Those of us of a certain age probably remember watching conductor Leonard Bernstein present his Young People's Concerts on television. This reviewer recalls being entranced by Bernstein's mellifluous speaking voice and the wonderful music emanating from the New York Philharmonic. Although somewhat dated today in terms of pop culture references, the programs, now on DVD, still provide a wealth of musical information and showcase Bernstein's prodigious gifts as a conductor, pianist, and pedagogue. In Leonard Bernstein and His Young People's Concerts, author Alicia Kopfstein-Penk has painstakingly analyzed these programs in detail, a project that evolved from her doctoral dissertation.Footnote 1 She has skillfully situated Bernstein and the shows within the larger sociological and political milieu, and in the process, demonstrated how he connected music to its non-musical environment.
Despite numerous biographies, coffee table books, and articles on various aspects of Bernstein's life and music, the Young People's Concerts have received relatively scant attention. Humphrey Burton discusses them briefly in his biography, Leonard Bernstein (1994), and there are a few dissertations, but until the publication of Leonard Bernstein and His Young People's Concerts, no full-length monograph existed.Footnote 2 The book is extremely well researched, but sometimes its fascination with statistics and detail overshadows its main subject areas or prevents us from arriving there in a timely manner. For example, Kopfstein-Penk includes tables with programs associated with recording sessions (29) and weekly hours taken up by children's series (73). Although this information may be useful, the level of detail sometimes overwhelms and frequently interrupts the narrative. This focus on data might suggest a target audience of experts, but the book frequently caters to novices as well, thereby potentially alienating both demographics. Kopfstein-Penk would do well to clarify her intended readership. In addition, there are a few small factual errors, such as her reference to John Cage's seminal piece, 4’33”, which she refers to as 3’44” (probably a typographical error).
Although the book lacks a specific audience focus, there is much to appreciate in the sheer amount of information presented. Eight chapters, bookended by an introduction and an epilogue, provide a wealth of knowledge. In addition, there are tables, charts and photographs, as well as eight appendices that list the programs alphabetically, numerically, by filming medium, by performer, by Nielsen ratings, without Bernstein, and by American and twentieth-century content. Kopfstein-Penk has been nothing if not thorough.
The first two chapters deal with Bernstein's choice of programs. Kopfstein-Penk notes that he “controlled almost all aspects of these televised concerts. He decided on the topics, wrote the scripts, selected the compositions and guest artists … narrated the programs, conducted and performed” (1). Bernstein chose the subjects based upon the age and interest of his own children at the time (57). The shows focused on “technical investigations, composers, music appreciation, and young performers” in fifty-three episodes from 1957–72 (14). Bernstein never talked down to his young audience (5), while always striving for the dual goals of education and entertainment. In fact, this reviewer feels that Bernstein helped pioneer the concept of “edutainment.”
The next two chapters are the least compelling because they overload the reader with details in a less-than-engaging manner. Chapter 3 focuses on the distinction in culture between lowbrow, highbrow, and middlebrow, and the ways in which these designations found their way into television programming. In chapter 4, Kopfstein-Penk notes that highbrow television programs generally netted a relatively small audience, and were therefore relegated to the “cultural ghetto of Sunday programming” (72). However, during the 1960s, the Young People's Concerts appeared in the rarified air of primetime, ultimately winning four Emmy awards throughout the span of the show (89). These programs also increased the prestige and coffers of the New York Philharmonic, and, this reviewer feels, that of Bernstein as well.
Chapters 5 and 6 examine different aspects of Bernstein's personality as they were filtered through these programs. Chapter 5 identifies Bernstein as a pacifist, focusing on ways that he subtly included his political philosophies. Although he was very outspoken regarding a variety of causes in his personal and professional life, doing so on television could incur the ire of the networks or the sponsors. Therefore, he had to be circumspect about injecting his own views. Nevertheless, he championed Soviet composer Dmitri Shostakovich during the Red Scare of the 1950s, promoted Cuba during the Cuban Missile Crisis, and asked for peace during the Vietnam War. Kopfstein-Penk notes of Bernstein, “He was … an activist who firmly believed that artists have a responsibility to shine a light on the ills of society” (94). In a similar vein, Chapter 6 presents Bernstein as a champion of justice and equality by showcasing African American and female performers on his program. André Watts, Janis Ian, and Shulamit Ran all got their professional start on the Young People's Concerts. These two chapters successfully captured part of the essence of Leonard Bernstein, and for that reason, they were the most interesting.
The final two chapters highlight modern and American music, respectively. Chapter 7 examines the two primary compositional camps of the twentieth century, experimental and tonal, placing Bernstein in the latter group as a musical reactionary and defender of tonality. Despite his compositional leanings, though, Bernstein featured several pieces of experimental music in his Young People's Concerts, as well as supporting those composers. On this topic, Kopfstein-Penk appears to be slightly defensive toward tonality in her language regarding twelve-tone music. Chapter 8 explains that Bernstein was one of the first to champion American music at the New York Philharmonic, focusing on composers such as Gershwin, Copland, and Ives.
The Young People's Concerts played a pivotal role in changing the public's view of topics ranging from Gustav Mahler to American music to concerts’ role in society (xxvi). They also helped to erase the “…artificial barriers between highbrow and lowbrow, art music and popular music…” (xxix). Furthermore, these programs allowed Bernstein to do what he did best—teach. As Kopfstein-Penk observes, “Bernstein knew that the best way to teach is to guide students to make their own discoveries, which will help them to remember better and take the lessons to heart. … Bernstein hoped these concerts would open people's minds and hearts not only musically, but perhaps politically and socially as well” (136).
Alicia Kopfstein-Penk's Leonard Bernstein and His Young People's Concerts showcases the groundbreaking work done by Bernstein in television's early years, a surprisingly under-researched aspect of his career. Engaging photographs, fan mail, and even comic strips help to illustrate the impact that Bernstein had on his television audience. The book functions at its best when it frames his teachings within their cultural and temporal environments. Kopfstein-Penk is to be commended for her meticulous and extensive archival research. Ironically, this same careful attention also leads to the book's chief flaw: overemphasizing details at the expense of main topics. A second criticism is that Kopfstein-Penk has not adequately defined her audience, and therefore, she seems to cover too much to appeal to everyone. However, despite these two key shortcomings, this book is an important and necessary addition to Bernstein scholarship because of its unique subject. Students of both music and television history will find much new information regarding Bernstein. Those of us who lived through the late 1950s and ’60s will alternately smile or nod in remembrance of Leonard Bernstein and the way in which he both entertained and educated the child in all of us.
