No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 August 2004
Tayob's study of the sermon is unique. This is so because, as he suggests, a unique approach grounded in the discursive traditions of Muslims themselves is called for when studying a religious symbol. That this symbol's religious and metaphysical dimension has not been sufficiently explored is the justification for this contribution on the sermon in Muslim societies. More than a ritual and disciplinary practice, Tayob's Friday sermon holds out many possibilities, and his privileged position as a Muslim, he reminds us, means that he is able to unpack the layers of the sermon from the inside out. The results of such an approach, we are promised, are far-reaching. It affords an opportunity to look at the position of the “mosque and imam traditions” within Islam, which he maintains is the missing link to explain the matter sufficiently well. It also serves the purpose of rethinking Qur
anic revelation. This is so because the Friday sermon as the most significant occasion on which the Qur
an is “re-cited” will now be recognized for performing the cosmological function of the original text of Islam. Eventually in this approach there is even salvation for the Qur
an from being a “bounded” book.
Tayob's study of the sermon is unique. This is so because, as he suggests, a unique approach grounded in the discursive traditions of Muslims themselves is called for when studying a religious symbol. That this symbol's religious and metaphysical dimension has not been sufficiently explored is the justification for this contribution on the sermon in Muslim societies. More than a ritual and disciplinary practice, Tayob's Friday sermon holds out many possibilities, and his privileged position as a Muslim, he reminds us, means that he is able to unpack the layers of the sermon from the inside out. The results of such an approach, we are promised, are far-reaching. It affords an opportunity to look at the position of the “mosque and imam traditions” within Islam, which he maintains is the missing link to explain the matter sufficiently well. It also serves the purpose of rethinking Qur

anic revelation. This is so because the Friday sermon as the most significant occasion on which the Qur

an is “re-cited” will now be recognized for performing the cosmological function of the original text of Islam. Eventually in this approach there is even salvation for the Qur

an from being a “bounded” book.
Mosque and imam traditions, as the author suggests, have to be studied in relation to the historical context and the discursive traditions employed. With the sermon as a prism for both the history that such a study unearths and the discursive tradition, a range of relationships that reveal some basic contradictions of authority and status within the discourse will be revealed. To understand the discourse we are called to look beyond the speech and written word and at the gestures of those involved. The leader is one who conforms to the pattern or the established discourse, and the history recovered is a genuine “people's history,” which recognizes the place of Muslim communities in shaping their own history.
For the purpose of this study, two mosques are chosen. After an introductory chapter, the reader encounters two chapters—one devoted to the discourse governing mosques in the Cape, and the other to the Claremont Main Road Mosque. Similarly, the next two chapters determine the “Transvaal mosque tradition,” with the Brits Mosque the specific focus. This is followed by two chapters that focus on the sermon in general and analyze the representative samples chosen for this study. A concluding chapter reinforces the central argument, and an argument for the efficacy of this method for understanding Muslim communities and all of Muslim understanding is made here. The clear and logical arrangement makes for easy reading and understanding of these arguments. The reader encounters a range of the familiar and predicable categories and terminologies of symbol, metaphor, sacred space, religious discourse, ritual, gender, tradition, orthodoxy, theology, and ideology, to name a few. Importantly, the scholarship is a representation of some of the academic scholarship in the period of South Africa's transition to independence and the (self) representations consistently negotiated in Tayob's work can be considered an example or measure of social identity formations experienced in South Africa. The style is lucid and wonderfully reflects the passion that the author has for what he terms the progressive Islam so close to his heart. Ideology in the sermon at Claremont is accepted or rejected by the congregation while the theology of Brits is dissimulated. In this regard, one may argue that what is absent in this discourse analysis is a discussion on nifāq undertaken with the same dexterity and thoroughness that the author examines bid

a (religious innovation) and

ilm.
Similarly, the author does not deliver sufficiently on his promise that he will relate his findings to the place of South African Muslim institutions in the new dispensation. Perhaps this is excusable since this work was published within the first five years of independence, and the most recent sermon analyzed dates to 1994. As South Africans, we celebrate ten years of liberation this year, and some Muslims may argue that today it is often the ideology that is dissimulated and the theology that is either accepted or rejected. In the face of a continuous and contingent demand on the Muslim community, neither the theoretical consistency of the mosque sermons that are theologically fused nor the concern with the relation of faith to dimensions such as class, gender, sexuality, and ethnicity in the ideological mosque sermons has prevented South African Muslims from appreciating their responsibility. The prism of the sermons continue to refract the full range of the spectrum, where for some kufr remains the greatest ẓulm and for others ecumenical pluralism is a preferred way of being for a Muslim in a civil society. They do so, however, in a second moment of an increasing awareness of the practice and action that has to follow the sermon in face of the challenges faced locally and on the African continent generally.
The book is a welcome addition to the study of Islam in South Africa. It is invaluable for scholars of, and readers with a passing interest in, the impact of the apartheid system on the different Muslim communities in South Africa.