As a member of the British academic community—an international relations professor who is deeply involved in Middle Eastern studies—I find it distressing that some of the most dismal aspects of the American academic environment are coming our way. Nowhere is this trend more pronounced than on the question of Israel. That country is, of course, no stranger to controversy, but the attack on the right of academics to criticize Israel is a relatively recent and a highly disturbing phenomenon.
Israel is often portrayed by its supporters as an island of democracy in a sea of authoritarianism. However, these very same supporters, in their excessive zeal for their cause, sometimes end up violating one of the most fundamental democratic principles: the right to free speech. Although accepting free speech as a universal value, all too often they try to restrict it when it comes to Israel and its treatment of the Palestinians. The result is not to encourage but to stifle debate about the Israeli–Palestinian conflict.
Britain prides itself on its tradition of civilized debate on all subjects, including Israel. The great majority of British Jews share in this tradition. Jonathan Sacks, chief rabbi of the United Hebrew Congregations of the Commonwealth, is a notable example of this fair-minded, liberal, and pluralistic tradition. One of his sixteen books is called The Dignity of Difference: How to Avoid the Clash of Civilizations. On the other side of the Atlantic, on the other hand, public debate about Israel is much more fierce and partisan, leaving relatively little space for the dignity of difference. The passion with which many prominent American Jews defend Israel betrays an atavistic attitude of “my country, right or wrong.”
One example is Alan Dershowitz, Harvard law professor and crusader on behalf of Israel. One of his books is called The Case for Israel. As the title suggests, this is not an objective, academic treatise but a lawyer's brief for his client. This lawyer is no friend of free speech when it comes to criticism of Israel, however well substantiated. Recent events in Oxford suggest that those of us who thought that attempts to stifle free debate about Israel are confined to American campuses need to think again.
The Oxford Union is one of the world's most illustrious debating chambers and a bastion of free speech. It was founded in the 19th century to uphold the principles of free speech and debate in England at a time when they were being severely curtailed. However, the Union recently failed to live up to its lofty ideals. A debate was scheduled for 23 October 2007 on the motion “This house believes that one-state is the only solution to the Israel-Palestine conflict.” Professor Ilan Pappé, Dr. Ghada Karmi, and I agreed to speak for the motion. Norman Finkelstein, an American-Jewish academic; Lord Trimble, a Northern Irish politician; and Peter Tatchell, a gay-rights activist, accepted the invitation to speak against the motion. In the end the debate took place without any of the scheduled speakers after an ugly, acrimonious, American-style row over the panel's makeup.
Various friends of Israel had complained to Luke Tryl, president of the Oxford Union, that the debate was “unbalanced” because it included Finkelstein, a well-known critic of Israel, on the “pro-Israel” side. What they failed to grasp, or deliberately chose to ignore, was that the motion was not for or against Israel but about alternative solutions to the Israeli–Palestinian conflict. Alan Dershowitz was the first and the most aggressive of the protesters. He had been invited to speak, but he replied that he would participate only if he could dictate the motion and approve the other speakers. These preposterous conditions were rejected, and Dershowitz stayed away. However, he did not simply sulk in his tent: that is not his style. He wrote to Tryl that it was outrageous for the Union to give Finkelstein a platform. Dershowitz then turned his polemical blunderbuss directly to Finkelstein, calling him “an anti-Semitic bigot” in an article he posted on the Internet on 19 October under the title “The Oxford Union is Dead.”
The pressure from the pro-Israel lobby unnerved Tryl. Four days before the debate, he curtly rescinded Finkelstein's invitation. My colleagues and I then withdrew in protest against the shabby treatment of an academic colleague and the violation of the principle of free speech at the Oxford Union. Through the eleventh hour we remained ready to rejoin the debate—but only on the condition that Finkelstein be invited back. He was not, so we stayed away. An opportunity to air conflicting views on a major issue in Middle East politics was lost.
The sorry saga of the Oxford debate is symptomatic of another unfortunate trend: the tendency to equate anti-Zionism with anti-Semitism. Here, America is in a league of its own with institutions such as Campus Watch, which “monitors” Middle East studies on campus. As its mission suggests, this organization is incompatible with core values of higher education such as tolerance, free speech, and academic freedom. Mercifully, there is nothing remotely resembling Campus Watch in the United Kingdom.
There is, nonetheless, an ongoing campaign to boycott Israeli universities that do not condemn certain government policies. It is fortunate that only a tiny fraction of British academics favor barring their Israeli counterparts from conventions and research projects. My own view is that an academic boycott is an oxymoron: you do not have a boycott on dialogue and debate. In fact, I strongly oppose a selective boycott precisely because it would infringe upon the freedom of Israeli academics. Freedom of speech is indivisible and inviolable.
