Deirdre Heenan and Derek Birrell call into question the uniqueness of social work in Northern Ireland and investigate the extent to which lessons can be drawn in this context. This analysis starts from the observation that few books have been devoted to this topic and that material on the issue is limited. Each of the eight core chapters discusses a key theme in social work. The authors first consider the implications of the sectarianism and violence resulting from the Northern Irish conflict and then focus on distinctive characteristics of the province: a structurally integrated system of health and social work services; community development approaches; the existence of a border on the island, a long-lasting poverty and the province's history of devolution. This remains a strenuous undertaking as it implies two distinct processes of evaluation: an assessment of Northern Ireland social work policy and of its response to a specific context of conflict as well as an assessment of the potential and actual transferability of the province's experience.
The book seems to highlight a story of policy failures. Sectarianism and violence are both considered as unique factors influencing social work practice. From the mid-1990s, the neutral and technical approach to sectarianism was challenged and ‘(connected) to the development of anti-racist, anti-discrimination and anti-oppressive practice agendas in Britain’ (p. 29). Anti-discrimination measures were absorbed into Section 75 of the 1998 Belfast Agreement that implemented broader equality provisions and a good relations strategy. Nevertheless, despite the relative success of legislative frameworks and affirmative actions, the authors point out that the result is a legalistic and managerialist approach to social work that does not adequately address social inequalities.
Confronted with the province's long history of violence, social work in Northern Ireland has developed a specific approach of emergency planning from the mid 1990s. Moreover, it has predominantly emphasised ‘trauma and related consequences’ as part of its mental illness policy strategy. The authors argue that social workers’ response to violence has not been fully analysed and evaluated for policy learning or policy transfer in either Northern Ireland or Great Britain. Also, that both the planning expertise and equality provisions aforementioned are not considered in UK policy formulation.
The community development approach, as a method of intervention, re-emerged in the UK in the early 1990s and could be easily adopted in Northern Ireland, a province that is characterised by a long-lasting tradition of voluntary and community work. UK legislation in the province was committed to mainstreaming the approach and focused particularly on health and social care. However, reviews reveal professionals’ ‘high level of unfamiliarity with the principles of community development, [which] suggests that it is not afforded a high priority’ (p. 87). Based on the failure of health and social care providers to materialise this mainstream approach, the authors conclude that the Northern Ireland experience does not provide for generalised insights aimed at tackling an ongoing bureaucratic social work in the province or in any other parts of the UK.
Northern Ireland's long-lasting status of ‘the most deprived or one of the most deprived regions of the UK’ (p. 109) raises the complex issue of poverty. It is deeply linked to social work practice, as poverty cannot be discussed without a concern for inequalities in, and amongst, others − the pay structure, childcare, or education − and for the impact of conflict on mental health. The book argues that devolved administration in the province, from 1998, has failed to ‘reach a consensus on a core social policy’ (p. 127) and to overcome identity politics. This has led to grounding policy development on ‘horizontal equality’ (which considers groups of people) rather than on ‘vertical equality’ (focusing on income) and to a general lack of innovations (p. 126).
The Northern Irish devolution experience was expected to provide for transferable insights, but the authors conclude that the devolved government's strategy, from 1999, has lacked innovations and performance on social care. Also, the existence of an internal land frontier dividing the island of Ireland is a unique feature of social work in Northern Ireland. Cross-border social work is a reality but a dramatic lack of research in this area remains problematic. Additionally, the authors point out a general failure in mainstreaming statutory cooperation on the island, divergences in professional social work education and a fragmentation of funding sources, leading to a very restricted applicability to other regions of the UK.
The historically integrated structure of health and social care is argued to be the most positive outcome of the Northern Irish system and to offer possible transferability. The book concludes however that even this achievement has not yet reached its full potential and that it has received little attention from government, assembly, departments and board policy (p. 72). Some key elements, for example user and public involvement, are still lagging behind Great Britain's modernisation agendas.
In their book, the authors meet the practical aim of social policy as they seek to identify insights from the Northern Irish experience in order to improve social work practice in general. Additionally, they adopt a normative approach that leads them to draw a negative assessment of policy responses to the challenges that they have identified. They support their argument by highlighting that social policy is not seen (unlike Scotland) as the main concern and function of the Northern Irish Assembly and that the institution suffers from a lack of social justice values (p. 149). Eventually, they stress a general lack of policy learning and transfer from the Northern Ireland experience, despite some promising elements.
The authors provide for a very relevant and critically analysed overview of policy evolution, impact and transferability in Northern Ireland. This knowledge does fill a gap in academic research, and is invaluable for political analysis. The authors raise key issues, such as democratic accountability, the ‘quangos model’ and policy-makers’ lack of involvement, understanding and success that would be particularly relevant for public policy analysis and for a broader conflict resolution perspective.
