Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T08:52:46.480Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Possibilities of the Interval: Heidegger and the Reimagining of the Interval in Luigi Nono’s A Carlo Scarpa

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 March 2023

Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

From 1976, the works of the Venetian composer Luigi Nono (1924–90) are marked by a noticeable change in both his philosophical and his political outlook. What results is a decade (1980–9) of compositions that feature poetry in librettos, live electronics, the spatialization of sound and a prominent use of microtonal pitches. Together these create completely novel soundscapes that are noticeably different from his previous output. This article will examine a particular influence – the philosophy of Martin Heidegger – in the creation of the 1984 piece for large ensemble A Carlo Scarpa. The purpose of this is not only to allow for an insight into the music and structure of A Carlo Scarpa, but also to illuminate how philosophical and political ideas can be represented within the craft of composition, and the new paths of thinking that guided Nono’s artistic output during the 1980s.

Information

Type
Article
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the Royal Musical Association
Figure 0

Example 1Outline of the harmony and sections of A Carlo Scarpa.

Figure 1

Example 2Section 19 is a harmonically clear section compared with other sections (the battuti strings being the only elements that play with microtonal deviations), and consists of only a single pitch (c). Despite the clarity of the celesta in the first bar, a very delicately played harp doubles it. Throughout the piece, no instruments play with complete instrumental purity; they are always either melded with other instruments or disrupted by percussive effects.

Figure 2

Example 3The harmonic structure of the two chords that make up section 1 of the piece. The first chord is E♭, which descends a minor third in bar 2 to C. The circled notes indicate they are performed at concert pitch, while the asterisk denotes the presence of the timpani. Backwards flats () and single stroke sharps () represent a quartertone flat and a quartertone sharp respectively. Single stroke arrows up ( ↑ ) and down ( ↓ ) represent an eighth of a tone sharp or flat respectively, and multiple signs next to a single note represent that two or more instruments are playing different microtonal deviations on that pitch. For instance, as will be shown momentarily, in the second bar, a flute and viola play an eighth of a tone sharp on middle C, while a French horn plays an eighth of a tone flat.

Figure 3

Example 4The instruments that play at concert pitch in section 1.

Figure 4

Example 5The instruments that play with microtonal deviation in section 1. It is important to note how Nono incorporates many diverse timbral colours with these instruments.

Figure 5

Example 6There are seven triangles used in A Carlo Scarpa. In section 1 – shown in this figure – the 3rd lowest and 2nd highest (triangles 3 and 6 respectively) are used. Triangle 3 mimics the rhythm of the timpani (the low part of the outer shell of concert pitches), while triangle 6 plays with the harp (the high part of the shell).

Figure 6

Example 7The strings playing battuti in section 1. In relation to Example 3, it is clear the contrabasses are playing at concert pitch and would be included in the ‘outer shell’ of the piece. However, because of the percussive effect of the technique, I have not included them there owing to the lack of tonal strength (though it is still perceptible). The violins and cellos are given headless stems, indicating that each player chooses a pitch that may be microtonally deviated from concert pitch.

Figure 7

Example 8The upper part of the ‘shell’ produced by the celesta and harp in section 1. The clarity of instruments is distorted by the strings playing battuti and by the triangle.

Figure 8

Example 9The lower part of the ‘shell’ in section 1, consisting of the timpani accompanied by a triangle and solo contrabass.

Figure 9

Example 10The first two beats of bar 1, exhibiting the way different timbres meld with one another.

Figure 10

Example 11The end of bar 1, with a violin playing on e″ quartertone flat, playing on the fingerboard (‘tasto’) with hair (‘crini’), while the viola plays at the bridge (‘al ponte’) and with both hair and wood of the bow (‘c+l’). These instruments then meld with a trumpet playing a very soft d″ quartertone sharp.

Figure 11

Example 12The ‘inner’ parts of the chord in bar 2 of section 1, based on the pitch of C. Once more it is possible to observe instruments that meld with one another, and use variable playing styles, creating dynamic, mobile textures.

Figure 12

Example 13The violas subverting the texture of the bell in section 21.

Figure 13

Example 14This figure shows bars three and four from the opening of Prometeo (1984, rev. 1985). Eight violins play a perfect fifth (four on the d ″ and four on the a ″). As is visible, Nono incorporates microtones into the interval, with the violins on A playing upwards in microtonal intervals (A, A quartertone sharp [], A sharp and A three-quartertone sharp – represented by three strokes []) and in D playing downwards (D, D quartertone flat [], D flat, D three-quartertone flat – represented by the mirrored flat symbol []). What this leaves is a ‘void’ in the middle of the chord, the meaning of which I will explore in greater depth momentarily. What is important to recognize, is how Nono uses microtones in order to give complexity to the most basic building blocks in Western music: the interval.