920–26), who despite the absence of a proper study of his tenure in Jerusalem had a “huge impact on setting the character of modern Jerusalem” (p. 159). For example, Mazza shows how Storrs’ founding of the Pro-Jerusalem Society in 1918 allowed the governor to preserve Jerusalem though his own “British and Victorian ideals” and maintain its “‘celestial’ character” (p. 162), a sentiment manifested in his removal of the Clock Tower built by the Ottomans in 1902 above the Jaffa Gate, which he saw as an “alien element” (p. 164). The author closely examines the riots that erupted at the Islamic Nabi Musa (Prophet Moses) festival in April 1920 in Jerusalem, which convinced British authorities that a civil regime more sympathetic to enacting the Balfour Declaration and the goals of Zionism needed to replace what appeared to be a military administration hostile to Zionism. Based on my own study on this topic, I would dispute the author's claim that the two groups—Arabs and Jews—were organized and the riots planned (p. 174); rather, the riots seem to have been far more spontaneous in nature, born of the heightened political tensions that characterized Palestine in the months leading up to the conflagration.
Overall, Roberto Mazza's Jerusalem: From the Ottomans to the British provides students of the modern Middle East, Palestine, and Jerusalem a cogent and rich discussion of a unique moment in Jerusalem's history, as it shifted from Ottoman to British rule, bringing together sources that will inspire other researchers to investigate further. He should be commended for undertaking such thorough research to complete this study. The high price of the book, however, may make it prohibitive to adopt in the classroom.
