Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T05:23:04.235Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

A high-order asymptotic analysis of the Benjamin–Feir instability spectrum in arbitrary depth

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 February 2023

Ryan P. Creedon*
Affiliation:
Department of Applied Mathematics, University of Washington, Seattle, WA USA
Bernard Deconinck*
Affiliation:
Department of Applied Mathematics, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA
*
†Email addresses for correspondence: creedon@uw.edu, deconinc@uw.edu
†Email addresses for correspondence: creedon@uw.edu, deconinc@uw.edu

Abstract

We investigate the Benjamin–Feir (or modulational) instability of Stokes waves, i.e. small-amplitude, one-dimensional periodic gravity waves of permanent form and constant velocity, in water of finite and infinite depth. We develop a perturbation method to describe to high-order accuracy the unstable spectral elements associated with this instability, obtained by linearizing Euler's equations about the small-amplitude Stokes waves. These unstable elements form a figure-eight curve centred at the origin of the complex spectral plane, which is parametrized by a Floquet exponent. Our asymptotic expansions of this figure-eight are in excellent agreement with numerical computations as well as recent rigorous results by Berti et al. (Full description of Benjamin–Feir instability of Stokes waves in deep water, 2021, arXiv:2109.11852) and Berti et al. (Benjamin–Feir instability of Stokes waves in finite depth, 2022, arXiv:2204.00809). From our expansions, we derive high-order estimates for the growth rates of the Benjamin–Feir instability and for the parametrization of the Benjamin–Feir figure-eight curve with respect to the Floquet exponent. We are also able to compare the Benjamin–Feir and high-frequency instability spectra analytically for the first time, revealing three different regimes of the Stokes waves, depending on the predominant instability.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic of a $2{\rm \pi} /\kappa$-periodic Stokes wave $\eta _S$ in finite depth $h$. The wave travels uniformly to the left or right, depending on its velocity. In the case of infinite depth, Stokes derived an asymptotic expansion for $\eta _S$ and its velocity as power series in a small parameter $\varepsilon$ related to the amplitude of the wave.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Schematic of the stability spectrum for a small-amplitude Stokes wave in sufficiently deep water. Spectral elements with positive real part indicate instability according to (1.1). The Benjamin–Feir figure-eight curve is coloured blue, while the high-frequency instabilities are coloured orange. In this manuscript, we are concerned with high-order asymptotic approximations of the blue figure-eight curve. For the corresponding approximations of the high-frequency instabilities in orange, see Creedon et al. (2022).

Figure 2

Figure 3.Numerically computed Benjamin–Feir instability spectra in infinitely deep water for Stokes waves of amplitude $\varepsilon = 0.31$ (a), $\varepsilon = 0.32$ (b), and $\varepsilon = 0.33$ (c). The methods presented in this work apply only for sufficiently small $\varepsilon$ and, thus, do not capture the separation of the figure-eight from the origin.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Schematic of the parametrizing interval of Floquet exponents for the Benjamin–Feir figure-eight curve as a function of $\varepsilon$. The grey-shaded region indicates the leading-order approximation of this interval $\varepsilon \mu _1$, where $\mu _1$ is an interval of values symmetric approximately zero. The blue-shaded region indicates the true interval as a function of $\varepsilon$ and is a uniform rescaling of the leading-order behaviour by a factor of $1+r(\varepsilon )$, where $r$ is an analytic function of $\varepsilon$ such that $r(\varepsilon ) = o(1)$ as $\varepsilon \searrow 0$. The boundaries of the true interval may be subtended by curves that are concave up or down, depending on $\alpha$.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Plot of $e_{BW}$ versus $\alpha$. The only root of $e_{BW}$ for $\alpha >0$ is $\alpha _{BW} = 1.3627827567\ldots$.

Figure 5

Figure 6.(a) Plot of the Benjamin–Feir figure-eight curve for a Stokes wave with amplitude $\varepsilon = 10^{-3}$ and aspect ratio $\alpha = 1.5$. Numerical results are given by the blue dots, and the asymptotic results to ${O}(\varepsilon ^2)$ are given by the solid orange curve. (b) Floquet parametrization of the real (blue axis) and imaginary (orange axis) part of the figure-eight curve on the left. The respective numerical results are given by the correspondingly coloured dots, and the respective asymptotic results to ${O}(\varepsilon ^2)$ are given by the correspondingly coloured curves.

