Many emerging scholars from the barrios, hoods, fields, reservations, and other sites of both living in and through oppression struggle for access to higher education. Yet, the academy also signifies compulsory assimilation into Western epistemologies and work modes that often limit the impact of our work (e.g., through the narrow conceptions of race, politics, and productivity). Ultimately, assimilation into Western academic practices renders scholars of color complicit in our own oppression and that of Black and Indigenous peoples all over the world (Moreira and Diversi Reference Moreira and Diversi2010). These experiences take a toll on our bodies, minds, and spirits in addition to introducing (or deepening) precarity in our lives. Moreover, the academy often demands those who deviate from gender, sexuality, ability, and class norms to resituate themselves with respect to peers and students to be more digestible to white Americans and assimilable into the dominator culture. In these ways, ideological diversity is discouraged unless it bolsters “diversity and inclusion” initiatives at the institutional level or tokenizes scholars at the margins.
Thus, conservative disciplines, including political science, often reproduce notions of respectability and scarcity. “Respectability” refers to the ways that groups perceived as outsiders are expected to comport themselves to the norms, social mores, and behavioral expectations of an ingroup (Higginbotham Reference Higginbotham1993). Whereas respectability often is seen in Black and white, as a vestige of anti-Black racism and white supremacy, it also shows up in how those with disabilities; a different place of origin; disparate cultural practices; class variations; and other non-heteronormative, white, middle-class, patriarchal notions of being are expected to bend and contort themselves into models of existence that reduce their perceived differences (Cohen Reference Cohen2004; Lorde Reference Lorde1984). As Sediqe and Nelson (Reference Sediqe and Nelson2022) write in this symposium, women of color are acutely aware of these dynamics, knowing that “they are at best an afterthought and, at worst, repulsively not welcome, in a variety of ways.”
Thus, as a primary site for the reproduction of imperialist hegemony, the academy also is critical terrain for intentional anticolonial resistance and decolonization (Mantz Reference Mantz2019; Reiter Reference Reiter2020; Smith Reference Smith2012; Vitalis Reference Vitalis2015; Wilmer Reference Wilmer2016). We specifically address these issues with regard to the intersections of neoliberal work cultures and coloniality. We ask: What fruitful directions for the discipline are revealed when we apply a decolonial framework?
Thus, as a primary site for the reproduction of imperialist hegemony, the academy also is critical terrain for intentional anticolonial resistance and decolonization.
This article approaches decolonization as a multilevel process that encompasses radical action across political, social, psychological, and spiritual realms (Smith Reference Smith2012). It is both a personal and a collective process aimed at uprooting and abolishing imperialist ideologies and structures, specifically colonial apparatuses that continue the genocide and land theft from Indigenous peoples around the world today (Smith Reference Smith2012; Tuck and Yang Reference Tuck and Yang2012). We argue that to decolonize productivity means to identify the ways that we embody neoliberal and colonial mindsets and to hold ourselves accountable for the damage we have caused ourselves and others—including whole communities—through our behavior, research, and pedagogies. To us, decolonization requires reestablishing our connection to our minds, bodies, and spirits based within compassion and radical self-love.
Drawing from interdisciplinary scholarship and our experiences as queer junior womxn of color in political science, we examine our relationships to the academy and propose a set of concrete interventions based in decolonial and intersectional research. The next section focuses on myths regarding “work–life balance,” the effects of these logics on the physical body, and the ways that the academy incentivizes the dissolution of community ties between mutually oppressed groups of scholars—namely, Latinx and Black scholars of race, ethnicity, and politics. We then identify the ways that researchers can build new pathways forward that align with decolonizing logics and interrogate the status quo. We conclude with a call for decolonization.
