This is a collection of 18 papers arising from a conference held in Boulogne-sur-Mer in September 2015 which is more or less evenly divided between contributions relating to Boulogne, in its role as main base of the classis Britannica and commercial port, and to its hinterland, the territory of the Morini. Both parts are prefaced by valuable up-to-date overviews, the former by O. Blamangin and A. Demon (29–41), the latter by C. Hoët-van-Cauwenberghe (199–215). The great majority of the chapters are by French authors, but two, also in French, are by British contributors: S. Esmonde Cleary on cross-Channel relations and A. Richardson on the archaeology of East Wear Bay, Folkestone (Kent), on the English coast facing Boulogne. Besides consideration of Boulogne itself, two particular themes of general interest emerge from the papers: economic activity, including the organization of cross-Channel trade and traffic, and Boulogne's role in that; and Late Roman militarization of the coastal region of northwest France. The review which follows focuses in particular on these topics.
The first (introductory) chapter summarizes what is known of ancient Boulogne, variously named by ancient authors, and the reasons for it being identified as the same place as the port of the Morini (later, Pliny's portus Morinorum Britannicum Footnote 1), Portus Itius (Caesar's port of embarkation for the second expedition to Britain in 54 BCEFootnote 2), and Gesoriacum-Bononia, first recorded in an inscription from Asia Minor of 4 CE.Footnote 3 The estuary of the River Liane provided an appropriate setting for a port which was within easy reach of the coast of Britain, and archaeology has confirmed evidence of settlement beside the river from the early 1st c. CE, though a more celebrated fixed point is the building of the lighthouse attributed to Caligula, La Tour d'Odre, the remains of which were destroyed when the cliff on which it was built collapsed in 1644. Whether the remains depicted in various 17th-c. illustrations were of Caligula's time or of the 2nd c. will never be resolved, as B. Delacroix (44–56) reminds us in her evaluation of the written sources relating to Boulogne and its role as naval and commercial port.
Although the creation of the classis Britannica probably dates back to Claudius and his conquest of Britain, physical evidence of bases associated with the fleet only emerges clearly in the early 2nd c. CE. At Boulogne, sufficient remains of barracks and fort wall (as excavated by C. Seillier and others from the 1970s) in the upper town suggest a fort of 4 ha, confidently dated to the late 1st/early 2nd c., but with a more precise suggested attribution (36) to the reign of Hadrian proposed by W. Dhaeze and P. Monsieur.Footnote 4 This compares with the evidence for the smaller fort, the completed fleet base (1 ha), 22 miles across the Channel at Dover, excavated by B. Philp, which he dated to the reign of Hadrian.Footnote 5 Arguably, on size alone, but supported by inscriptions including those on gravestones of its senior officers, Boulogne was the headquarters of the fleet. The early 2nd c. is the time when we begin to see the extent of the fleet's role through finds of brick and tile stamped CL. BR in southeast Britain, especially associated with iron-making sites in the Weald, as well as across the Channel in Boulogne, while inscriptions on stone attest to the presence of detachments of the fleet on Hadrian's Wall.Footnote 6
With Boulogne listed as the end point of three itineraries, two starting in the Mediterranean, one from the Rhine, the port clearly played a vital role in supporting the cursus publicus and communications with Britain, but how much of a role it played in commercial traffic is more difficult to assess. How does one distinguish the residues of supplies to the garrison of the fort from those of commercial trade? As yet, neither quays nor dumps of traded goods of the kind reported from London have been found.Footnote 7
Two contributions, by W. Dhaeze and P. Monsieur (127–68) and by J. Flahaut with A. Demon and R. Delage (169–95), examine the rich ceramic record from Boulogne and how it changed over time. The town has produced a great variety of imports, including amphorae from an impressive range of sources, as well as sigillatas and even cooking wares (Black Burnished wares) from Britain. Interestingly, these goods were not traded on into the countryside beyond, as is shown by the types of ceramic found in the hinterland to the north of Boulogne. L. Pastor (261–78) notes the absence of mortaria and British Black Burnished 2, and the poor representation and lack of diversity of amphorae, which are almost exclusively of olive-oil-carrying south Spanish Dressel 20 type. So perhaps it is supplies to the fleet, not the results of commercial trade, which we are seeing in the ceramic record at Boulogne, at least until the mid-3rd c. when the fleet appears to have been disbanded.
