In American Taxation, American Slavery, Robin Einhorn chronicles the history of American taxation, arguing that its historical roots can be found in the institution of slavery. Einhorn's story is about how slavery undermined American democracy and influenced the design of American taxation because slaveholding elites ruled the nation until the Civil War. The main finding in general terms is that “the antigovernment rhetoric that continues to saturate our political life is rooted in slavery rather than liberty. The American mistrust of government is not part of our democratic heritage. It comes from slaveholding elites … (p. 7).
Following a brief Introduction, the Prologue discusses taxation in England and France in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, with passing reference to the Netherlands and Spain, maintaining that comprehensive and regressive taxation in the two countries, and in others, took place in the presence of monarchy and aristocracy and in nonrepresentative governments. In discussing the oppressive nature of taxation under the French Farmers General, Einhorn draws one of several generalizations about the contemporary world found in the book when she considers that among the noteworthy aspects of the Framers General, “[P]erhaps the most obvious is that it provides an object lesson about the perils of ‘privatizing’ public services,” especially, she claims, when compared to today's Internal Revenue Service (p. 11). Einhorn concludes the Prologue noting that although the story of the “history of American taxation is a history of taxation with representation” (p. 21, emphasis in original), the United States was “half slave and half free in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries,” which strongly influenced American politics and taxation (p. 22).
Part 1 presents the historical development of colonial and revolutionary tax systems in Virginia (Chapter 1), Massachusetts (Chapter 2), and several other colonies (Chapter 3). Although there was much variation in colonial and revolutionary taxation, Einhorn contends the general pattern was that where local governments were more democratic, with greater representation and less slavery, as in the northern colonies, taxation was comprehensive, sophisticated, and less regressive. Where there were less democratic local governments, with less representation and more slavery, as in the southern colonies, taxation was narrow, primitive, and more regressive. The critical difference was slavery.
In Virginia and elsewhere in the South, taxation relied on a “poll” or “tithables” tax and to various degrees on taxation of some trade, including slave imports, but the colonial South placed little reliance on taxation on the value of property (including slaves) or on wealth. Because a major aspect of southern society was “sovereign mastership” in which slaveholding elites were seen as the “masters” of their “families,” it was considered too intrusive to assess slaveholders' property (pp. 30, 51, 82). As a result, when Virginia attempted to tax the value of property in 1777/78, it was ineffective and primitive. When it instituted a land valuation scheme in 1779 for example, it did nothing more than “pretend” to value land based on the “opinions” of state assessors (p. 47). Virginia's “opinion-poll assessment” involved officials in “only pretending to assess land values” because Virginia had no colonial experience assessing property (p. 48).
In Massachusetts and elsewhere in the North, taxation was more comprehensive and sophisticated. Since the mid-seventeenth century, there was reliance on taxation on the value of property, as well as on “poll” taxes and taxation on trade. The democratic nature of local government and the lack of slaveholding masters meant northern colonies did not have to “pretend” to assess property values. In Massachusetts, for example, “its annually elected local officials were capable of assessing the value of property. Taxpayers could trust in the competence and good faith of these officials” (p. 78).
The historical development of the revolutionary and early national tax systems in the United States is discussed in Part 2. Chapter 4 discusses the origins of the U.S. tariff and Chapter 5 discusses the issue of national-level direct taxes. According to Einhorn, because of slavery, early national taxation relied nearly completely on import tariffs until the 1913 constitutional sanctioning of the income tax. And, because of slavery, national-level direct taxes were constitutionally constrained to be proportional to population and thus were nearly impossible to effectively implement. The tariff became a way around the slavery issue as its economic incidence depended on individuals' consumption of imported goods and it was neither directly on slaves nor slaveholders nor was the incidence explicitly known. And as long as the tariff was set at a low rate and kept simple “nobody had much incentive to investigate its economic details” (p. 133). As a result, Congress could propose import taxes “without talking about slavery” (pp. 117, 120, 128, 134, 154, 155, 156). But once the Confederation era impost, which was a 5 percent ad valorem duty on all imported goods, morphed into an enumerated tariff schedule with differential duties, a discussion of slavery could not be avoided. Nonetheless, Einhorn maintains, despite southern rhetoric to the contrary, the tariff was not an assault on slavery; the debate was about “northern industry rather than southern slavery;” it was about “industrial policy” not “tax policy” (p. 199).
Part 3 discusses the development of property taxation at the state and local level and the adoption of uniformity clauses in state constitutions during the nineteenth century (Chapter 6). Einhorn maintains that uniformity clauses, requiring uniform tax assessments and rates for different types of property, were first adopted in the South to protect slaveholding elites from majorities enacting higher slave taxation. Later, northern states adopted uniformity clauses in their constitutions to require “equal” treatment of elites, who they believed were receiving “unequal” favorable tax treatment. Whereas the northern states ostensibly wanted to increase taxes on elites, the courts often interpreted uniformity clauses as protecting elites from higher taxation that state legislatures imposed on corporations and the wealth of elites. Uniformity clauses thus were restraints on majority rule, according to Einhorn.
I have three primary reservations with Einhorn's story. First, the role of slavery in the history of taxation, while obviously important, seems exaggerated. In Einhorn's story, slavery not only played the decisive role in tax history, slavery appears to have lurked behind every tax. Second, her view of the role of tariffs in antebellum American history ignores an important proposition (tariff symmetry) in international economics. It was shown long ago that a tax on a country's imports is a tax on its exports, independent of exporters' consumption of imported commodities. Antebellum import tariffs implicitly taxed southern exports and thus were a de facto tax on slavery. Consequently, tariffs could not be enacted “without talking about slavery,” as antebellum tariff history documents. Third, Einhorn's story is undermined by her rhetoric, a few examples of which should suffice. When discussing the view that the nation was born in a tax revolt and rebellion against tyranny, which created a frugal republican government that has since been lost, she calls that a “radical libertarian” view (p. 3). When discussing the view that government growth and taxation were in response to citizens' demands, she calls that an “old-fashioned ‘liberal”’ view (p. 3). When examining the limitations of the liberal story, Einhorn argues it assumed that Roosevelt “outlined a political program that everyone except A few crazy extremists supported … these assumptions are no longer warranted. Today, the former extremists run the country, championing ‘creationism,’ attacking regulation, and pledging to cut taxes ….” (pp. 4–5, emphases added). Finally, when describing the antebellum United States, she concludes that “[I]t was a kind of Weimar in blackface” (p. 211).
Overall, Einhorn tells an interesting and provocative story of the role of slavery in the history of American taxation. For readers interested in the historical evolution of American public finance prior to the enactment of the national income tax, it is a story that should be worth reading.