PRODUCTIVITY NARRATIVES AND NEOLIBERALISM IN ACADEMIA
Neoliberalism is a social system that—among its multiple tenets—embraces free markets and privatization for managing the world’s natural resources, public goods, and services (Mirowski Reference Mirowski, Mirowski and Plehwe2019). Neoliberal agents target elite civil-society actors and view academia and other sites of knowledge production as a means to propagate their agendas (Mirowski Reference Mirowski, Mirowski and Plehwe2019). Neoliberalism in academia is most visible in the commodification of knowledge production (e.g., scholar–entrepreneur models), banking models of education (Freire Reference Freire1968; hooks Reference hooks1994), and exhaustive and exploitative work cultures within institutions. Neoliberalism in the academy has accelerated the banking model of education in which students are fed knowledge that reifies their hierarchical and predetermined positions in society. Under this model, knowledge becomes an elite commodity that sustains the status quo (Freire Reference Freire1968; hooks Reference hooks1994), creating, in turn, entrepreneur–scholars who must package and market their own always-innovative brand of research, thereby turning social scientists into capitalists and students into consumers. Neoliberal academe also crafts a culture of scarcity that fosters gatekeeping and reproduces intergroup competition and conflict. For example, anti-Black discrimination and abuse by Chicanx/Latinx scholars uphold the subjugated positions of Black students, colleagues, and campus workers (Abrica, García-Louis, and James-Gallaway Reference Abrica, García-Louis and James-Gallaway2020; Haywood Reference Haywood2017). This article does not deeply interrogate this issue; however, we believe it is critical to understand how neoliberalism and white supremacy intersect to extinguish solidarity among us. We urge our colleagues and comrades to reflect on and act against these divide-and-conquer techniques.
It is important to note that women of color experience neoliberal work cultures differently depending on their own positionality (e.g., marital status, family commitments, and disability status as well as race, gender expression, place of origin, age, and class) within department and campus dynamics, region, and grander society. These heuristics reveal disparities in the ways that women of color navigate academia (Jackson Reference Jackson2019). Together, these neoliberal practices produce toxic work cultures that disproportionately affect women of color in academia (Zambrana Reference Zambrana2018). As junior women of color in the discipline, there often are aspects of our personal identities that are not only perpetual but also critical to how we show up in the work itself. Yet, taking on anti-racist and anticolonial practices within neoliberal work cultures has different consequences for scholars at the margins. As Harbin and Greene discuss (Reference Harbin and Greene2022), the pandemic switch to virtual classrooms makes radical scholars of color even more vulnerable to online harassment.
In summary, academia is a microcosm of grander society. It reproduces the hierarchies of power-sustaining oppression. Working in tandem with multiple preexisting myths (e.g., the bootstrap mentality and grind–hustle culture), the academy is buttressed by the historical and ongoing system-induced precarity of marginalized peoples.
The Myths of Work–Life Balance and “Produce or Perish”
The mass disruption caused by the global COVID-19 pandemic has cast a new and bright light on the myth of work–life balance. Single mothers in the academy, for example, suffer the most across all disciplines regarding work–life balance (Kelly and Grant Reference Kelly and Grant2012). The academy frequently disincentivizes family building or care or the pursuit of nonacademic interests (Ackelsberg et al. Reference Ackelsberg, Binion, Duerst-Lahti, Junn, Van Assendelft and Yoon2004). These dynamics expose the ways that neoliberalism reifies hetero- and homo-normativity and ableism because the academic myth of work–life balance is constructed to reflect hetero-patriarchal ideals of family, work, and leisure (Utoft Reference Utoft2020). In addition, achieving a work–life balance is almost impossible for disabled academics who must contend with inaccessible campuses and resources and an ingrained ableist culture outside of work (Grigely Reference Grigely2017).
Another entrenched myth in academia is “produce or perish”—that is, the belief that publication records are the ultimate reflection of success and intellectual capacity. This myth is entangled with academic elitism that privileges top-ranking journals, themselves complicit in discriminatory practices (Atchison Reference Atchison2017). For example, despite gender biases in journal acceptance rates (Teele and Thelen Reference Teele and Thelen2017) and in citations (Atchison Reference Atchison2017), publications in top-tier political science journals are key for hiring and promotion. Moreover, publishing systems favor mainstream theories and methods, and they reflect the structural organization of power with white male academics historically dominating editor positions. However, even after controlling for productivity, women are still less likely to receive tenure and promotion (Hesli, Lee, and Mitchell Reference Hesli, Lee and Mitchell2012). For women of color, these conditions often mean contending in uneven playing fields rather than focusing on those aspects of our work life that truly fulfill us as nuanced and complex human beings (Jackson Reference Jackson2019). We do not believe that the answer to this problem is simply to insert women of color into asymmetrical power dynamics and unjust reward systems. Rather, we suggest that the only way to decolonize is to retool, recalibrate, and redefine these systems altogether.
