In his introduction to the first of two parts of The Emergence of the Modern Coptic Papacy (the third and last volume of The Popes of Egypt edited by Stephen J. Davis and Gawdat Gabra), “The Coptic Papacy under Ottoman Rule (1517–1798),” Magdi Guirguis makes an important point: a history of the Coptic papacy is very far from being a history of the Copts. While educated urban communities might indeed have been tied in some way to the ecclesiastical hierarchy, matters have long been entirely different where the more rural areas are concerned. The number of churches and monasteries has diminished steadily since the 13th century. The result, Guirguis writes, is that, as late as the 1980s, “in most villages, if you asked a Copt to recite the Lord's Prayer, he would start reciting the first chapter of the Qurʾan, just as Muslims do, believing it to be part of his own faith tradition. The majority of these people were not baptized and had never seen a priest in their life.” The more recent patriarchs made occasional efforts to remedy the situation, but their success was limited.
Although the history of the patriarchs and the Coptic elite since the Arab conquest of Egypt is easier to reconstruct than that of a semiliterate population in the countryside, the obstacles still remain considerable. A majority of historians of the medieval and early modern periods have relied on the traditional, and often hagiographical, histories of the patriarchs, which are remarkably economical with their information. Magdi Guirguis is one of the very few scholars who has actually tackled the archives of the Coptic Orthodox Patriarchate and of the Dar al-Watha'iq al-Qawmiyya in Cairo and has consequently produced a series of excellent studies in which he breaks entirely new ground.
From the Middle Ages to the present day the Church of Alexandria has been characterised by a fluctuation of authority between, on the one hand, the Coptic notables or arakhina, rich and educated individuals often serving the Muslim government as scribes and bureaucrats, and, on the other hand, the patriarchs and the clergy. In the late Mamluk and early Ottoman periods the influence of the arakhina declined and that of the patriarchs increased accordingly. The legal documents Guirguis consulted show that the main concern of a patriarch such as John XIII (1484–1524) was the question of marriage—whether, for example, the traditional prohibition of marrying a fourth time, or of marrying first cousins, was still valid at a time of declining population—and the question of concubinage, much in fashion in higher Coptic society, which raised the problem of the legal status of children born of female slaves. While he proved practical and pragmatic where the first question was concerned, John was adamant in his opposition to concubinage, and the same was largely true of his successor Gabriel VII (1525–68). The next patriarchs, John XIV (1571–85) and Gabriel VIII (1587–1603), had to deal with the overtures of the Roman papacy and the quest for Christian unity (which, in the West, was understood as submission to Rome). Here Guirguis refers to the documents published by Antoine Rabbath in 1910 rather than to the far better and more recent edition of the same texts published by Charles Libois in the Monumenta Historica Societatis Iesu between 1993 and 2003.
By the early 17th century the struggle for authority between lay leadership and the clergy was again coming to the fore, with opposition to the papacy growing both in lower Egypt and in Cairo. Despite an interlude of peace under the enlightened Matthew III (1628–46) the unrest was a prelude to the return of the arakhina as the Ottoman government became weaker and less centralized and ever more power was placed in the hands of individuals. Church government seems to have followed suit, and from the time of the papacy of Mark VI (1646–56) in the mid-17th century to the late 18th century the arakhina had the upper hand. Not only did the lay Copts come to occupy the very highest positions in the financial and administrative apparatus of the state, thereby becoming valuable intermediaries between the Coptic communities and the government with whose representatives they were often on the best of terms, but they also amassed vast fortunes. They could thus provide a leadership sometimes denied to the patriarch, and, in the case of Mark VI as well as most of his successors, it was they who actually elected the patriarch. Their power meant that they could continue practices, such as concubinage, which had been widely condemned. Their authority in the Church was further proved by their active part in the restoration of churches and monasteries, their encouragement of educational reform and the copying of religious texts, and the fact that they could even become secular bishops by the 18th century.
The second part of this book, “The Modern Coptic Papacy (1798–2011),” is by Nelly van Doorn-Harder. It covers a period for which, in contrast to earlier times, the source material is increasingly rich and, for the papacy of the late Shenouda III (1971–2012), “becomes,” in Van Doorn-Harder's words, “overwhelming.” The essay, which crosses the borders at which history turns into journalism and ends at the tantalizing moment between the fall of Mubarak and the death of Shenouda, is over twice as long as that of Magdi Guirguis.
Both Coptic society and relations between the Copts and the Muslims were disrupted by Napoleon's 1798 invasion of Egypt and its aftermath. With the rule of Muhammad ʿAli between 1805 and 1849 the power of the arakhina began to decline once again. Although the new ruler still used the notables, particularly as land surveyors and scribes, he tended to prefer other Christians to the Copts, recruiting Frenchmen and Armenians. The patriarchs, moreover, starting with Peter VII (1809–53), were concentrating power in their own hands and implementing reforms that were once the domain of the notables. Peter and his successors, particularly Cyril IV (1854–61), turned their attention ever more to foreign churches, not only to the Ethiopians who were in communion with them, but also to the Russians, Greeks, Armenians, and Anglicans. They were increasingly open to western ideas and were stimulated by the spread of Protestant missionary schools to found more schools and seminaries of their own. But perhaps the most decisive changes in the Church of Alexandria took place during the long papacy of Cyril IV, which lasted from 1874 to 1927.
Once again it was the laity that took the initiative, founding the Church Community Council in 1874, a lay board advising on the financial and civil affairs of the Coptic community. In 1881, a group of laymen started to create a series of voluntary charitable associations running educational and health projects, and in 1895 they launched the newspaper Misr. The Coptic Seminary, originally founded by the Council in 1875, led to the foundation of Sunday schools. In 1911, finally, after the murder of Butrus Ghali, the first Coptic prime minister, an attempt was made to unify the Church with the Coptic Congress organized by the laity and held in Asyut.
The problems the patriarchs now faced were, of course, changing. Cyril VI, for example, patriarch in 1952 when Jamal ʿAbd al-Nasir came to power, had to adapt himself not only to an entirely new form of government—in fact he got on surprisingly well with the new president—but also to a massive emigration of the Copts and the foundation of new churches in North America and elsewhere. In Egypt he oversaw a monastic revival and the establishment of nunneries and new schools before he was succeeded by Shenouda III in 1971. The task of Shenouda was perhaps the most arduous of all. The Coptic Church expanded into central Africa, requiring a missionary organization. Emigration increased, and the new problems were compounded by the opportunism of Sadat, who catered to the intolerance of the Muslim Brotherhood at the expense of the Copts. Besides persecuting the Coptic clergy, Sadat sentenced the patriarch to exile in the monastery of Baramus, which lasted some four years. Shenouda also met with opposition within his Church when, for example, he entered into a theological conflict with the charismatic monk Matta al-Miskin.
Like the other volumes of The Popes of Egypt, this last one has the advantage of greater objectivity than most works on the Copts, which are often informed by anti-Islamic rhetoric. The authors accept that the relations between Christians and Muslims in Egypt have not always been idyllic and that there have indeed been bouts of persecution, but they present the Copts as an integral part of Egyptian society who have usually lived in the same conditions as their Muslim neighbors.
