No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 26 February 2004
The October issue of PS includes a letter from Neubauer and Zeitlin stating that Bush winning his election in the electoral college without a majority of the popular vote was unprecedented since 1876. I think they are representing the general view of political scientists and, for that matter, most textbooks both in political science and in history. It is a mistake.
The vote for Alabama is customarily shown as in the table below:

That Other would get six electoral votes on the basis of 8,000 popular votes while the Republicans got zero on the basis of 237,000 popular votes and the Democrats got five on the basis of 325,000 popular votes is absurd. Granted that in most tables of the election Alabama is at the top as the first state in the alphabet, it is surprising that this absurdity has not been mentioned in most discussions of the election.
The situation in Alabama was most peculiar. 1960 was the year in which a number of Southern Democrats organized an independent Democratic Party mainly to oppose Kennedy. This party in fact carried Mississippi. Alabama is unusual in that the electors are subject to a primary election. There were two Democratic slates, one pro and one anti Kennedy. In the primary six anti-Kennedy electors won as did five pro-Kennedy.
The Democratic electors favoring Kennedy behaved as electors normally do and sat quietly at home. The anti-Kennedy electors ran a vigorous campaign between the primary and the actual election. In the election itself, 324,000 voters voted for all 11. What they had in mind is not clear but giving all their votes to Kennedy is clearly in error.
They could have been divided between the two candidates in proportion of six to five, or in the proportion shown in the primary. Both of these would have increased Nixon's popular votes and decreased Kennedy's. Granted how close the national popular vote was, allocating as few as 65,000 of them to Nixon rather than Kennedy would have given Nixon a popular plurality.
There are other difficulties in the election. Mississippi had a set of anti-Kennedy electors who won in their election. Like the six “Other” electors from Alabama, they eventually cast their vote for Senator Harry Byrd (Virginia). Once again, it is not obvious whether they favored Kennedy or Nixon. Illinois went for Kennedy by a margin smaller than the usual number of votes produced by the Chicago machine from graveyards and empty lots. Texas went for Kennedy by fewer votes than are normally cast by cattle in South Texas.
Nixon did not ask for a recount, giving as his explanation a set of rather plausible public interest arguments. I think, however, that his knowledge that the ballots were in the possession of the Democratic bosses in both Illinois and Texas and hence a recount would not change things, is more likely the explanation. That, however, is far from certain.
As a final comment, if Nixon thought, as he well might have, that he had won the election and lost the count, it might well have led to his having even less respect for honesty in politics than he already did have. This might have affected his future behavior.