Abortion politics are highly visible to the public, at least when it comes to Supreme Court decisions, street demonstrations, and violence against abortion providers. Political scientists and others who follow electoral politics more than casually are typically aware that abortion politics in the 1970s significantly shifted the focus of the Republican Party to family-values issues in ways that continue to reverberate in contemporary politics, such as in the recent rise of the Tea Party movement. But abortion politics in Congress, especially in the House, occur largely under the radar of most people, including professional political scientists. As a result, if you ask the average politically aware person who was the most active congressional sponsor of constitutional amendments to ban abortion, most would answer: the late Henry Hyde (R-IL), Chris Smith (R-NJ), or perhaps another well-known conservative representative. As Scott Ainsworth and Thad Hall note, the correct but surprising answer is Rep. James Oberstar, not only a Democrat, but also a dyed-in-the-wool liberal from Minnesota. Aiming to address such gaps in knowledge, Abortion Politics in Congress: Strategic Incrementalism and Policy Change offers a thorough analysis of abortion politics in the US Congress, particularly the House of Representatives.
As the title suggests, Ainsworth and Hall argue that policy incrementalism has been more successful in abortion politics than the sort of radical change outlined in the rhetoric of many movement activists on both sides of the abortion issue. They posit several reasons why incrementalism is more strategic: If change is difficult in general, overturning Supreme Court decisions is even more daunting. The legislative process is long and complex. Incrementalism resonates symbolically while allowing members of Congress slowly to construct a coherent story regarding legislative change. Because it proceeds slowly, incrementalism is less likely to attract strong oppositional lobbying efforts. And last but not least, most Americans favor a limited practice of abortion, making radical change difficult on either the pro-life or pro-choice side of the debate.
This book explores the practice of incrementalism on abortion policy in the House in the years since 1973, the year of the famously controversial decision of Roe v. Wade. It is divided into two parts, the first of which details the theoretical basis of strategic incrementalism, the legislative history of abortion, and the relationship between the two. The second part addresses abortion politics in the House, especially the politics of bill sponsorship and committee referral.
Like most legislative proposals, the typical abortion bill dies in committee. That said, although no major abortion bill has passed, many incremental proposals have. Ainsworth and Hall show that 80 percent of these proposals further a pro-life agenda, of which a remarkable 25 percent have been successful. Although they find that religion is likely to lessen adherence to incrementalism, ideology is not a factor, even when the median House member trends conservative and despite the fact that party leaders tend not to whip on abortion. While upwards of 60 percent of such bills were assigned to the Judiciary Committee in the years immediately following Roe, this number decreased as abortion opponents began to utilize committees such as Appropriations, Armed Services, and International Relations to further the incrementalist agenda. This approach is most famously exemplified by the Hyde Amendment, the rider that has been attached to appropriations bills since 1976 to limit the use of federal funds to subsidize abortions.
Findings such as these lead Ainsworth and Hall to suggest that incremental policy change is better suited to the institutional structure of Congress than the supermajoritarian politics of constitutional amendments. While they concede that radical politics may more successfully foster vigorous social movements on either side of the issue, they argue that incrementalism is better suited to policy change at the institutional level, pointing to the legislation passed in 2003 outlawing partial-birth abortion as a case in point. Rather than pushing for a bill to prohibit all late-term abortions, sponsors decided to restrict a specific procedure, successfully effectuating a major step in the incremental agenda.
The prohibition on partial-birth abortion raises the question whether a tipping point short of the ultimate pro-life victory of overturning Roe can be identified. Unfortunately, the authors' account of incrementalism does not directly address this issue. Quoting Rep. Robert Dornan (R-CA), Ainsworth and Hall note that the ultimate goal of pro-life forces, for all their incrementalism, remains the overturn of Roe: “We've got to start somewhere. We have to take this one step at a time” (108). However, I would have liked to have heard the authors discuss the relation between incrementalism and this ultimate goal in greater detail. Given the ultimate goal of overturning Roe, does incrementalism slip into a less stealthy, more radical politics at some point? Certainly the debates on partial-birth abortion were more visible to the public than most of the other bills discussed in this book. If so, what ramifications, if any, did this have for maintaining the practice of strategic incrementalism?
As the authors note, abortion politics is, in the end, a story about how American politics works. It offers a rich mixture of morality politics and judicial constitutional interpretation, but it also includes elements that are often overlooked, such as judicial-congressional relations, legislative gridlock, and strategic incrementalism. The authors nicely fill these gaps, bringing these aspects of the story together with the more visible elements of abortion politics, providing a more complete narrative than one usually finds in the professional literature on this issue. The book includes a variety of data drawn from the 93rd–108th Congresses, such as leading sponsors of abortion legislation, ideological scores for key House members, and ideological distance between members on key committees, just to name a few. This book would be useful for political scientists in a variety of subfields, as well as for advanced undergraduates and graduate students interested in better understanding the complex politics of abortion in the United States.
