No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 May 2004
From defecation to menstruation, medieval Islamic scholars debated how human biological functions and emissions pollute the performance of core rituals. That normal bodily activities somehow taint the fulfillment of divinely required duties affects how Muslims perceive themselves as earthly creations striving to fulfill Allah's many commands. On any given day, believers repeatedly mitigate expected and unexpected bodily effluents before they execute any mandatory prayer or fast. Because ritual purity is so intimately entwined with basic human experience (and often in tension with it), early scholars argued over what constituted pure and impure acts. A journey into the detailed contours of these debates is the subject of Marion Katz's Body of Text.
Katz skillfully translates the disputes in the Qur

an and the Musannafs of

Abd al-Razzaq al-San

ani, and Ibn Abi Shayba. Chapter 1 scrutinizes Qur

anic statements that link purity regulations regarding for example, menstruation, urination, and sexual intercourse with a burgeoning covenantal community whose ritual obligations connect it with, yet distinguish it from, its Jewish and Christian neighbors. Chapter 2 examines the Musannafs for their varied comments that command, for example, one to wipe one's feet before prayer. Because the majority of scholars favored washing over wiping, Katz posits a privileged “living tradition” that opposed a less popular but more authoritative scriptural exegesis. The Umayyad court's insistence on the performance of minor ablutions from cooked food, or from the touching of one's genitals, to further its political agenda, constitutes Chapter 3. Chapter 4 recounts numerous versions of the Islamic “Fall” story to demonstrate how Adam and Eve's transgression resulted in the transformation of whole, perfected humans into hollow, porous creatures—appetitive on one end; waste producing on the other. This chapter will be of greatest interest to non-specialists. It contains examples and methods that cross disciplines and traditions. In general, Body of Text is aimed at professionals in the field whose detailed knowledge of the early tradition will allow them to appreciate fully Katz's nuanced translations and subtle (re)interpretations of legal sources. Scholars of Islam will also find intriguing the broad-scale attack on the revisionist works of Joseph Schacht, Norman Calder, and John Wansbrough. The generalist interested primarily in the question of purity may wish that more of Katz's polemic had been relegated to the footnotes.
Katz's study is most engaging when it compares Islamic purity laws with those in Zoroastrianism, Rabbinic Judaism, and Christianity. More efforts might demonstrate how an Islamic understanding of purity emerged in the context of sectarian debate. For example, Katz notes how early scholars pondered whether touching one's penis cancels wuḍū

. Both al-Shaybani and

Abd al-Razzaq record traditions stating if you think a part of your body is impure, you should cut it off. These remarks are tantalizingly similar to Jesus's observations that if your hand, foot (a rabbinic euphemism for penis), or eye “causes you to stumble, cut it off” (Mark 9:43–48; Matt. 5:29–30). What might account for the fact that this Christian reference appears in the Islamic context as a sarcastic rebuttal against those “extremists” who view touching the penis differently from fondling the nose? A broader, comparative lens would show that the opinions of Muslim scholars were not created in isolation but articulated within a milieu where such issues were hotly contested by rival monotheists.
While specialists will cherish the meticulous analyses of widely scattered and seldom translated legal materials, both generalists and specialists should take issue with the methodological orientation of this work. Woven throughout each chapter is an ongoing argument with modern anthropologists who argue for a religion's underlying purity “system” or logic. By surveying the range of opinions on whether expelling bile from the mouth is analogous to purging feces from the anus, Katz convincingly argues that early Islamic purity laws may only in part reflect a desire to contain “matter out of place,” or to recover a “loss of bodily control.” Because idiosyncratic concerns had as much to do with shaping the individual opinions of early scholars as anything else, Katz concludes there is no overarching, imagined system of purity that emerged within the documents themselves or was projected back by later scholars attempting to legitimate current practices. While Katz's evidence certainly points to an amalgam of opinions that defy systematization, one often wonders whether the forest is not lost through the trees. What is most profound about Mary Douglas's work is her identification of a universal human need to establish order in the midst of chaos, to catalogue and thus control anomalies that are, at first glance, incomprehensible. Order is established only through a rigorous analysis of marginal substances or questionable acts, which either renders (through analogy) those ambiguities as unambiguous or contains the danger they pose to the system of order through ritual. Without these larger categories in place to structure the world, human action becomes meaningless. Meaning here is not construed in any universal sense but within the constructed worlds of those who defined how order must be separated from chaos. Islamic law, like other religious codes, often operates according to idealized sets of classificatory rules based on divine expectations. The idea that no single operative was in place to separate “pure” from “impure” is somewhat counterintuitive, especially as purity laws became part of one's identity as a Muslim.
It is, of course, easy to fault a book for not doing more. The fact that Body of Text questions established understandings of ritual purity and invites us to continue this discussion of purity beyond the last page underscores the success of the argument. Most significantly, Katz's work broadens our comprehension of what it means to be religious. Religious piety and expression can just as easily be located in debates over the status of semen, farts, and urine as it can in discussions of prayer, pilgrimage, and paradise. Katz's study draws us into a vibrant, lively world where one's body becomes a map through which believers try to navigate the divine will. Katz's focus on the conflicts, debates, and humorous anecdotes about how one can be fully human in a divinely created world allows us to hear voices very much like our own. For its ability to capture the dynamism of these debates over bodily functions, Body of Text represents a breath of fresh air among most traditional studies that engage the history of Islam's formative period.