With Becoming Ottomans, Julia Phillips Cohen breaks new ground in her analysis of the Sephardi communities of Salonica, Istanbul, and Izmir, and of the complex and changing forces that tested their allegiance to imperial citizenship and nationality (Ottomanism). She challenges the long-held master narrative that Ottomanism was an abstract ideology that managed to gain a foothold only among the Ottoman elite. Surprisingly, this trope, which essentially suggests that Ottomanism was a failure, persists in Ottoman historiography to this day. Scholars who challenge the narrative of Ottoman nationalism as an abstraction encounter many difficulties. It is not easy, for example, to uncover the process through which these ideas were transferred outside of the elite society and into the consciousness of nonelite classes or diverse ethnic and religious communities. If one were able to establish a mechanism with which to analyze this transfer, would it be possible to locate the point at which individuals or communities shift from religious and/or ethnic allegiance to an ideology calling for primary loyalty to the imperial dynasty? One would also need to examine the role of local factors in reinforcing or subverting national identity formation.
Julia Phillips Cohen takes on these challenges. Drawing on a wide array of Jewish and Ottoman sources, including newspapers, materials from state archives and private collections, contemporary books and pamphlets, as well as photographs and postcards, she skillfully analyzes how local factors reinforced or subverted national identity formation. Her study examines the methods used by Sephardim to demonstrate their community's allegiance to Ottomanism, to imperial citizenship, and to the Ottoman Empire more broadly. Cohen describes the difficulties they faced in defining the meaning of citizenship and national identity during the final seventy-five years of the empire's existence. As she illustrates, the process involved a series of negotiations among communal leaders who often held different visions of how best to demonstrate the community's patriotism and allegiance to the new imperial civic order.
Cohen begins her study with the 1856 Reform Decree in which the Jews were not recognized as a distinctive community. Even without recognition, however, the Jews declared their adherence to this new imperial civic model of citizenship—a model that envisioned intercommunal cooperation among various religions and ethnicities. Jewish leaders taught community members that through philanthropy, patriotism, activism, and self-sacrifice they would become loyal citizens and the community would emerge from obscurity. In 1876–77, as the empire was engaged in wars with Serbia, Montenegro, and Russia, Jewish leaders began to urge their young men to volunteer for the army in order to prove the willingness of Ottoman Jews to sacrifice for their country.
Cohen analyzes the Jewish response to the shift in Ottomanism during the Hamidian period from the civic, intercommunal model to one emphasizing political Islam. The belief in intercommunal harmony that was at the center of civic Ottomanism was crushed by the massacre of Armenians in Istanbul in 1896 and by the Greek–Ottoman war of 1897. Jewish leaders had to decide whether to risk aligning themselves with the civic ideal and intercommunal neighborliness by maintaining good relations with communities now viewed as disloyal, or to attach themselves to the Ottoman state and its Islamic vision. Unanimous agreement did not exist, but the trend was to reaffirm the community's adherence to the empire and to Jewish-Muslim brotherhood. Community leaders criticized European interventionism and resisted westernizing pressures, a crucial position that reaffirmed their loyalty to the state and their commitment to Hamidian Ottomanism.
According to Cohen, the Jews’ emphasis on their “Eastern” heritage was most clearly apparent in two events. In 1892, the community decided to celebrate the 400th anniversary of the Jewish expulsions from Spain. This “invented” holiday occurred at a moment when the Ottoman Empire was under pressure to accept large numbers of Jewish refugees from Russia, Romania, and Corfu. The Jewish community hoped that their celebration would engender positive feelings at the Porte toward these refugees. The second event was the 1892 Chicago World's Exposition where Elia Souhami Sadullah & Co, a joint Jewish–Muslim company, was commissioned to build the Ottoman exhibit. Many Ottoman Jews attended the exposition as proud members of the Ottoman Empire. In sum, the Jewish community successfully waded the uncertain waters of Hamidian Ottomanism, so much so that by the end of the 19th century the Ottoman government had recognized the Jews as a model community.
The Second Constitutional Era presented Jewish leaders with some of their greatest challenges when Zionism and socialism found footholds within the community. For those who had fought so many decades to prove their community's loyalty to the empire, the popularity of these ideological movements threatened to undo their efforts by introducing new divisions. These divisions were most evident in the Jewish response to the visit of newly elected Mehmet V to Salonica in 1911. Zionists, socialists, and assimilationist Jews each proclaimed their own vision of citizenship through their newspapers, in social gatherings honoring Ottoman dignitaries, and in the most visible symbols of Mehmet V's visit—the archways under which the Sultan would ride and through which each group most visibly identified themselves.
Cohen demonstrates successfully that Jewish–Ottoman patriotism was an evolving project that responded to circumstances and political exigencies. But she emphasizes that there was one element that did not change—the narrative, or “myth,” of the special Ottoman–Jewish relationship forged by the Spanish expulsions and the Ottoman state's generous reception of Jews, which later expanded to produce a historical narrative of Jewish attachment to the Ottoman sultans spanning five centuries. This narrative served both the Sephardim and the empire: for the former, it fulfilled their need to show complete allegiance to the empire; for the latter, it provided a rebuttal to European claims that the empire was intolerant.
If Becoming Ottomans was only an examination of the Sephardi response to Ottoman citizenship and the imperial national project, it would be a tremendous contribution to the field. But the book touches on many other subjects under debate among Ottoman historians. Cohen engages with scholarship on communities in borderland areas, since the Sephardi community in Salonica found itself temporarily on the border with Bulgaria after the Treaty of San Stefano in 1878 redrew the map. Her book also connects with scholars theorizing the meaning of modernity. She argues that Jewish–Ottoman modernity was very middle class, which meant proper and moderate behavior, a commitment to civil society, and public expression of duty and patriotism to the empire. In addition, Cohen contributes to scholarship challenging the outdated but persistent Weberian view that Ottoman modernization equals Westernization, as well as the narrative of provincial resistance to Ottoman centralization policies. Finally, Becoming Ottomans challenges scholarship on the roots and growth of Zionism in the empire and on how the introduction of this ideology “complicates the master narratives of late Ottoman politics, and the notions that ideologies and social practices necessarily overlap” (p. 131).
Cohen does not examine the non-Sephardi Jewish communities whose presence in the empire predated the Spanish expulsion and who were conquered by the Ottoman state rather than objects of its tolerant immigration policies. This population is clearly outside the boundaries of the author's research, and its absence does not detract from the strengths of this book. However, this reviewer was left wishing to know more about its commitment to Ottomanism. Cohen's book is firmly situated within a growing body of scholarship that challenges the master narrative that Ottomanism and the imperial citizenship project were failures, or that Ottomanism did not extend beyond elite circles to take root among non-Muslim communities. The book is engaging, accessible, and an important contribution to late Ottoman history.
