Cultural historians of science will find in this book a model for thinking broadly about the social spaces of early modern material culture and about the prose conventions that made perceptual order out of those spaces, lending their objects an aspect of vivid reality. Cynthia Sundberg Wall's achievement is the more remarkable for the fact that science is not her main concern. Her engagement with the primary sources and secondary literatures of history and philosophy of science is quite limited. The Prose of Things is not a rigorous historical epistemology that single-mindedly tracks developments in tightly defined categories. Nor is it a causal cultural history that fully explains the shift from the general and symbolic to the particular and the local in eighteenth-century writing. Rather, it draws together insights from ‘thing theory’ in a historically informed account that makes possible a set of close readings which open up the transformation of the dimensions of descriptive prose.
Description has always seemed the poor relation of interpretation. Aristotelian scorn for details as accidental rather than essential suggested that things possessed no truth in and of their particular selves, becoming meaningful only through acquiring symbolic function. Think, for instance, of the objects and spaces of John Bunyan's Pilgrim's Progress (1678). These work allegorically to describe a spiritual rather than literal journey. Bunyan's was a world of relative material sparseness, in which writers drew on a shared ‘cultural storehouse’ (p. 11) of stock images with reliable resonances for readers. Late in the seventeenth century, Wall argues, space became localized, and things began to acquire a startlingly vivid reality in their own right. Although a Dickensian thickness of description lay far off, variety, particularity and texture became newly worthy of attention. Despite the faith in divine design that motivated them, Robert Hooke's microscopic examinations of the structures of common things and beings (fleas, for example) had the effect of endowing ordinary matter with new importance. The diarists John Evelyn and Samuel Pepys, meanwhile, wrote not spiritual autobiographies but voluminous accounts of local social worlds, Pepys demonstrating a precocious connoisseurial interest in the arrangement of household interiors (tellingly, both he and Evelyn were first published only in the early nineteenth century). Jonathan Swift mobilized satirical details to reveal the scabs and warts of the Augustan establishment; Daniel Defoe's characters moved in a world awash in new mercantile goods; and Samuel Richardson brought material objects indoors, beginning to sketch the increasingly crowded interiors that would become ubiquitous in the Victorian era. By the early nineteenth century Sir Walter Scott's Ivanhoe (1819) marked a turn in historical writing from the sweeping to the mundane. History itself became ‘real’ through vivid quotidian details that made it seem like the present.
Wall links these reoriented fictional regimes of description to transformations in key social spaces and non-fictional genres: shops, advertisements, auctions, auction catalogues, houses and house-guides, tour guides, and handbooks on furniture and landscape gardening. A personnage clé here is Horace Walpole, who engaged the new world of things both as fashionable consumer and as surreal Gothic novelist. Exhilarated and exasperated by the literal and symbolic stresses of accumulation, he loved auctions but fretted they would ruin him, and commented wrily on how volatile fashions made systematic collecting and the stable attribution of value all but impossible. Hence the unnerving shower of giant helmets and gigantic limbs raining down on his characters in The Castle of Otranto (1764) – people literally dominated by things. As Wall explains, in an era when Thomas Chippendale and Josiah Wedgwood were revolutionizing popular relations to consumer objects through genres like furniture handbooks and venues like the showroom, accumulation made possible – if it did not necessitate – a new art of arranging one's things as a form of individual self-expression. Where objects had stood as external to human actors, the emergent late eighteenth-century emphasis on interiority now anthropomorphized and individuated particular objects and spaces in prose narratives, which in turn conveyed an essential sense of the inner lives of their characters.
Though slightly uneven, with connections sometimes more asserted than fully demonstrated, Wall's study is highly stimulating, and engages a question of fundamental importance that should be of interest to historians of science, especially early modernists. Avoiding a form of Marxist analysis that would reduce the overflowing material realities of eighteenth-century prose, scientific and otherwise, to a narrow narrative about the rise of possessive individualism in that century, Wall performs a wonderfully eye-opening exercise in what might be called ‘literary phenomenology’: the study of how prose has been used in different ways to register perceptual realities as constituted by interactions among persons, things and spaces. Herein lies the great value of the book for historians of science. Wall's approach could prove extremely fruitful for imaginatively rethinking a number of scientific genres and practices where the question of spatial relations is central, such as natural history, travel, collecting and display. Wall's touchstone is Virginia Woolf's observation that the central image in Robinson Crusoe is a large earthenware pot. Wall succeeds in getting us to see such things no longer merely as the objects of cold economic utility, but as heralding the materialization of a new perceptual order: one where ordinary things became real as objects of knowledge and desire in a way they never had before.
