Janaki Nair's Mysore Modern takes a novel approach in examining the recreation of the kingdom of Mysore during the period of princely rule by examining the development of visual and spatial aesthetics and legal reforms through which the Wodeyar dynasty distinguished their royal heritage from the legacy of Tipu Sultan and legitimated their royal authority through “exhibitionary display.” Through her analysis, the “enlightened modernity” of Mysore is shown as deliberate construction from the underlying currents of political anxiety that shrouded the Wodeyar lineage following their “reestablishment” on the throne of Mysore.
Mysore Modern can be divided into two primary parts. The first (chapters 1 through 5) examines the transition from the Muslim rule of Haidar Ali and Tipu Sultan to the establishment of Krishnaraja Wodeyar III as king of Mysore in 1799 and the subsequent “museumization” of the city of Mysore. In this section, the former capital of Srirangapatna, the former seat of the Vijayanagara viceroy and the Wodeyar/Tipu Sultan empire from 1610 CE, is contrasted to the city of Mysore, which became the seat of royal power after the defeat of Tipu Sultan. Nair demonstrates how the British actively sought to retell the history of Tipu through critiques of his palace art that depicted his successful battles against the British found in his Dariya Daulat palace. This was contrasted to the European notion of history painting through which the British and Wodeyars could “accurately depict” past events. This process created a new visual aesthetic and legitimated Wodeyar rule. Equally important for the legitimization of the royals was the reconceptualization of city-space. Nair shows how the once vibrant city of Srirangapatna became a site for the commemoration of the fallen British soldiers and a lasting memorial to the fall of the mighty Muslim ruler. Conversely, Mysore, which had been important only because of a few Wodeyar temples and a small fort, was consciously created as a space for public display of the royal power through the construction of the Royal Palace and the performance of Dasara and other royal festivals. The shifting aesthetic styles eventually culminate in the art of K. Venkatappa, which focuses on themes that are more directly concerned with politics in a nationalist model instead of the traditional focus on kingship.
In the second section, Nair focuses on legal reforms that signal the transition from the power of a monarch to the bureaucratic system of “modernity”. She focuses on the regulations regarding women's inheritance rights in the cases of devadasis and child brides. In both of these cases, women became the site on which issues of tradition, gender, and morality could be discussed in ways that transcended caste distinction. The book concludes with the “reunification” of Karnataka and the dissolution of the Mysorean state in preference of the linguistically defined territory. According to Nair, the creation of Karnataka caps the transition from the monarchal rule of the premodern Mysore to the modern state, which is unified based on language and shared culture rather than divine kingship.
Nair's book is engaging and thought-provoking throughout. She does an excellent job presenting the transition from Tipu Sultan's state to princely rule of the Wodeyars in a creative and fresh manner that forces us to reconsider the role of the dynasty and the construction of their enlightened and modern identity. In the second half of the book, however, the tone changes, as do the types of materials that she is analyzing that made the book seem a bit too disjointed. While the overall argument of the book (the shift from monarchal rule to bureaucratic state) is not hampered by the shift, this reader would have liked to see Nair continue her analysis of the ways in which the power and authority were displayed in twentieth-century Karnataka beyond K. Venkatappa. Another issue that Mysore Modern left unsettled for me was the author's use of terms “modern” and “modernity.” Nair begins her introduction with a promising discussion of the construction of modernity through constituent elements that arise within the region; however, I wanted her to return to the concept of modernity itself and reflect on the broader issues of constructing the concept through the accumulation of the various aesthetics and reforms that developed in Mysore.
Neither of these critiques, however, can take away from the importance of Mysore Modern, which is a wonderful exploration of Mysore during princely rule that is further illuminated in contrast to the periods before and after. It would be quite helpful for those concerned with the construction of power and authority during princely rule in any region of British India as a whole, and it is a “must read” for anyone interested in Karnataka, Mysore, or the Wodeyar Dynasty.
