In April 1763 the Swedish botanist Pehr Forsskål was trekking in the isolated hills south of Mount Sudan in Yemen when he came across a flowering balsam tree. After a brief inspection, Forsskål's curiosity must have turned to jubilation. He had discovered the Meccan Balsam, the almost mythical tree mentioned in the Book of Genesis and said to have been given by the Queen of Sheba as a gift to King Solomon, the genus of which had long been a source of controversy among European botanists. Forsskål immediately wrote home to his mentor Linnaeus announcing his discovery. Sadly, however, Forsskål himself was never to see home again. Just over three months later, he died of malaria in the remote Yemeni town of Yarim, aged just thirty-one.
Forsskål's remarkable story, and the story of the Danish-sponsored expedition of which he was a part, is the first of five scientific expeditions to the Near and Middle East undertaken between 1761 and 1881 surveyed by J.M.I. Klaver in this new publication for Oxford University Press's Arcadian Library series. The others – the French naturalists who accompanied Napoleon to Egypt between 1798 and 1801, the Prussian expedition to Arabia and Abyssinia led by Wilhelm Friedrich Hemprich and Christian Gottfried Ehrenberg between 1820 and 1825, and two separate expeditions to the island of Socotra led by the Scottish botanist Isaac Bayley Balfour and the Germans Emil Riebeck and Georg Schweinfurth in 1880 and 1881 – comprise what Klaver terms some of the ‘great scientific expeditions’ of the period. These enterprises are differentiated from previous descriptive accounts of the region's natural history by virtue of the fact that they were large-scale, state-sponsored and ‘performed in the modern framework of Linnaean nomenclature’ (p. 7). Klaver's aims in this book are to assess the scientific importance of these expeditions and to detail the vicissitudes of the naturalists, some of whom – like Forsskål – paid the ultimate price for their research.
The first of these aims Klaver achieves by surveying in detail the scientific work undertaken on each of the five expeditions. In addition to the published results – most of which were produced some years after the original materials were assembled – Klaver draws on surviving collections such as the Herbarium Forsskålii in Copenhagen (reconstructed over a century after Forsskål's death by the botanist Carl Christensen). He also makes use of an impressive amount of private correspondence and personal diaries including a newly discovered journal of the German expedition to Socotra. His final assessment is that due recognition ought to be given to the achievements of these expeditions – more so than has generally been attributed to them in previous accounts. ‘The joint efforts of Forsskål, Geoffroy, Savigny, Delile, Hemprich and Ehrenberg’, argues Klaver, ‘laid the foundation for a modern taxonomical study of the flora and fauna of Egypt, the Red Sea and the Yemen’ (p. 241).
Throughout his account, Klaver is keen to emphasize the lasting importance of these expeditions to the current disciplines of botany and zoology, pointing out where the findings of his protagonists bear relevance to modern scientific research. These observations are detailed with a clarity which will make them accessible to the non-specialist. Moreover, Klaver's fascinating descriptions of the scientific results yielded by the expeditions are richly complemented by some beautifully reproduced illustrations. These include several engravings by Georg Wilhelm Baurenfeind – the draughtsman who accompanied the Danish-sponsored expedition – numerous botanical and zoological illustrations from the Description de l'Egypt and Ehrenberg's Symbol physicae, and a generous selection of the German Socotra journal.
His second aim, Klaver realizes again through his rich use of printed and archival sources. The scientists' first-hand accounts provide a remarkable insight into the many hardships suffered in the course of the expeditions. At points, these verge on the comic, as when Forsskål is dispossessed of everything except his trousers by a band of robbers between Cairo and Alexandria. At others, they are suffused with poignancy, as in Ehrenberg's letter describing the moment at which Hemprich died in his arms of ‘Massawa fever’. The level of detail which these sources provide illuminates personal antagonisms between individual scientists and the difficulties of safely shipping materials back to Europe. One theme which emerges throughout the book is the ways in which the expeditions were entangled with issues of national pride. This is brilliantly illustrated in the case of the Danish-sponsored expedition (which comprised Danes, Swedes and Germans) by Klaver's description of Forsskål's method of encoding genera and species in his letters to Linnaeus in order to conceal his discoveries from ‘the bunglers in Denmark’ (p. 58).
One consequence, however, of Klaver's desire to stress the importance of these expeditions to the development of modern scientific disciplines is that he neglects to clarify the sense in which they were ‘scientific’, or to attempt a definition of what the term ‘scientific’ means in the context of the period covered by the book. This is particularly relevant to the Danish-sponsored expedition. The fact that the purported aim of the journey to Yemen was to answer the questions drawn up by the Hebrew scholar and theologian Johann David Michaelis is detailed by Klaver at some length. However, he never really addresses the question of how this complicates the notion of ‘science’ as a coherent discipline, distinct from theological or philological studies. Although Klaver does point out that Forsskål largely neglected most of Michaelis's questions, when the former is described studying the coralliferous formations of the Red Sea whilst simultaneously speculating on the location of Moses' crossing, the sense in which his pursuits are ‘scientific’ deserves further analysis. Readers of another recent English-language account of the Danish-sponsored expedition – Jonathan Sheehan's The Enlightenment Bible (2005) – may be struck by the extent to which the interpretation of the expedition's findings might differ depending on the concerns of the author. This is likely to be less of a concern, however, with the nineteenth-century expeditions. Neither does it detract from the fascination which the book will undoubtedly hold for historians of science, of exploration and of wider intellectual history alike.