Respectability and Body Politics
Although our assessments are based formally on merit and intellectual production, physical characteristics often shape our opportunities. The academy often demands that people who fall outside of gender, sexuality, ability, and class norms resituate themselves with respect to peers and students. For example, it is not uncommon for women of color to wait until after tenure to change their hair, get a tattoo, or otherwise adjust their outward appearance. This is especially true for scholars whose physical characteristics mark them as deviant or disposable (i.e., trans and gender nonconforming, femmes, fat people, and those with visible disabilities). Nelson and Sediqe (2022, this issue) recount the consequences for showing up as unapologetic Black and Muslim women, including the dismissal of their ideas and the questioning of their pedagogies. Thus, authenticity or self-expression in the form of body adornment, language choices, and other ways of being typically are sidelined until after tenure, when job security and reputation are less fraught. This phenomenon is concentrated especially among women of color academics who navigate academia as low-wage, junior, and contract-based faculty members.
Together, these mutually reinforcing ideas of work–life balance and respectability sustain working environments that reward those who opt-in to neoliberal capitalist structures. For many scholars of color, conformity requires alienation from community and family and subjugation of cultural and ancestral ways of being for Western practices (Wilson Reference Wilson2008). The ensuing existential turmoil coupled with ongoing precarity and global social destruction results in scholars suffering illness, unhappiness, and premature death.
CONTESTING AND REFRAMING: RADICAL SELF-LOVE AS DECOLONIAL PRAXIS
Women of color scholars are violently assimilated into practices that segment and harm our minds, bodies, spirits, and all of our relationships. Moreover, the contemporary political moment has exacerbated these already strenuous conditions facing scholars at the margins. Given academia’s roots in Western imperialism and settler colonialism (Smith Reference Smith2012; Wilson Reference Wilson2008), our approaches to contest and reframe these politics are rooted in decolonial action. We echo Wilmer (Reference Wilmer2016, 1051) who, citing Smith (Reference Smith2012), proposed that to decolonize political science requires we first decolonize political scientists. Thus, we speak directly to the individual actions we can take immediately—although we recognize that, ultimately, it is collective action that will create profound change.
We approach decolonization as a holistic ongoing process that encompasses structural, psychosocial, biological, and metaphysical domains. We thus propose a decolonial praxis rooted in radical self-love (Taylor Reference Taylor2018), which seeks to extirpate dominator ideologies from our psyches and daily practices to reclaim our self-esteem and autonomy. Practicing radical self-love as decolonial praxis in the academy entails deprogramming neoliberal productivity narratives, healing from abuse, holding ourselves accountable for hurt we have caused, and developing work cultures centered on our needs (both individual and collective) rather than profits. We do this in community with one another and through accountability to vulnerable people. We also do this at the departmental and disciplinary levels by affirming collective accountability to our students and communities. As a community, practicing radical self-love means rebuking mainstream advice to develop “thick skin” as a means to avoid the damages of interpersonal and systemic abuse in the academy. It follows then that, as political scientists, we must rebuke incentive structures that reward self-denial and a culture of exhaustion. Rather, a radical self-love approach strengthens our spirit, making us resistant to this violence. This strength comes from tending to our own needs and ensuring that our own cup is full before pouring ourselves into our research, teaching, and mentoring duties.
Practicing radical self-love as decolonial praxis in the academy entails deprogramming neoliberal productivity narratives, healing from abuse, holding ourselves accountable for hurt we have caused, and developing work cultures centered on our needs (both individual and collective) rather than profits.
Practice Slow (and Intentional) Scholarship
How do we enact radical self-love as a decolonial move in academia? The movement for slow scholarship offers strategies that uphold principles of radical self-love. Framed within feminist ethics of care, slow scholarship promotes collective anti-neoliberal action through reclamation of our time (Mountz et al. Reference Mountz, Bonds, Mansfield, Loyd, Hyndman and Walton-Roberts2015). Slow scholarship rejects unnecessarily fast-paced research, multitasking, and sexualized and gendered productivity narratives that impinge on our ability to think freely. Ethics of care center the scholar, creating boundaries that uphold a healthy working environment, protect against exhaustion, and harness power for change.
