This is the first full monograph-length study of the history and topography of the Circus Maximus: though of course Humphrey's Roman Circuses (1986) includes over 200 pages on this important monument. Marcattili's main concern is with the religious cults and practices which developed in the Circus Maximus area from the archaic period onwards, the ideological associations which they lent to the monument and the effects of these on its later usage and architectural development. These topics are treated in three major sections, which successively address: (1) the Circus cults and their topography, (2) the architectural development and usage of the Circus up to the end of the Augustan period, and finally (3) its subsequent history under the emperors who followed.
Our archaeological knowledge of the Circus Maximus remains poor, despite excavations in the 1930s and 1980s. M.'s approach, therefore, is to focus chiefly on the analysis of literary texts and surviving visual images. The texts are presented as discussion of each arises, although most are given only in Latin or Greek, with no Italian translation: surely reducing the accessibility, and potential impact, of the book. The visual representations are collected together in a catalogue, grouped according to artistic medium and presented in chronological order within each group. This is an extremely useful resource, which includes a bibliography and commentary for each of the 113 pieces included, and is accompanied by a series of tables showing which elements in the topography of the Circus occur most frequently, both overall and in each different medium. Some of the pictures in the catalogue itself are rather small, but they are supplemented by a series of good-quality close-ups inserted into the main text, which support particular aspects of M.'s discussion.
In general, M. gets good value out of his sources, and is able to put forward some interesting new suggestions about the topography and significance of the Circus Maximus as a result. But I found that I had reservations about some aspects of his approach. Literary references to features in the Circus are liable to be treated as straightforward data, with too little attention paid to issues such as authorial agenda or genre. At its extreme, this results in the reporting, without comment or analysis, of the Historia Augusta's claim that Elagabalus filled the basins of the euripus with wine (220): but a similar approach can be identified throughout. The visual material is better handled, with a sensitive understanding of the varying aims of artists working in different media and for different purposes. But I would still question, for example, M.'s suggestion that a depiction of the aedes Solis as a distyle temple on a late Republican denarius is a precise reflection of its real architectural form (73) rather than a device designed to allow room to depict the deity within.
M. argues from the start that a full understanding of the Circus Maximus can illuminate the history of the entire city of Rome, and this is borne out by the wider implications arising from some of his new ideas. His arguments about the exact position of the underground altar of Consus, for example, potentially have profound consquences for our understanding of the Republican pomerium. On the analogy of other archaeologically-attested underground cult sites, M. argues that this altar was represented above ground by a monopteros visible on several surviving representations of the Circus. If this is correct, and if we assume that Tacitus' beliefs about the course of Romulus' pomerium in this area were influenced by the real course of the Republican boundary, it should mean that the pomerium ran directly along the spina of the Circus until it was extended in a.d. 49. Of course, there are many ‘ifs’ in that argument: but this is true for all debates concerning the pomerium, and M.'s ideas certainly offer new possibilities for thinking about the effects of the boundary in this area. Similarly, M.'s discussion of the arch of Stertinius and its relationship to the route of the triumph allow him to argue that triumphal processions must have passed into and out of the Circus at the Forum Boarium end. This suggestion in turn casts new light on a recently-discovered fragment of the Forma Urbis, on which the road between the eastern edge of the Circus and the Palatine hill is marked in red paint. For M., this designates the triumphal route: again speculation of course, but with interesting potential ramifications for both the ceremony of the triumph and the character of the Severan marble plan.
But M.'s discussion of the triumphal route and its associated rituals rests on an explicitly-stated assumption that both remained rigid and unchanging from the archaic to the high imperial eras. This is very different from Mary Beard's perspective, and although Beard's The Roman Triumph appeared just too late for M. to consult, this general approach to Roman religious ritual has been under challenge from scholars such as Wiseman for some years. Similarly, M.'s interpretations of the religious and cosmic resonances of the Circus are often presented in terms which imply that one coherent set of beliefs about the Circus held general sway in antiquity: again, an approach which has been rigorously challenged by scholars such as Beard, North, Price and Scheid. Ultimately, responses to this book will depend on where individual readers stand in these debates about the character of Roman religion, and the validity of different approaches to it.
