In November 2007, Slow Food convened its Fifth International Congress in Puebla, Mexico, the first such event to be held outside of Europe. The organisation, which was founded in opposition to the global spread of North American fast food, has had a special interest in Mexico, where the festival foods are slow indeed. Yet even as international delegates savoured delicious mole poblano and barbacoa, such delicacies were becoming increasingly difficult to obtain in popular barrios because of rising food prices and ecological pressures. In this captivating and important book, geographer Marie Elisa Christie describes the efforts of women in three rural towns to preserve their traditional cuisine – and the communities that depend upon it – in the face of rapid urbanisation.
As Christie observes, the word ‘kitchen’ alone can hardly do justice to the complex physical and social environments in which women cook in these towns. To begin with, they maintain two separate spaces, an indoor cocina de diario for everyday family meals, which are often cooked on modern appliances, and an outdoor cocina de humo for preparing vast earthenware pots of mole and rice over smoky fires. Moreover, the boundaries between these spaces are marked less by physical walls than by social activities. While a single individual will often make ordinary meals, festival cooking is by definition a collective task undertaken by circles of women. Anthropologists have long observed the importance of this labour for the religious celebrations that bind communities together. Christie shows further that women's work spills out from the kitchen to become part of these public rituals. Rather than isolating women, such work connects them to vital social networks. The author's understanding of these multiple, overlapping spaces emerges in part from the innovative methodology of asking her informants to draw their own kitchens and explain how they use them.
Needless to say, kitchens are highly gendered spaces that ensure the social reproduction of families and communities. Although festival cooking also depends on male labour – for example, in the slaughter of livestock and cooking of meat – Christie shows men as uncomfortable outsiders within the kitchen. When they do enter, they usually eat quickly and leave quietly; woe betide the man foolish enough to crack a joke about these matriarchs. Power relations are equally pervasive among women and children, and each cooking circle has a clear chain of command leading up to the female head of the household sponsoring a particular feast. These work parties provide an efficient means of passing along rituals and traditions to the next generation, although younger women often complain that elders withhold crucial parts of recipes as a way of preserving their own position. In this richly textured ethnography, Christie pays fitting tribute to the labour of food preparation. It is a pity, however, that she does not give greater attention to the rituals of consumption. Even when men are present, family meals seem little more than the feeding of children.
The challenges of modernity are ever present in the towns of Xochimilco, Ocotepec and Tetecala, which are all located within a few hours' drive from Mexico City. Xochimilco, famous for its chinampa hydroponic gardens, has suffered ecological devastation as the capital's incessant thirst has caused lake water to be pumped away and replaced with sewage. Likewise, Ocotepec has faced steady incursions on its land from real estate developers in neighbouring Cuernavaca. While these two communities have confronted rapid urban growth, Tetepec's residents have increasingly departed, unable to make a living from their tropical orchards, and their places have been taken by migrants from farther south in the state of Guerrero. Everywhere, the churning of population has unsettled communities. Many farmers have abandoned their fields, saying it is impossible to protect their crops and livestock from thieves. To preserve social stability, women must re-enact the miracle of feeding the multitudes; where festival participants once numbered a few score, cooks now conjure mole and rice for upwards of a thousand.
Yet Christie is careful to show that responses to modernity have not been a stereotype of peasant stubbornness, but rather flexible adaptation to new circumstances. She emphasises the role of sazón – literally ‘seasoning’, but more broadly, individual taste and creativity – as a marker of distinction. While her informants express intense concern about traditional flavours – the mole of Xochimilco requires sweet pasilla chillis and bitter chocolate, and one should not even think about trying to pass off commercial mole on a crowd – the skill of bringing these disparate ingredients into harmony is recognised as an individual gift. Moreover, people insist that local traditions will not only survive, but will be improved. Not everyone may agree that the future is Nescafé-cured pulque, but microwave popcorn has already become an instant festival tradition, further blurring the division between public and private as women run long extension cords from the streets back into their homes. Some of the strongest supporters of tradition are newcomers who seek acceptance within a community by their adherence to established rituals. Nevertheless, many ambitious young women express frustration with the limitations of cooking for their families and wish to find opportunities outside the home.
This book makes an important addition to the emerging feminist literature on culinary labour. Like the recent work of Meredith Abarca, Voices in the Kitchen (2006), which also emphasises sazón as a source of empowerment, Christie has conveyed an invaluable perspective on society, ecology and even cosmology through the words of hardworking Mexican women. If the Slow Food movement is to succeed in its mission of promoting a sustainable food system, it must start by making itself relevant to their lives.