Figure 6

Figure 7.(a) Interval of Floquet exponents parametrizing the half-loop of the Benjamin–Feir figure-eight curve for a Stokes wave with aspect ratio $\alpha = 1.5$ and variable amplitude $\varepsilon$. The numerically computed boundary of this interval is given by the blue dots, while the solid blue curve gives the asymptotic results to ${O}(\varepsilon ^2)$. The orange dots give the numerically computed Floquet exponents of the most unstable eigenvalue, while the solid orange curves give the corresponding asymptotic results to ${O}(\varepsilon )$. (b) Real (blue axis) and imaginary (orange axis) part of the most unstable eigenvalue with $\alpha = 1.5$ and variable $\varepsilon$. Numerical results are given by the correspondingly coloured dots, and the asymptotic results for the real and imaginary part to ${O}(\varepsilon ^2)$ and ${O}(\varepsilon )$, respectively, are given by the correspondingly coloured solid curves.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Plot of $r_2$ versus $\alpha$. For all $\alpha > \alpha _{BW}$, $r_2$ is well defined. As $\alpha \searrow \alpha _{BW}$ or $\alpha \rightarrow \infty$, $r_2$ becomes singular. The singular behaviour as $\alpha \searrow \alpha _{BW}$ is arrested by the factor of $\mu _1$ in front of (3.42b) and (3.53a). The singular behaviour as $\alpha \rightarrow \infty$ remains, showcasing the breakdown of compactness in finite versus infinite depth, see Berti et al. (2022) and Nguyen & Strauss (2020) for further discussion.

Figure 8

Figure 9.(a) Plot of the Benjamin–Feir figure-eight curve for a Stokes wave with amplitude $\varepsilon = 0.1$ and aspect ratio $\alpha = 1.5$. Numerical results are given by the blue dots, while asymptotic results to ${O}(\varepsilon ^2)$ and ${O}(\varepsilon ^4)$ are given by the solid orange and green curves, respectively. (b) Floquet parametrization of the real (blue axis) and imaginary (orange axis) part of the figure-eight curve on the left. Numerical results are given by the correspondingly coloured dots. The asymptotic parametrizations of the real part to ${O}(\varepsilon ^2)$ and ${O} (\varepsilon ^4)$ are given by the solid blue and light blue curves, respectively, while those for the imaginary part are given by the solid orange and red curves, respectively.

Figure 9

Figure 10.(a) Interval of Floquet exponents parametrizing the half-loop of the Benjamin–Feir figure-eight curve for a Stokes wave with aspect ratio $\alpha = 1.5$ and variable amplitude $\varepsilon$. The numerically computed boundary of this interval is given by the blue dots, while the solid blue and light blue curves give the asymptotic results to ${O}(\varepsilon )$ and ${O}(\varepsilon ^3)$, respectively. The orange dots give the numerically computed Floquet exponents of the most unstable eigenvalue, while the solid orange and red curves give the corresponding asymptotic estimates to ${O}(\varepsilon )$ and ${O}(\varepsilon ^3)$, respectively. (b) Real (blue axis) and imaginary (orange axis) part of the most unstable eigenvalue on the half-loop with $\alpha = 1.5$ and variable $\varepsilon$. Numerical results are given by the correspondingly coloured dots. The asymptotic approximations of the real part to ${O}(\varepsilon ^2)$ and ${O}(\varepsilon ^4)$ are given by the solid blue and light blue curves, respectively. The asymptotic approximations of the imaginary part to ${O}(\varepsilon )$ and ${O}(\varepsilon ^3)$ are given by the solid orange and red curves, respectively.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Real part of the most unstable eigenvalue (modulo $\varepsilon ^2$) on the largest high-frequency instability (orange) and the Benjamin–Feir instability (blue) as a function of $\alpha$. Numerical results using $\varepsilon = 10^{-3}$ are given by the correspondingly coloured dots. The asymptotic results (3.71) and (3.73) are given by the correspondingly coloured solid curves. We observe three regimes for the periodic water wave problem: (i) $\alpha <\alpha _{BW}$; (ii) $\alpha _{BW}<\alpha <\alpha _{DO}$; and (iii) $\alpha >\alpha _{DO}$, where $\alpha _{BW}$ is the root of (3.23) and $\alpha _{DO}$ is the root of (3.74). This agrees with the numerical results in figure 11 of Deconinck & Oliveras (2011).