The volume of emails during the pandemic has exploded, further colonizing our time. We also have a dramatic increase in screen time that is producing a particular type of exhaustion: “Zoom fatigue.”Footnote 1 Thus, boundaries around email are imperative to slow scholarship and self-care, which includes logging out evenings and weekends and removing email applications from our phones. Mountz et al. (2015) also urged us to consider how we approach thinking and writing. Prioritizing writing and thinking is imperative for all scholars, especially for those engaging in community-based work. Freeing our time allows us to reflect on our complicity in the exploitation of our communities; to halt the extraction and erasure of our knowledge; and to unclog the muddied connections among our minds, hearts, spirits, and the lands we occupy. This process requires more than armchair intellectualism; it requires that scholars be part of the context that they are studying and that we (re)build relationships as a form of knowledge itself (Wilson Reference Wilson2008). Wilson (Reference Wilson2008) discussed how much of our work is intuitive and involves “extra-intellectual” sources that surpass the five senses. Thus, it is not enough to make time only to write and think but also to reevaluate our entire Western academic training to tap into our intuition and center relational accountability as part of our research process. This necessarily requires scholars to slow down and take the time to learn, think, and ponder our positionality within the complex web of imperialist relations. In essence, we can begin to think of research as ceremony (Wilson Reference Wilson2008).
Freeing our time allows us to reflect on our complicity in the exploitation of our communities; to halt the extraction and erasure of our knowledge; and to unclog the muddied connections among our minds, hearts, spirits, and the lands we occupy.
Practicing slow and intentional scholarship means recalibrating the ways we evaluate ourselves for tenure, jobs, and funding; slowing down publishing timelines to provide ample time for critical thinking and writing; and leveraging our power to counter neoliberal and colonial repression (Mountz et al. 2015). Many scholars of color, particularly women of color, are inundated in service work, as elaborated by contributors to this symposium. Yet, we should be strategic with this aspect of our position by identifying prime gatekeeping appointments such as committees for hiring, tenure and promotion, admissions, and funding.
CONCLUSION: BE ACCOUNTABLE, BE BOLD, TAKE RISKS
A critical missing piece in academic culture is accountability. This is especially true regarding racialized, ableist, gendered, and sexual abuse among colleagues and in faculty–student relationships. We urge our peers to be bold and to take risks by asking difficult questions, producing work outside of the mainstream, and ceasing the reinforcement of oppression. We urge political scientists to do this work as a form of praxis, in community with others, and as a baseline of research and pedagogy. We urge tenured faculty, especially those in administrative ranks, to leverage their institutional power to protect early-career scholars and graduate students who opt for slow scholarship and to cash in political capital to orient university cultures toward an ethics of care. Moreover, although we understand that many women of color rely on this system to support themselves, their family, and their community, we also hold true the reality that this system prevents them from moving in their fullness and wholeness. When they do, they risk being pushed out, ostracized, and isolated. They also risk losing their income and sense of financial security.
A secondary consideration of advocating for a decolonial approach to political science is the uneven power dynamics that frequently limit faculty at multiple margins of identity from fully expressing their concerns, beliefs, and intellectual expertise. These dynamics may result in even tenured faculty of color feeling hampered or boxed in by the status quo of the discipline. In these instances, we support the same tactics and strategies taken up by community organizers in pooling power and relying on broader networks of actors to accomplish liberatory goals. Specifically, for junior and tenured faculty of color who seek to build a decolonial framework within the discipline, they first need to decolonize the message that scholarship should be produced in isolation.
These conditions are worsening under the global COVID-19 pandemic. Communities of color are hit hardest by the political ambivalence, misinformation, and negligence of a wealthy ruling class (McNeil Reference McNeil2020). Despite these realities, academia continues to place undue burdens and expectations on us (Harbin and Greene Reference Harbin and Greene2022; Sedique and Nelson Reference Sediqe and Nelson2022). Decolonizing ourselves is a requirement for ethical, relevant, and critical research and for healthy, happy, and productive scholars. It entails a reorganization of power at all levels of academe. As an extension of this work, we invite other scholars to expand on the ways that radical self-love as decolonial praxis can transform our lives as scholars, even within crumbling institutions.
