No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 21 January 2005
Dear Sir,
Re: Is Turner's syndrome associated with cardiomyopathy and myopathy?
We appreciate that Drs Finsterer and Stöllberger have outlined their experience with patients suffering from myocardial non-compaction associated with various forms of neuromuscular disorders. Dr Finsterer may be right that non-compaction was already present in our patient at the age of 9 years, and that our cardiologists were probably not sensitized to the existence of the entity at that time. All of us are now experiencing that, with better quality imaging provided by a new generation of echocardiographic equipment, more details are disclosed. We believe that the diagnosis should be made primarily by echocardiography. We would not expect that the cardiac surgeon would be able to evaluate the appearance of the left ventricular apex during repair of a malformed mitral valve with fused tendinous cords. There exists an overlap between various forms of abnormal myocardial structure, evidenced also by a non-uniform terminology – non-compaction, left ventricular hypertrabeculation, spongy myocardium. In fact, prominent left ventricular trabeculations can be found in many hypertrophic hearts, and strict echocardiographic diagnostic criterions are therefore warranted for the distinction of non-compaction.1
In a recent study,2 in four-fifths of the patients with non-compaction, an association with neuromuscular disorder was found. Our patient demonstrated no clinical features of a neuromuscular disease up to 17 years of age and had normal values of creatine kinase, this together making the diagnosis of any form of a dystrophinopathy less probable. We would hesitate at this moment to refer all patients with myocardial non-compaction, and absence of clinical features of a muscular disease, for a complete and routine workup to exclude neuromuscular disorders. Almost one-fifth of the patients in the above-mentioned study2 refused the neurological investigation, being reluctant to undertake the additional studies when they appeared only to have a cardiac problem. We should have a low threshold, nonetheless, for investigation of any possible neuromuscular disorder, starting with a specifically oriented history, and we should be prepared to refer the patient for specialist opinion when indicated. We thank Drs Finsterer and Stöllberger for drawing our attention to this interesting issue, focused on the potential neuromuscular involvement in the setting of myocardial disease.