S. Esmonde Cleary (67–81) highlights the importance of the trade which flowed down the Rhine and across the North Sea to London, but also to Richborough, while M. Reddé returns to the theme of connectivity in his concluding reflections (375–82), where he draws attention to the potential role played by the road network. Assessing the possible roles of different ports engaged in trade and supply between the Continent and Britain between the 1st c. and the mid-3rd c. is very difficult, given the one-sided nature of that trade as visible in the archaeological record: one thinks of the ubiquity of Gallic sigillatas in Britain and, until the mid-2nd c., on the Rhine frontier. However, with the ending of the supply of Lezoux sigillata to the Rhine frontier around the mid-2nd c., it is much more likely, even if it had always been the case, that routes other than via the Rhine played their part in the supply to Britain.
The 2nd-c. British connection evident in the pottery at Boulogne is not mirrored in the sources of rotary querns (meules) found in northwest France analyzed by P. Picavet in his important contribution (243–60). Not even those manufactured just across the Channel at East Wear Bay, Folkestone in the 1st c. BCE/1st c. CE and discussed by Richardson (85–102) have been found in northern France. Even the British distribution is largely limited to east Kent, suggesting that East Wear Bay was perhaps not as important an entrepot as the author suggests (101–2). On the other hand, hand mills of puddingstone from sources either side of the Seine between Rouen and the coast reached southeast Britain in the 1st c. BCE/1st c. CE.Footnote 8 Just as in 1st- and 2nd-c. CE London and military forts across Britain, the dominant source of hand mills in northern France were the Mayen lava quarries in the Eifel Mountains.
For the later Roman period, an important chapter by S. Lelarge and colleagues (105–25) catalogs the vessels of pewter made mainly in southwest Britain and recorded from settlements across northern France. This complements the evidence of the distribution of British Oxfordshire color-coated ware and mortaria and the more common southeast Dorset Black Burnished ware (BB 1) with corresponding evidence of the import of Argonne ware into southeast Britain for demonstrating the degree of interdependence between the economies of southern Britain and northwest France in the later 3rd c. and 4th c. The distribution map of pewter finds (119) recalls those published by this author over 30 years ago, on the basis of the evidence, partly collected earlier by him in 1974, of finds of Romano-British pottery on the Continent, and also of coins of the usurper emperors Carausius and Allectus and later issues minted in London.Footnote 9 It is quite possible that a similar level of connectivity existed earlier, from the Late Iron Age through the first two centuries CE. Then the trade in consumer goods like pottery was, as observed above, one-sided, with large quantities of imports into Britain, such as the Late Iron Age and Early Roman Gallo-Belgic fine wares manufactured in northern France, but any material of British origin an exceedingly rare find across the Channel. It is only by chance, perhaps, that durable British pottery and pewter happen to make these connections – potentially of the longue durée – visible, as they do in Late Antiquity.
However, there may be a connection between the increased militarization along the coast of northwest France, part of the Litus Saxonicum, in the later 3rd c. and 4th c. and the greater incidence of Romano-British pottery exports. The Dorset BB 1 has a strong military association and an extraordinary extended distribution from the south coast to Hadrian's Wall.Footnote 10 Although it is also a common find in civilian settlements, it is doubtful whether it would have been distributed as widely as it was if there had not been an official interest in it, either as regular contribution to army supply or as a means of payment in kind for agricultural goods.Footnote 11 While its distribution across the Channel may be explained in terms of a simple commercial success, its rise to prominence in the later 3rd c. and 4th c. also coincides with social and military developments in northern France.Footnote 12 Reported and discussed here by S. Lelarge (299–315) is the discovery of a 4th- or 5th-c. inhumation cemetery furnished with weapons and military equipment (elements of the cingulum militiae) at Nempont-Saint-Firmin on the estuary of the River Authie between Boulogne and Amiens. Military connections are also evoked by the excavation of a possible temple to Mithras at Marquise between Boulogne and Calais, reported and discussed by J. Maniez and V. Merkenbreack and colleagues (317–34). This find further strengthens the settlement's possible identification with the Marcis or Marcae of the Notitia Dignitatum.
This is an important and stimulating collection of papers which deserves a wide readership on both sides of the Channel; editors and authors deserve our thanks and congratulations.