Figure 11

Figure 12.(a) Plot of the Benjamin–Feir figure-eight curve for a Stokes wave with amplitude $\varepsilon = 10^{-3}$ in infinite depth. Numerical results are given by the blue dots, and the asymptotic results to ${O}(\varepsilon ^2)$ are given by the solid orange curve. (b) Floquet parametrization of the real (blue axis) and imaginary (orange axis) part of the figure-eight curve on the left. The respective numerical results are given by the correspondingly coloured dots, and the asymptotic results for the real and imaginary part to ${O}(\varepsilon ^2)$ and ${O}(\varepsilon )$, respectively, are given by the correspondingly coloured curves.

Figure 12

Figure 13.Plot of the Benjamin–Feir figure-eight curve for a Stokes wave with amplitude $\varepsilon = 2.5 \times 10^{-2}$ in infinite depth. Numerical results are given by the blue dots and the asymptotic results to ${O}(\varepsilon ^2)$ are given by the solid green curve. The solid orange curve gives the approximation of Berti et al. (2021). This approximation is not asymptotic in the imaginary part of the figure-eight curve to ${O}(\varepsilon ^2)$.

Figure 13

Figure 14.(a) Interval of Floquet exponents parametrizing the half-loop of the Benjamin–Feir figure-eight curve for a Stokes wave with an infinite depth and variable amplitude $\varepsilon$. The numerically computed boundary of this interval is given by the blue dots, while the solid blue curve gives the asymptotic results to ${O}(\varepsilon ^2)$. The orange dots give the numerically computed Floquet exponents of the most unstable eigenvalue, while the solid orange curves give the corresponding asymptotic results to ${O}(\varepsilon )$. (b) Real (blue axis) and imaginary (orange axis) part of the most unstable eigenvalue in infinite depth with variable $\varepsilon$. Numerical results are given by the correspondingly coloured dots, and the asymptotic results for the real and imaginary part to ${O}(\varepsilon ^2)$ and ${O}(\varepsilon )$, respectively, are given by the correspondingly coloured solid curves.

Figure 14

Figure 15.(a) Plot of the Benjamin–Feir figure-eight curve for a Stokes wave with amplitude $\varepsilon = 0.1$ in infinite depth. Numerical results are given by the blue dots, while asymptotic results to ${O}(\varepsilon ^2)$ and ${O}(\varepsilon ^3)$ are given by the solid orange and green curves, respectively. (b) Floquet parametrization of the real (blue axis) and imaginary (orange axis) part of the figure-eight curve on the left. Numerical results are given by the correspondingly coloured dots. The asymptotic parametrizations of the real part to ${O}(\varepsilon ^2)$ and ${O} (\varepsilon ^3)$ are given by the solid blue and light blue curves, respectively, while those for the imaginary part are given by the solid orange and red curves, respectively.

Figure 15

Figure 16.(a) Interval of Floquet exponents parametrizing the half-loop of the Benjamin–Feir figure-eight curve for a Stokes wave in infinite depth with variable amplitude $\varepsilon$. The numerically computed boundary of this interval is given by the blue dots, while the solid blue and light blue curves give the asymptotic results to ${O}(\varepsilon )$ and ${O}(\varepsilon ^3)$, respectively. The orange dots give the numerically computed Floquet exponents of the most unstable eigenvalue, while the solid orange and red curves give the corresponding asymptotic estimates to ${O}(\varepsilon )$ and ${O}(\varepsilon ^2)$, respectively. (b) Real (blue axis) and imaginary (orange axis) part of the most unstable eigenvalue on the half-loop in infinite depth with variable $\varepsilon$. Numerical results are given by the correspondingly coloured dots. The asymptotic approximations of the real part to ${O}(\varepsilon ^2)$ and ${O}(\varepsilon ^3)$ are given by the solid blue and light blue curves, respectively. The asymptotic approximations of the imaginary part to ${O}(\varepsilon )$ and ${O}(\varepsilon ^2)$ are given by the solid orange and red curves, respectively.

Supplementary material: File

Creedon and Deconinck supplementary material

Creedon and Deconinck supplementary material

Download Creedon and Deconinck supplementary material(File)
File 324.9 KB