Stage for Action: U.S. Social Activist Theatre in the 1940s by Chrystyna Dail offers a thorough and compelling history of Stage for Action, a nearly forgotten theatre company for which Dail makes a strong case as having an outsized influence on mid-twentieth-century social and political performance in the United States. Compiling research from more than a dozen archives across the country, Dail pieces together a narrative that combines election campaigns, the career of Arthur Miller, the treatment of African American soldiers after World War II, labor union actions, the House Un-American Activities Committee, and more. In doing so, Dail highlights how Stage for Action's plays were deeply enmeshed in the history of its era during its short existence from 1943 to its disbanding in 1949.
The book's five chapters each cover plays from Stage for Action (SFA) focused around specific issues. The most successful of these tell the reader something new about theatre in the United States. Chapter 2 shows how SFA became increasingly involved in electoral politics, leading to the company's open support for Progressive Party presidential candidate Henry Wallace in 1948, with SFA plays growing more “politically provocative” as a result (69). Dail shows the evolving political ethos of SFA through a fascinating comparison of three different versions of Arthur Miller's one-act That They May Win, first produced in 1943 and revised by Miller in 1944 and 1948. In Chapter 3, Dail delves into the civil rights activism of SFA and looks at two plays, Skin Deep by Charles Polacheck and All Aboard by Ben Bengal, where “they do not merely highlight the problem of racial prejudice; instead, they demand new laws addressing issues of inequity” (71). The latter play was performed at a mass meeting of the NAACP in New York City in April 1947. As Dail writes, “[t]he plays of SFA regularly served as the opening act or afterpieces for lectures regarding prominent social issues or were sandwiched between speeches by politicians, labor leaders, and public intellectuals” (89). That use of social activist theatre to rally people at events connects SFA to the radical theatre of the 1920s and 1930s, and groups like the Workers’ Laboratory Theatre and the New Theatre League, an influence that Dail acknowledges, although she demonstrates how SFA's approach to theatre evolved away from Living Newspapers and, for the most part, simple agitprop.
The necessity of this book and the importance of the history it recounts are blunted a bit by some awkward aspects. For instance, Dail spends pages in an effort to demonstrate that SFA member Arthur Miller's 1953 play, The Crucible, was, for lack of a better word, plagiarized in part from the 1948 SFA play Salem Story by Sidney Alexander. While this might be interesting to examine in a separate article, in the context of the book the effort seems misplaced. The book would have benefited also from more attention to the broader scope implied by its subtitle; U.S. Social Activist Theatre in the 1940s is a bit of a misrepresentation since the focus is primarily, if not exclusively, on SFA. Dail quotes John Gassner to say that the 1940s began “a downward spiral in socially relevant plays” (6), but the history is not that simple. It leaves out companies like the American Negro Theatre, which was producing such work starting in 1940, or the Yiddish theatre scene in New York City, which was still going strong in the 1940s with groups producing plays that focused on some of the same topics as SFA. Dail is so successful in contextualizing SFA in historical and political currents, even giving the life stories of some of the key players, that the oversight is noticeable. Finally, the organization of the book can be frustrating. Dail repeatedly returns to the campaign of Henry Wallace, adding new information or reiterating details that were included just a few pages before. Perhaps this means that the book would have benefited from a more chronological approach.
However, as an act of recovery and the culmination of much research, Stage for Action is an impressive feat. Here was a theatre that involved people as well-known as Miller, Paul Robeson, and Barbara Bel Geddes, a group praised by Eleanor Roosevelt in her “My Day” column in April 1944, and a company that was killed, in part, by the Communist witch hunts of the House Un-American Activities Committee. It took on issues from workers’ rights to the threat of the atomic bomb to liberation for Puerto Rico. In Dail's telling, SFA was at the forefront of activist theatre, with branches in multiple cities, performing for enthusiastic audiences of hundreds of thousands of people, and its legacy far outlasted its existence in the work of the artists who came from the group.
