Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T09:23:26.298Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Verified combination of numerical weather- and avalanche-prediction models at Kootenay Pass, British Columbia, Canada

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 September 2017

Claudia Roeger
Affiliation:
Pfarrweg 3, D-83043 Bad Aibling, Germany E-mail. croeger@canoemail.com
David M. McClung
Affiliation:
Department of Geography, University of British Columbia, 1984 West Mall, Vancouver, British Columbia V6T 1Z2, Canada
Roland Stull
Affiliation:
Atmospheric Science Programme, Department of Earth and Ocean Sciences, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia V6T 1Z4, Canada
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The combination of numerical weather prediction (NWP) and snow avalanche forecasting has been performed using the output of two weather models run at the University of British Columbia, Canada, and a local numerical avalanche-forecasting model developed for Kootenay Pass (McClung and Tweedy, 1994). The main motivations for this work are. (1) to extend the lead time of avalanche forecasts by using NWP forecasts of meteorological variables as input to statistical avalanche-threat models (instead of the traditional method of using current/past observed meteorological variables as input); and (2) to create another tool to help avalanche forecasters in their daily decision-making by making true forecasts instead of “nowcasts”. Therefore, verified weather-forecast model output was used as input for the local avalanche-forecasting model at Kootenay Pass. The resulting 24 hour avalanche forecast was compared to observed avalanche occurrences and to the 12 hour avalanche forecast with current weather observations. As a result, the avalanche-model output for the test runs with numerically predicted weather data is comparable in accuracy to the runs with observed weather data. The results also suggest that avalanches may be predicted statistically for 24 hours into the future when high-resolution NWP is used as input, weather- and avalanche-forecast errors taken into account during operational use.

Information

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s) [year] 2004
Figure 0

Table 1.Variables used for AFM. D: directly gained from NWP; E: empirically estimated

Figure 1

Table 2.Contingency table definition, where A–D are the counts of events in each category, out of N total events

Figure 2

Fig. 1.Results from contingency table analysis for avalanche moisture type, prediction vs observation, Kootenay Pass, January–April 2000. A value of 1.0 is best in all categories.

Figure 3

Table 3.Results from contingency table analysis for avalanche moisture type (Fig. 1) (obs: observed data; fcst: forecast)

Figure 4

Fig. 2.Results from contingency table analysis for overall avalanche occurrence (wet and dry avalanching), Kootenay Pass, January–April 2000. Perfect forecasts achieve zero for FAR and 1.0 in all other categories.

Figure 5

Table 4.Results from contingency table analysis for avalanche prediction (wet and dry avalanching) (Fig. 2) (obs: observed data; fcst: forecast)

Figure 6

Fig. 3.Results from contingency table analysis for dry avalanches, Kootenay Pass, January–April 2000. Perfect forecasts achieve zero for FAR and 1.0 in all other categories.

Figure 7

Table 5.Results from contingency table analysis for dry avalanche prediction (Fig. 3) (obs: observed data; fcst: forecast)

Figure 8

Fig. 4.Results from contingency table analysis for wet avalanches, Kootenay Pass, January–April 2000. Perfect forecasts achieve zero for FAR and 1.0 in all other categories.

Figure 9

Table 6.Results from contingency table analysis for wet avalanche prediction (Fig. 4) (obs: observed data; fcst: forecast)

Figure 10

Fig. 5.Results from cluster analysis: neighbors with avalanche occurrence in %. Difference to results with weather observation input. Median, lower and upper quartile. A value of zero is best.

Figure 11

Table 7.Values according to Figure 5: upper and lower quartile and IQR of difference to AFM–weather observation combination and median values of avalanche occurrence (%) for each AFM–weather-forecast combination, 10 or 30 nearest neighbors (nn)

Figure 12

Fig. 6.Average AAI per day: difference to results with weather observation input. Median, lower and upper quartile. A value of zero is best.

Figure 13

Fig. 7.Relative distance at neighbors 1, 10 and 30: difference to results with weather observation input. Median, lower and upper quartile. A value of zero is best.

Figure 14

Table 8.Values according to Figure 6: median, upper and lower quartile and IQR of difference to AFM–weather observation combination of AAI for each AFM–weather-forecast combination, 10 or 30 nearest neighbors (nn)

Figure 15

Table 9.Values according to Figure 7: median, upper and lower quartile and IQR of difference to AFM–weather observation combination of relative distance at neighbors 1, 10, and 30 for each AFM–weather-forecast combination