The editors claim in their preface that this is the first comprehensive textbook on stroke rehabilitation. To a great extent this is true, for although there have been other books on the subject, they have been much narrower in scope and usually written with a target audience in mind. Having undertaken this ambitious endeavor, have the authors succeeded in encapsulating the breath and depth of stroke recovery and rehabilitation?
In terms of breadth of material I would say they have. The chapters follow a chronological path for stroke as a disease and for an individual stroke patient's journey through rehabilitation. The book begins with the history of stroke rehabilitation and the current epidemiology of stroke, and then addresses acute stroke diagnosis and care before coming eventually to the nuts and bolts (in Chapter 7) – the neurophysiology of stroke recovery and rehabilitation, with the subsequent chapters covering specific deficits and syndromes. Following this are the patterns of recovery and models of rehabilitation and training, complications and then, slightly unusually, stroke care systems and stroke in different age groups including children, before returning to the individual's psychosocial and community integration.
The introductory chapters are interesting, especially the history of rehabilitation, but take a very American perspective, perhaps not surprising given that all the editors and most of the authors are from American institutions. The acute stroke chapters are meant to be an overview of current knowledge and are necessarily brief; however, I felt they seemed awkward and incomplete. I wonder whether it is absolutely necessary to have these chapters in a textbook whose main focus is rehabilitation, and which is the main reason people will be buying this book. The neuroimaging chapter covers conventional imaging in stroke but misses the opportunity to cover imaging relevant to rehabilitation research, such as functional MRI and PET scanning, which would have been very exciting. Although some of this is covered elsewhere it is not done so in any great detail.
The chapters on stroke recovery and rehabilitation are, as might be expected, much more expansive and flowing. Concepts such brain mapping and plasticity in stroke recovery are discussed in detail. The chapters on rehabilitation are subdivided according to impairments – for instance, of speech, swallowing, higher function, vision and locomotion – and the pathophysiology and the theories and evidence for rehabilitation are covered for each. Movement is examined in great detail over several chapters, including a chapter dedicated to robotics. A criticism is that sensation is not covered in any detail, though the group of chapters is titled “Sensorimotor impairments”. The following chapters are similarly fulsome in content. On complications following stroke, there are whole chapters on spasticity, bowel and bladder disturbances, mood and shoulder pain. An omission I feel is some mention of post-stroke delirium which does affect a large percentage of stroke patients. The final chapters on community reintegration cover family, vocation, driving and sexuality.
Overall, I found this a satisfying and comfortable book to read, both in terms of text layout, prose and content. Having a summary at the end of most chapters is a nice touch and some chapters have a paragraph detailing research frontiers in that particular area. It would have been an excellent feature if this had been done for all appropriate chapters.
There are shortcomings. The price of trying to cover everything within almost 800 pages has at times been a lack of depth. In some cases this is intended, as in the acute chapters and neuroimaging, but is also seen in the core rehabilitation chapters. The authors admit as much, for instance, in the chapter on neglect, where for the sake of keeping an enormous topic to chapter length, the pathophysiology of all the disorders are not covered as well as some of the rarer syndromes. This being written mainly by American authors, there is an American perspective to the book especially in its terminology, historical aspects and in the description of rehabilitation systems. Yet I would say most of this book is applicable to anyone working with stroke rehabilitation patients. A few illustrations need improvement, being crude and uninformative. I would also quibble over the order of some of the material: for instance, having stroke care systems before individual integration and the inclusion of certain topics in certain sections, e.g. central post-stroke pain in the impairments section rather than in complications. There are omissions and duplication, which are unavoidable, but generally overlapping topics are well cross-referenced to other chapters. One thing I found irritating was that references to evidence often related to other textbooks.
If you are a physician working in the rehabilitation of stroke patients in a combined stroke unit, a stroke rehabilitation unit or a specialist rehabilitation unit, this book still has something new to add to your existing knowledge. It is a book to dip into for information and, although there will be areas you know much more about, there will be others where it will provide welcome information and insights. To the trainee (medical or therapist) who has chosen stroke or neuro-rehabilitation as a specialty, I would wholeheartedly recommend this as an invaluable and standard tome. For the pure academic rehabilitationist, however, I suspect this volume would not be research-orientated enough.
In conclusion, I actually really like this book – it is currently unique in the field of stroke rehabilitation, and I would certainly wish to have a copy on my office shelf.
