In this long-awaited book, Jan de Vries argues the Industrial Revolution was preceded by an equally important industrious revolution that took place within the household. It is an arresting and ambitious thesis, first aired by de Vries in a much-quoted article in this Journal a decade and a half ago (“The Industrial Revolution and the Industrious Revolution,” This JOURNAL 54, no. 2 (1994): 249–70). Now he offers a comprehensive, book-length case for the industrious revolution. It is, at one and the same time, breathtakingly erudite, accessibly written, and admirably concise.
De Vries's industrious revolution addresses a fundamental paradox that has emerged in studies of the British Industrial Revolution over the last quarter century. Recent quantitative studies of the classic period of Industrial Revolution, from 1760 to 1830, show much lower rates of economic growth than had previously been assumed. Real wages emerge as stagnant, at best. Yet studies of the material lives of the population, especially of their access to consumer goods, reveal a progressive expansion of material horizons across the eighteenth century. For business, social, and cultural historians, it is the century of “consumer revolution,” when commodities such as tea, watches, silver plated buckles, and printed fabrics became familiar purchases, even among the laboring classes.
De Vries resolves this paradox in two ways. First, he points out that if macroeconomic growth before 1830 was slower than previously believed, then “it leaves ‘preindustrial’ England as a rather richer economy than had earlier been assumed, for the simple reason that less growth in the 1760–1830 period means the pre-1760 economy must have possessed a per capita income closer to that found in the post-1830 period” (pp. 85–86). Here de Vries is expressing his attachment to what he calls, “The Revolt of the Early Modernists” (p. 7): the effective challenge mounted by early modern economic historians (including, prominently, de Vries himself) to the old belief that the European economy of the period from the fifteenth to the eighteenth centuries was premodern and therefore growthless. While rejecting Neil McKendrick's idea of an eighteenth-century “consumer revolution” capable of jump-starting the leading sectors of the Industrial Revolution, de Vries nevertheless insists that consumer demand was transformed in northwest Europe between 1650 and 1800. New kinds of commodities emerged, with the capacity to entice ordinary people out of self-sufficiency into working harder and buying more. They included new manufactured goods that were cheaper, less durable, and more fashion sensitive, such as clothing fabrics in lightweight, printed cottons and containers for food and drink in decorated earthenwares. They also included new kinds of stimulants, both exotic (such as tea, tobacco, and sugar) and domestic (such as gin and brandy).
Second, de Vries argues that the key dynamic in this period of preindustrial economic expansion was the behavior of the household as an economic unit, in particular the way time was allocated to different activities by members of the household. In order to buy more, ordinary households devoted increasing time and effort to paid work, especially the wives and daughters of those households. Wage rates may have stagnated, or even fallen, but more household members participated in paid work, they worked longer hours and, above all, they worked for more days. Here de Vries's debt to the new household economics of Gary Becker is explicit. As with Becker, the key question of who decided—husband or wife, parents or children—is not closely interrogated. The black box of the household is opened, but there is not much rummaging inside. Nevertheless, a great strength of de Vries's application of Becker lies in the way he approaches the issue of consumer choice, preferences, and taste. De Vries insists we move beyond the simple listing of new goods characteristic of much existing work on early modern consumption. He directs our attention to the way new goods only achieved a role in the life of households, and hence a market, by interacting with people and other commodities in what he terms consumption clusters. To succeed, novelties had to fit into existing ways of living in an intelligible manner. He stresses the embeddedness of material things in the practices and routines of everyday life. It is a formulation that echoes recent work in the sociology of innovation and consumption influenced by actor network theory. But de Vries's application of the household-centered approach goes further than this. He also uses it to give his industrious revolution chronological specificity. In the final section of the book, he argues that the industrious revolution went into reverse after 1850, eclipsed by the rise of the male breadwinner household. As the fruits of industrialization started, finally, to appear in workers' wage packets, their wives and children retreated from paid employment. The cause of this retreat he identifies as a new set of household expectations around cleanliness, health, and education, expectations that could not readily be fulfilled commercially.
This is a splendid book, magisterial in its command of its field, original in the thesis it advances and largely convincing in what it argues. Its shortcomings lie less in what it does than in what it fails to do. Curiously for an advocate of the “Revolt of the Early Modernists,” de Vries is chronologically timid when it comes to excavating the foundations of his industrious revolution. He traces its starting date only back as far as the mid-seventeenth century, when the new commodities he identifies as the spur goading women and children into paid work first became available. In 1600, he insists, northwestern Europeans still lived in inherited material worlds (p. 144). His list of key new commodities is, however, largely confined to the exotic groceries, Asian-influenced ceramics, and cotton textiles that are all too familiar from the eighteenth-century consumer revolution literature. Yet north German stonewares were transforming the market for drinking vessels in the sixteenth century, while the shift to lighter, brighter, cheaper, more fashion sensitive and less durable woolen textiles—the famous New Draperies—was underway in the fifteenth century. These textiles had many of the characteristics de Vries sees as typical of his post-1650 new consumer goods. They also provided novel opportunities for the kind of women's and children's work he discusses, because they required a much higher ratio of female spinners to male weavers than the older, heavier woolen fabrics. Moreover, the emergence of the New Draperies coincided with the aftermath of the Black Death, arguably the founding moment of the Western European marriage pattern, acknowledged by de Vries as the indispensible framework for the household behaviors he identifies. Perhaps de Vries should have the strength of his early modernist convictions and look for an earlier origin for his industrious revolution. It would chronologically unite all the analytical elements that contribute to his argument—family structure; opportunities for paid work; new consumer goods—and leave the timing of the industrious revolution less reliant on consumption alone.
