The stated aim of this book is to use hydro-mechanical analysis to provide ‘a clearer picture of technical development and achievement and, if possible, evolution of vertical-wheeled Roman water-mills’. It is focused mainly on the development of water wheel technology with minor emphasis on the implications of that development for Roman culture. It is a highly technical work that will be accessible to a relatively specialized group, so this review attempts to summarize the methodology and conclusions for a broader audience.
The first section explains the issues involved in hydro-mechanical analysis. Some of the variables necessary to make the calculations are not known, so the author recreated a disk-type mill wheel in order to establish reasonable assumptions for the power necessary to overcome friction from the grindstones, gearing, and rotation of the wheel axel. The second section is a catalogue of twenty-seven mills, providing the basic archaeological information and a hydro-mechanical analysis of each one. It is not meant to be a complete listing of all known vertical-wheeled mills, but only those with enough archaeological data to make the analyses possible. The entries are accompanied by nice reconstruction drawings illustrating how each mill worked.
In the last section the author uses the technical data established in the previous section to evaluate the efficiency of the Roman mills. Taking eight examples for which there were enough data to make a reasonable calculation, he came up with efficiency ratings in the range of 28–44 per cent. He notes that ratings as high as 65–70 per cent have been cited for overshot wheels but these are based on modern wheels, which have larger diameters than Roman ones (e.g., the Barbegal wheels are only 2.1 m). He goes on to explore why the Romans used such small wheels.
A key distinction he makes is between weight-driven wheels and impulse-driven wheels. The weight-driven wheels have built-in buckets to collect water that acts as weight to rotate the wheel whereas the impulse-driven wheels have paddles hit by a stream of water that propels the wheel. He then focuses on two phenomena that illustrate why impulse wheels were potentially more efficient. The first is that for impulse wheels the same force of water jet applied to a larger wheel will produce more torque than on a smaller one but the smaller wheel will rotate faster. Since the rotational speed of the wheel is what governs the rotational speed of the millstone (via gears), a lower gear ratio can be used to achieve the same output, and the greater the rotational speed of the millstones, the more grain ground. Moreover, the smaller wheel is lighter, has less bearing resistance, and is less costly to build. The second phenomenon is that if water flow rate (m3/m) is constant but the velocity (m/sec) of the water is doubled then the power is quadrupled (like putting your finger over the end of a hose to make it squirt further). The two phenomena taken together mean that smaller wheels combined with accelerated head races to increase the water velocity could grind more grain with the same amount of water. As an example of technological advancement, he cites the mill at the Baths of Caracalla where the first version was later altered to include a higher head and faster wheels.
The author proposes an evolutionary model in which the Romans learned to build more efficient vertical impulse wheels using the phenomena set forth above and then translated these principles into a horizontal wheel, which by definition is impulse driven and does not require gearing to change the axis of rotation. Thus he sees a progression by which man learns empirically the critical factors governing power generation and then uses them to create a simpler form, as opposed to the evolutionary model that sees the simpler non-geared horizontal wheel as the progenitor of the more complex geared vertical wheel. Finally he addresses Michael Lewis's proposal in Millstone and Hammer: The Origins of Water Power (1997) that both the vertical and the horizontal wheels were developed at roughly the same time in different places during mid-third century b.c. He attempts to reconcile his proposal with Lewis's by noting the possibility of regression, i.e. that the horizontal water wheel was known but then lost only to be rediscovered again later.
To my mind this latter theoretical investigation, which lacks solid evidence one way or the other, is less useful than the mechanical results of the study, which provide insight into the factors governing the choices of mill engineers. Though not an easy read, this study establishes the methodological groundwork for evaluating mill technology that could ultimately be used to explore broader issues of the relationships between food production, technological development, and the Roman economy.
