This book offers an innovative perspective on bilateral investment treaties (BIT) by categorizing BIT provisions into six core principles—reasonableness, security, non-discrimination, access, transparency, and due process—unlike the provision-by-provision discussion in other works on investment treaties. The purpose of this new approach is to argue that “promoting the rule of law with respect to foreign investment is the primary function of the BITs, while promoting a liberal investment policy is a secondary function”. The author identifies the justification for having BITs as the need for norms and not state interests or pragmatism. Therefore, although in the early years of BIT programmes the hope of obtaining additional investment might have resulted in the proliferation of the treaties, treaty commitments may be considered codifications of policies that in the signatories’ opinion should be adopted (pp. 8−9). Contrary to this assertion, the actual effect of investment treaties on investment inflows is still subject to much debate. The author even warns that the justification for the continued existence of the treaties would be problematic if no positive association between them and increased external capital in host states is found.Footnote 1
To advocate the novel perception of BITs as an instrument of liberal legalism, Vandevelde first reviews important events and their consequences to explain the emergence and proliferation of BITs. Based on his experience as a negotiator of the US BIT programme in the 1980s, Vandevelde has written extensively on this topic, and the present volume is the most recent accumulation of his expertise and experience with BITs. In addition to a chapter devoted to the history of bilateral investment treaties, chapters on BIT principles touch upon the evolution and formulation of each treaty provision and its policy rationales, which, therefore, produces one of the most comprehensive studies of the BIT emergence and negotiating history.
He also examines economic liberalism and development economics, which affect national policies towards foreign investment. The theories are tested under empirical evidence on the macroeconomic effects of foreign investment on growth, inequality, and environmental and labour concerns. He concludes that foreign investment is more likely to contribute to economic growth where the host country has a commitment to the rule of law (p. 114). While the BIT role in promoting a liberal investment regime is limited due to its few provisions on market facilitation and investment neutrality, the focus is instead on investment security and the promotion of the rule of law. Vandevelde, therefore, presents the important argument that while the positive impact of the BITs on investment flows is indecisive, BITs may serve to commit host countries to principles that have intrinsic worth and strengthen their liberal democracy (p. 119).
The later chapters of the book are devoted to examining all the common provisions of BITs from definitions and standards of treatments to dispute-settlement provisions. Vandevelde explores the treaties according to his six principles to demonstrate “the essential coherence of the BITs, characterizing them as a reflection of core principles … rather than as merely a collection of provisions that in some way protect, promote, liberalize, or regulate investment” (p. 12). One provision might contain the elements of several principles, and the author treats this overlapping on the basis of the relevance of that provision to the principles. For example, the arbitral interpretations of the fair and equitable treatment standard “require adherence to five of the six core BIT principles” (p. 195). The principle-based approach highlights the important elements of a desired legal framework for foreign investment in which reasonableness, security, non-discrimination, transparency, access, and due process are guaranteed.
In exploring the meaning of treaty terms, despite the discussions on their origins and structures, the book focuses mainly on the meanings that arbitral awards determine for the treaty standards, reflecting the tendency to give a decisive influence to jurisprudence in the common-law background of the author. The structure, policy, and origins are also provided for each provision. However, an alternative approach would suggest more emphasis and analysis on their context and negotiating history, which are presented in depth in the book to further clarify the intention of the parties. Notwithstanding this, the book's intensive study of BIT history and the economic theories underlying those treaties serve as a foundation for continued study of the recent developments of the BIT content, as well as the directions that arbitrators should adopt in applying treaty terms to specific relationships. Vandevelde's new and detailed argument on the functions of BITs may serve as a critical way to justify the existence and proliferation of these treaties.
