Edward Watts's new study offers a detailed analysis of the context and consequences of a student riot in late fifth-century Alexandria for the communal identities of late antique pagan intellectuals, Egyptian monastics and their lay associates (philoponoi), together with the exercising of episcopal authority in the city. Drawing on the account in Zacharias Scholasticus' Life of Severus detailing the beating of Paralius and the subsequent events during which a monastic party ransacked and destroyed the Isaic shrine at Menouthis, W.'s book develops earlier, formative treatments of the riot (e.g. F. R. Trombley, Hellenic Religion and Christianization vol. 2 (1994)), by exploring the ways in which a consideration of ‘the internal dynamics of smaller communities’ (262) casts into greater relief the transformations in the nature of society, and religious thought and action in the late antique period. W.'s analysis is particularly persuasive in the case that it makes for seeing the episode as, in some ways, indicative of the shifting nature of authority as mediated via those oral traditions which shaped communal conceptions of the significant past during Late Antiquity. Through the account of Paralius' beating at the hands of his pagan confreres, W. highlights the ways in which long-standing narratives of ideal conduct adjacent to established forms of authority — for instance within the culture of the philosophical schools of Alexandria — were being shed in favour of alternative narratives about the past in the new arenas of intellectual and religious authority, i.e. within the ascetic and ecclesiastical communities of late antique Egypt.
W.'s focus on dissecting the minutiae of a single incident in time means that a considerable proportion of the study is dedicated to exploring the context for the attitudes and behaviours on display in Zacharias' recollection of the events of a.d. 486. It is therefore a book rich in detail, characterized by careful examinations of a range of sources. After a scene-setting introductory chapter (‘The Anatomy of a Riot’), Part One (‘Historical Discourse in Intellectual Communities’) examines the delicate social fabric of the late antique philosophical schools, with the purpose of conveying some of the reasons for the beating meted out to Paralius, as someone who had challenged the claims to authority made by such figures as Paralius' grammarian Horapollon and the philosopher Asclepiodotus. Issues pertaining to the codification of authority within intellectual communities, and the nature of membership relative to those models of authority, are discussed in ch. 2 (‘Personal Legacy and Scholastic Identity’), whilst the immediate context for Paralius' treatment and its consequences for the future practice of philosophical ethics among Neoplatonists is analysed in ch. 3 (‘Past, Present, and Future in Late Neoplatonic Historical Discourse’) largely through a discussion of Damascius' Life of Isidore.
Part Two (‘The Past Within and Outside Late Antique Monasteries’) addresses similar concerns to Part One of the study, by examining the rôle of oral history in shaping identities and allegiances within and beyond Egyptian monastic communities. Ch. 4 (‘History and Shape of Monastic Communities’) looks at the nature of authority in Pachomian koinonia, but also at other texts such as the Historia Monachorum, in order to explain how historical narratives about monastic authority and ascetic endeavours caught the attention of those lay Christians residing beyond the confines of Egyptian monasteries. Ch. 5 (‘Anti-Chalcedonian Ascetics and their Student Associates’) considers one such example of attentive lay associates, the Alexandrian philoponoi, who had intervened to rescue Paralius, and who had interpreted his rough treatment ‘not as the corrective action of scholastic older brothers but as a religious provocation’ (154). W. argues that Zacharias, as a philoponos himself, had crafted his first-hand experience of the event in his Life of Severus in order to provide a Christian challenge to the dominant pagan environment of the Alexandrian school system: Zacharias' intention was realized, and thus changed forever the exercise of intellectual authority by the philosophers by turning their activities and ideas into objects of public (and imperial) scrutiny. Part Two of W.'s study makes a particularly valuable contribution to late antique studies in laying bare the rôle that both the cultural and political expressions of the significant past (viz. the rôle of memory) played in refining communal identities, and also as acting as catalysts for inflaming social tensions between competing parties.
Part Three considers the appropriation of the events of a.d. 486 by the Alexandrian episcopate, and in particular the way in which the patriarch Peter Mongus handled the immediate aftermath of Paralius' beating in order to effect his own reconciliation with the anti-Chalcedonian lobby, which had earlier been compromised by his subscription to the Henotikon of the emperor Zeno. Ch. 6 (‘Creating the Legend of the Alexandrian Bishop’) and ch. 7 (‘Theophilus and Cyril: The Alexandria Bishop Triumphant’) consider the evolution of the distinctive models of episcopal authority in Alexandria, with Athanasius' relations with the imperial authorities presented as the principal historical model for the Alexandrian bishops of the fifth century. As the reception of this model by Theophilus and Cyril indicates, the historical memories surrounding Athanasius did not remain static, and were actively transformed in order to meet the different challenges presented by the fifth century. Ch. 8 (‘Peter Mongus Struggles with the Past’) argues that Peter Mongus' reconciliation with Zeno appeared to compromise the reputation for an Athanasian-style resistance to imperial authority which anti-Chalcedonians had historically claimed for themselves (as typified in the stance taken by Peter's predecessors Dioscorus and Timothy Aelurus): Peter's ownership of the episcopate's initiatives in the aftermath of the attack on Paralius, thus enabled him to write the script of the event (240) in such a way as to heal his somewhat damaged reputation among sections of the anti-Chalcedonian community. His spearheading of the attack on the Isis cult in Menouthis was designed to evoke memories of the anti-pagan initiatives of Theophilus, although as W. points out it was a strategy which failed to convince the hard-core opposition that Peter's episcopate was in any way a genuine heir to the rich traditions of the Alexandrian Church. According to W.'s analysis, Peter Mongus emerges as the one personality who had perhaps most skilfully understood the complex memories underlying the riot, but who ultimately benefited the least from its place in the formation of future historical narratives of the Alexandrian Church.
My principal complaint about the study lies in its deferral of the historical reliability of Zacharias' account of Paralius' beating and the subsequent riot to an appendix (‘Appendix Two: How much should we trust Zacharias Scholasticus?’). As W. points out, Alan Cameron has lately challenged certain details about the Paralius episode in the Life of Severus, and it is my opinion that a study which leans so heavily on examining representations and uses which narratives of the past have been put to, should nevertheless have addressed the representational qualities of Zacharias' own account from the very beginning rather than marginalizing such an important consideration to the back of the book. In addition, many readers may be deterred from engaging with W.'s central arguments about the nature of orality in defining tradition and group identities by the at times hugely detailed historical nature of W.'s study. W. nevertheless cuts a swath through this mass of evidence with regular summary passages, and skilfully composed conclusions, both of which reiterate central and peripheral arguments, although they do very occasionally give the impression of a circularity of argumentation.
These reservations aside, W.'s book is remarkable in its investigative response to a single event in the complex landscape of religious and political change in the fifth century. It is hoped that it will become a template for future approaches to understanding the development and transformation of identities and allegiances in late antique society by encouraging other commentators to focus less on ‘the bigger picture’, and more on its details.
