David Jones in this excellent book pinpoints the two crucial issues. When is it legitimate to deliberately end a human life? And how do we live well in the face of death? In addition, he is concerned with the ethics of euthanasia and the pastoral theology of caring. However, his answers to these questions only appear in his brief final chapter and the book actually is an exposition of four theologians’ views on death.
Jones' bibliography gives a sense of the breadth of his research and depth in analysing Ambrose, Augustine, Aquinas and Rahner's contributions to a theology of death. He clearly shows how one theologian builds upon another, to create a rich exegesis of a Catholic theology of death. In this era of sound bites and emotionally charged debates on physician-assisted suicide, this erudite and helpful book is a welcome counterpoint to strictly medical, philosophical or pop culture's treatment of dying. Jones displays a broad and deep knowledge of theology and church history. Furthermore, he exposes philosophical inaccuracies such as Granville Williams' misunderstanding of Christians’ opposition to infanticide, linked to false arguments about euthanasia, or lesser known facts such as Granger Westberg's foreshadowing of Kübler-Ross.
Jones not only summarises these theologians’ positions but explains their general theological framework. Some highlights of Jones' treatment of these theologians are as follows:
Ambrose of Milan (339–397 ce)
Ambrose represents a blend of Christian faith and Platonic philosophy and references three deaths: death to sin; physical death; death of the soul by mortal sin. He reflects the Greek view of death as freeing the soul from the body and does not really have a full-blown view of the resurrection. His concern is for the life of the soul which flourishes in death.
Augustine (354–430 ce)
Augustine is influenced by Ambrose but moved well past his thought. He avoids his Platonism and the equation of the fear of death with a lack of faith. Later he acknowledges grief as appropriate for the Christian. Ultimately he understands the death of the body and soul as evils resulting from punishment for sin and, unlike Ambrose, embraces a doctrine of bodily resurrection. Augustine avoids the spirit/flesh dichotomy which misreadings of Pauline theology can create. Jones' exposition of Augustine's opposition to suicide helps us understand how the contemporary distinction between suicide and heroic self-sacrifice has Augustinian roots.
Aquinas (1225–1274)
Aquinas embraces the mature Augustine and marries his theology to an Aristotelian framework, i.e. the nature of the soul and its relationship to the body are key to the Thomastic theology of death. The rational soul is non-material and indestructible. By itself it does not constitute a human person but exists in its own right and it is better off in the human body. In resurrection, the body must be raised for the soul to be complete.
Death is both natural and unnatural because death is due to the fallen nature of humans, which robs us of our immortality. However, it brings us to our eternal happiness. Aquinas' arguments against suicide are a further development of Augustine, based on the love of self, God and community.
Karl Rahner (1904–1984)
Rahner, a German Jesuit, uses Thomistic theology in conversation with a post-Kantian existentialism. His goal is to develop a more integrated synthesis of grace and nature in his theology of death while acknowledging its mystery. (I was surprised that Martin Marty, Cry of Absence, was not in Jones' bibliography as it is an excellent appropriation of Rahner's insights on death.) Rahner picks up Aquinas' discussion of the soul which at death becomes pancosmic. There is an aspect of death which is neutral rather than evil, but suffering and death contain an element of martyrdom. Ultimately death is a human act – dying to sin and life.
Jones' Conclusion
Building on his exposition of these four theologians, Jones presents a theological approach to grief, fear and hope and the meaning of a good death. In a Christian theology there is genuine grief even if there is a better life awaiting the saved. Prayers for the dead are offered still but not so much against the day of wrath as solidarity with the dead. Fear of death is tempered by hope but fear helps us to realise our need for God's grace. There is a rejection of suicide and its distinction from martyrdom.
Jones concludes that physician-assisted suicide is wrong because suicide is wrong, that euthanasia is actually a form of murder and withholding and withdrawing treatment are not absolutely immoral but often problematic. Given the strong preceding chapters, one wishes for an expanded application of their relevance to contemporary euthanasia debates which seems short-changed in this final chapter.
