Advanced capitalist states have long drawn on the most marginalised members of society to fulfil seasonal farm labour demands, thus keeping food prices and the minimum wage low. Temporary foreign worker programmes in the early twenty-first century, however, represent an effort to legitimise this long-standing practice as a ‘win-win-win’ scenario for growers, sending and receiving country governments, and migrant workers. Proponents argue that programmes of this kind offer a complementary solution to farmers’ labour needs in the global North and poverty for migrants from the majority world. In Tomorrow We're All Going to the Harvest, Leigh Binford critically evaluates the putative merits of Canada's Seasonal Agricultural Worker Programme (SAWP), which has been heralded internationally as exemplifying best practices. When even a supposedly model arrangement is riddled with exploitation and abuse, he queries, what does this augur for other temporary foreign worker programmes?
Encompassing a wealth of fieldwork from the early 2000s, Binford draws on in-depth interviews and observation from two primary SAWP sending and receiving regions: Tlaxcala, Mexico, and south-west Ontario, Canada, respectively. He uses the theoretical concepts of social fields and fields of power, as developed by William Roseberry, to disentangle the networks of relationships between SAWP institutions and individuals. Particularly illuminating are the excerpted interviews with Mexican migrants and their families, consular officials and Canadian horticultural employers. These narratives underscore the lived, human dimension of migrants’ experiences as well as the structural constraints shaping power inequities in the SAWP. This highly readable text, which stands as a singularly comprehensive overview of the SAWP, speaks primarily to scholarly audiences. Those engaged in related public policy and activism would also find it insightful. It would be a welcome addition to university courses on the political economy of agriculture, labour, immigration and racialisation.
After situating the programme historically within post-war agrarian developments in Canada and Mexico, the author turns to a key contradiction. On the one hand, most migrants express overall satisfaction with the SAWP and seasonally return to work in Canada. Simultaneously, many migrants report overwork, substandard working and housing conditions, and employer mistreatment. Mounting criticisms of the programme often converge on how SAWP migrants’ legal status in Canada hinges on remaining employed by the initial grower who hired them. Given the threat of arbitrary dismissal (and repatriation) or receiving a negative evaluation from their employer that could preclude future SAWP employment, many farm workers accept long hours and difficult working conditions without complaint. Binford explains the contradiction between the ‘systemic exploitation’ (p. 59) of this unfree labour regime and workers’ ostensible satisfaction on the basis of what he calls a ‘dual frame of reference’ – that is, workers often favourably compare the SAWP with ‘the cold brutality of making a living in Mexico’ (p. 63). His key theoretical argument here is that neoliberal restructuring and consequent loss of employment in rural Mexico (the point of reproduction) has enabled the wringing of surplus value from migrants in Canada (the point of production). Both locations give rise to the social field of power in which migrants’ conditioning unfolds. Binford asserts that in order to construe the SAWP as a fair, reciprocal exchange between workers and employers, one must disregard the transnational differences between where both groups stand within this social field of power.
Readers concerned with international development will take interest in Binford's contribution to contemporary debates on guest worker programmes as a form of poverty alleviation. Those who endorse these programmes often claim that migrants’ sacrifices and remittances contribute to long-term economic development for their families and home communities. In chapter 5, however, Binford demonstrates that, despite material improvements to some migrants’ lives, the SAWP only allows most Mexican participants to avoid poverty on a temporary, year-to-year basis while they participate in the programme. Drawing on Amartya Sen's concept of development as an overall reduction in human ‘unfreedoms’, Binford makes the compelling case that the SAWP deprives participants of many non-economic freedoms, such as their political capabilities. Accordingly, the SAWP cannot be defended on the grounds that it provides holistic development or long-term poverty alleviation for Mexican communities.
While Mexico is the main migrant-sending country of concern in this book, a chapter co-authored by sociologist Kerry Preibisch considers how, since the 1970s, labour market segmentation between Caribbean and Mexican SAWP workers has evolved to the disadvantage of the latter. They attribute this to a ‘soft’, albeit insidious form of racism in which employers and rural communities circulate racial discourses that stereotype a given racial/national group as being inherently better suited to working with particular crops. The climate of ethnic/national competition thwarts potential solidarity between Mexican and Caribbean workers. It also discourages migrant-sending countries from demanding better conditions for their workers because a given sending country can easily be replaced by another, more acquiescent one.
On the topic of organising migrant farm workers, in many respects Canadian labour groups face an even greater challenge than their US counterparts, as Binford points out in his comparison between the Canadian United Food and Commercial Workers (UFCW) union and the US Farm Labor Organizing Committee. He implies that so long as the SAWP persists, farm worker-driven structural change or widespread unionisation remain doubtful prospects. In light of dominant trends among neoliberal states toward larger, less regulated temporary foreign worker programmes, he questions why the UFCW bothers trying to organise migrants rather than opposing the programmes altogether. Elsewhere in the text, Binford is usually careful to highlight migrants’ perspectives; here, however, I think he misses some important nuance by sidestepping the complicating point that many migrant farm workers do not want the SAWP to be terminated. Moreover, when historically white-dominated unions oppose temporary foreign worker programmes outright, they are often accused (sometimes correctly) of xenophobia or racism. A discussion of this classic union challenge would have further strengthened this section.
My quibbles with the book are minor and mainly aesthetic. The title is somewhat clunky, and it is unclear how the quote from which it derives relates to the key themes of the text. There are also some errors in Canadian geography; the province of New Brunswick is denoted as ‘New Britain’, and repeated references to the Ontario town of St. Catharines use the incorrect spelling of ‘St. Catherines’. These do not, of course, detract from the overall strengths of the book. In its rigour, depth and scope of analysis, Tomorrow We're All Going to the Harvest stands as an incisive contribution to pressing questions about the implications of temporary foreign worker programmes for contemporary agriculture, neoliberal capitalism and transnational human rights.
