Since 1972, I have monitored the participation of women at the American Political Science Association Annual Meetings. The reports have been published each year in PS: Political Science and Politics. (I'm planning to do this again this summer in Philadelphia.) From time to time, I have also authored surveys of female participation at regional meetings of political science associations.
In 1988, 1991, and 1994, I was able to undertake analysis of the participation of women at the International Political Science Congresses (held every three years on a different continent). This summer, since I went to Fukuoka, Japan, to give two papers and chair a panel at the 2006 IPSA gathering, I decided to undertake another tally of participation.
If it's a problem identifying the gender of participants at American meetings (are the Terrys or Lees male or female? When I was researching my book, Women in American Politics, I discovered that a state superintendent of public instruction named Adel was a man!), it's much more challenging deciphering the gender of scholars from Asia, Africa, the Middle East, Latin America, and Europe.
Fortunately, as before, I was able to enlist the assistance of my former colleagues, Zillur Khan (for South Asia) and Ruben de Hoyos (for Latin America). I also had help from Fumiko Fukata, chairperson of my university's foreign language department, and The-Kuang Chang, professor of political science at Ball State University, a friend of my former colleague David Chang, who had assisted me in the three earlier IPSA tallies.
One consistent in my findings over the years is that the presence of women in gatekeeper positions (association president, program committee member, section chair, panel chair) facilitated opportunity for participation by other women. Without women providing opportunities for other women, the female contribution at these meetings would be much less. Many countries have a small number of female political scientists. They many not be teaching at major universities or be in senior positions. They face greater difficulties in getting funding to travel to IPSA meetings. Often, male leaders have a blind spot in recognizing the contributions of women professionals. (Of course, there are occasional women who are “one of the guys,” token panelists who don't see a reason to give opportunity to sister scholars.)
The 2006 program chair was females as was one other member out of nine on the Program Committee. Of the conveners and co-conveners, 27.5% were women (cf. 15.6% in 1988, 14.9% in 1991, and 19.3% in 1994). (See Table 1.)
Participation in the Plenary Sessions, Subfield Sessions, Research Committees, Study Groups, Special Sessions, etc.
Sections headed by women provided 25.7% of the female chairs at the 2006 Congress, 21.0% of the female papergivers, and 50.0% of the female discussants. Panels organized by women accounted for 45.0% of the female papergivers and 57.5% of the female discussants.
How does this performance compare to the participation at the APSA Annual Meeting? At the 2005 APSA Annual Meeting in Washington, D.C., women were 29.5% of the chairpersons, 30.0% of the papergivers, and 27.5% of the discussants. Women were 29.4% of the section heads. (These women-led sections had 40.6% of the Annual Meetings' female panel chairs, 35.3% of the papergivers, and 41.8% of the discussants.)
Author Bio
Martin Gruberg is professor of political science at the University of Wisconsin, Oshkosh. He has been active in the women's caucuses almost since their inception, circa 1970, and was president of the caucus of the Midwest Political Science Association. He has authored a book on women in American politics and taught courses in the women's studies program at his university.
