No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 May 2004
On 22 November 2001, the Turkish Parliament passed a new civil code that changed women's legal status in the family, establishing full equality between spouses. The New Legal Status of Women in Turkey, a booklet published by Women for Women's Human Rights (WWHR), a women's non-governmental organization (NGO) based in Istanbul, provides a comprehensive overview of the new legal status of women in Turkey.
This booklet focuses mainly on the gains of the new civil code, which came into effect on 1 January 2002, replacing the Civil Code of 1926. While the former code, which was based on the Swiss civil code, granted women considerable rights (by outlawing polygamy and gender inequality regarding divorce, custody of children, and inheritance), it included several discriminatory articles that relegated women to a subordinate status and reinforced unequal power relations between men and women in the family. The former civil code, for instance, stated that the “husband is the head of the family,” thus giving him the final say over the choice of the place of residence and over matters related to children. The husband also represented the marriage union in legal matters. The new civil code removed these and similar discriminatory clauses that disempowered women in relation to their husbands. It has established equality between spouses, thus granting women equal say in decisions regarding the marriage union and their children (pp. 8, 18–19).
The booklet also discusses the new property regime, which gives spouses equal rights over property acquired during marriage (pp. 21–22). This property regime has been supported by a majority of women's groups and organizations in Turkey, as it recognizes that women contribute to the well-being of the household through their unpaid, invisible labor. During discussions on the draft new civil code, however, nationalist and religious conservative members of Parliament opposed the acquired-property regime, arguing that it would turn the marriage union into a corporation, increase divorce rates, and thus threaten the very foundations of Turkish society (p. 7). While nationalists and religious conservatives eventually accepted the acquired property regime as the new property regime, in part yielding to the pressure exerted by women's groups, they passed a law, stipulating that the new property regime is valid only for assets acquired after 1 January 2002 (p. 24).
Pointing to the existing “tensions and contradictions between official laws and customary practices” (p. 2), the booklet argues that legal changes, such as the adoption of the new civil code, are not sufficient to enable women to enjoy their rights in the public arena and in their everyday lives (p. 1). Indeed, secular gains and constitutional equality have often been circumscribed and undermined by customs and traditions. Under customary practices, the booklet discusses such practices as “bride price” (p. 16), “virginity testing” (pp. 53–55), and “honor crimes” (pp. 55–56), which violate legal provisions protecting women's rights and bodily integrity.
While the booklet recognizes the powerful impact of potential European Union membership on Turkey's domestic politics, it rejects the argument that the civil code was revised merely to make Turkey's legislation conform with that of the E.U. member states and thus to speed Turkey's membership in the union. It is rightly argued that two decades of activism, lobbying, and campaigning by the women's movement played a key role in the revision of the seventy-five-year-old civil code. The booklet also highlights the successes of the women's movement in the revision of certain articles of the penal code and in helping bring into effect a new law against domestic violence that allows for a protection order against the perpetrator of the violence (p. 5).
The booklet has several strengths. There are, for instance, frequent references to the former civil code with the effort to better highlight the key gains women made under the new code. Also, a great deal of information is provided under the headings such as “Conditions for Marriage,” “Women's Right to Economic Independence,” “Women's Right to Political Participation,” “Reproductive Rights and Health,” “Violence against Women,” “Homosexuality,” “Transsexuality,” “Sex Workers,” and “Pornography.”
While the booklet covers a wide range of issues concerning women, it has several limitations. One such limitation concerns the omission of any discussion on the headscarf (türban) issue, which has triggered considerable debate in Turkey since the mid-1980s. Another limitation is the absence of any discussion of dissent among women's groups concerning the content of the revisions demanded in the civil code. While the Preface indicates that 126 women's groups got together to voice their common demands regarding the new civil code, it does not mention any groups or activists who opposed the proposed revisions. Future editions would benefit from a preface that provides a more detailed account of the context within which the amendments to the civil code were debated and subsequently passed to better appreciate the political significance of women's activism. These limitations aside, the booklet is a valuable resource for activists, NGOs, researchers, scholars, and all those interested in women's legal status in Turkey.
While the reform of the civil code is a major step forward in the struggle to achieve gender equality in Turkey, it needs to be followed by other reforms aimed at eliminating sexism in all spheres of life. Women's groups and organizations in Turkey continue with their efforts to bring into public attention the laws that discriminate against women. This booklet is part of that effort.